5 ms·
As said in the previous writeups, the only really conclusive test is "Don't eat wheat for 3 weeks, then pig out for a meal. You'll know a few hours after that."
by jerf 16y ago
As said in the previous writeups, the only really conclusive test is "Don't eat wheat for 3 weeks, then pig out for a meal. You'll know a few hours after that."
This isn't just experience speaking (though it is, my father was at best marginal according to the biopsy but it's definitely celiac based on this test), but also the best current medical research. Biopsies can have problems where they hit a normal stretch of intestine, even though large chunks of it are affected. Quite a bit of research remains focused on just the best way to diagnose Celiac, which is usually not the hard part of a disease, at least after several years of research. :)
If that doesn't definitively make you sick on the pig-out day, it isn't Celiac. Small improvements during those three weeks are modestly positive signs but not really definitive. (In my experience they were mostly within "placebo" range, but how sick I got after my last pizza was not.)
- savemylife 16y agoThanks, that's reassuring. The doctor said pretty much the same thing regarding not hitting the right patch of intestine with the biopsy. She also said I was a difficult patient and did not tolerate the procedure well, so she couldn't do as thorough an exploration as she would have liked (though this was mostly the colonoscopy, not the endo). In fact I recall screaming a few choice words at her during the procedure because I was in such pain. She said that I should ask for full anesthesia rather than just twilight if I ever repeat these tests. I'm prepared to stick to this diet for 3-4 months or so before giving up.
- jerf 16y ago"I'm prepared to stick to this diet for 3-4 months or so before giving up." The goal here is to determine if you have the disease, not to live as if you do. If you have the disease, then proceed to the part where you live as if you have it. :) This is especially true if it turns out this isn't it! You really only want to pursue one avenue at a time so you don't get interference, and you don't want to tie yourself up for 3 extra months for no gain.
- savemylife 16y agoYes, but if it takes a few months to start to feel better (improvement takes weeks-to-months, not days, right?), then it seems like I need to give it a good 3-4 months to test that out. Especially since it's hard to be truly eliminate all sources of wheat for a newbie. I want to give this a really good try, and then if I'm not better in that time period, I can check celiac/gluten off the list of potential causes. Believe me, I'm not excited about having to give up pizza and beer. :-) I think I'm actually in agreement with you here insofar as I'm trying to pursue one thing at a time, and not go crazy trying 5 other treatments simultaneously. I just don't want to have the Celiac issue crop up 2 years from now and wonder if I really gave it a good enough try.
- grandalf 16y agoI'm curious if you could post about your diet and exercise habits...
- savemylife 16y agoSure. Prior to the Celiac possibility, I did not eat that well. Lots of prepared (Healthy Choice/Lean Cuisine) frozen meals. Not exactly fast-food, but certainly not cooking. I weigh about 155 at the moment, which is down from 180 a year ago, thanks partially to Weight Watchers, and partially to the gluten-free diet. I'm small, so an ideal weight for me is probably around 135/140. Now that I am (temporarily, at least) gluten-free, I'm eating more healthily than I ever have in my life. Lean meats/fish and fresh veggies just about every meal. Some rice and potatoes here and there. My snacks are small amounts of fruits and nuts. I do allow myself some ice cream (after carefully scanning the labels for gluten). Currently I walk about 3 miles more or less daily. In the past I went through various phases where I ran 3-4 miles daily (often twice daily). However physical exertion really makes me feel worse sometimes, so it's very hard to stick with it. It's not the "good" pain that comes with solid exercise (I'm familiar with that). It's more like my head feeling like it's going to explode, feeling incredibly dizzy and being totally useless the rest of the day.
- 16y ago
- carbocation 16y agoSince you're invoking the "best current medical research," can you cite the evidence that says that wheat-deprivation-followed-by-a-giant-wheat-meal is more sensitive and/or specific than duodenal biopsy for Celiac? Since you skip around this detail, what is the telltale sign that occurs a few hours after the meal? I ask because (1) I am inclined to doubt that this is true, but (2) the guidelines always lag the latest evidence, so if it is true then it wouldn't be in the guidelines anyways.
- CapitalistCartr 16y ago" . . . the telltale sign that occurs a few hours after the meal" I can answer this one. It ain't 'telltale signs'. It's miserable hell. Imagine eating some bad food. The effects are far from subtle.
- carbocation 16y agoThanks. So that one could reproducibly identify this, can you be more specific? For example, is it diarrhea? Cramping pain? Other?
- jvdh 16y agoSecond hand evidence, but what I've heard is that you'll know pretty quickly whether you have a response or not. Cramping pain, nausea, diarrhea, feeling miserable, you name it. And this was just from eating a small treat, not even a full meal. So if you want to know for certain, follow the diet for some time, and then feast on gluten.
- carbocation 16y agoThanks. Hopefully jerf can provide some citations for the diagnostic utility of this. It doesn't sound promising, honestly.
- joshkaufman 16y agoHere's what happens to me: when I eat gluten, I'm exhausted within a few hours, then for ~2 days after. I also have clear GI symptoms - bleeding, mucus, etc. (I've heard that exact symptoms vary, based on your personal level of gluten sensitivity - it's a spectrum.) When I eliminated gluten for 4 weeks, I felt much better - normal energy, no GI symptoms. Then I reintroduced a little - breaded ahi tuna on a salad for lunch. Within 2 hours, I was exhausted, and I was absolutely worthless for the next two days. My doctor did a Celiac blood test - it came back negative on 2 tests, and positive on the 3rd. I'm waiting on the results of a genetic profile, but my MDs said my self-experimentation is the clearest signal, and to stay gluten free regardless of what the tests indicate.
- ABrandt 16y agoMany Celiac patients are asymptomatic. Would this pig out test still be conclusive?
- jerf 16y agoImagine that something is dribbling fuel for a fire into a container. This is your intestines natural healing process. Then, every time you eat, someone tries to catch the fuel on fire. A untreated celiac patient's intestines don't "catch fire" with every meal with gluten in it, because there isn't always even enough fuel to light a fire. Waiting three weeks lets enough metaphorical fuel build up to catch on metaphorical fire. (This metaphor isn't perfect but should demonstrate the point.) Three weeks is even a bit generous; two is frequently recommended. If you can go without gluten for three weeks, then freely eat gluten again, it is almost certainly not celiac. Or it's very, very weak, and can't be wrecking your life like savemylife's.
- whirlycott1 16y agoThis is absolutely wrong. My father has DH, my aunt is celiac and my wife has a gluten allergy. My next door neighbor died earlier this year from problems relating to his inability to handle his celiac diet properly. I say this only to note that I have a lot of exposure to gluten related problems in my life. In many people, my father for instance, gluten problems don't manifest themselves until much later in life, sometimes out of the blue, seemingly unprovoked. While what you suggest may yield some cluees, only a fool would follow your advice about this being definitive (your words).
- savemylife 16y agoI don't think jerf meant that individuals who test positive (via serum or biopsy) should try a gluten-challenge, and then rule out Celiac based on not having a reaction. I think rather he meant that those who test negative on the standard tests should try the gluten-challenge, and if they show no reaction, they should move on and look elsewhere for a solution. Not meaning to put words into his mouth, but that's what I took away from it. Sorry to hear about your neighbor. I've wondered lately how many people actually die from Celiac, either directly, from complications, or via suicide due to lack-of-diagnosis. I bet the suicide numbers are pretty high.
- whirlycott1 16y agoThe problem with my neighbor was that he was an old (75 or so) stubborn WWII veteran who didn't recognize that he had a problem earlier on until he landed in the hospital and had almost no intestine left. He almost died there since there was a lot of internal bleeding and still, in the US anyway, Celiac isn't well understood by all doctors. He had to change to a gluten-free diet, but basically he couldn't figure out how to eat since everything he ate for his life had gluten in it. This was more of an education and class issue than anything, in my view. Later on in life, he just got more and more depressed about his situation and eventually died just a few days after he broke his hip in hospital while there getting treatment for internal bleeding caused by his Celiac. His family said at that point he had lost his will to live and simply gave up.