6 ms·
Google is very concerned about ads that visually block text content. But somehow forcing ads in front of videos on YouTube isn't the same exact thing? Both fo
by tyingq 9y ago
Google is very concerned about ads that visually block text content. But somehow forcing ads in front of videos on YouTube isn't the same exact thing?
Both force an ad to be looked at before granting you access to the content you came for. I don't get the distinction.
- sokoloff 9y agoGoogle owns one of them, so there's that distinction...
- matt4077 9y agoHave you ever seen the little "x" in the corner of google display ads? If you click it, you're asked for the reason you're objecting to the ad. Among them "ad covers content". Meaning: you shouldn't always assume the worst, especially if there's evidence against it.
- Pxtl 9y agoAt least I don't have to play a hidden object adventure game to find the close button for YouTube ads.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThis is only really because you're already aware of where YouTube's buttons are and how they work. If you visited any given other website often enough, it'd be more or less the same.
- theWatcher37 9y agoDoes this apply to twitters full-page sign up pop up?
- Animats 9y agoTo deal with that, right click on "Inspect element", mouse upwards until the whole popup is selected, and click "Delete Node".
- akoncius 9y agothis solution is absurd, do you understand?
- Animats 9y agoIt works. You can get rid of many annoying pop-ups and overlays that way. It even works on dumber paywalls.
- KGIII 9y agoTrue, but it isn't very practical and doesn't actually answer the question. It does work, however.
- akoncius 9y agogiven that it's not automatic and it doesn't work on mobile or for people who have no experience in html, it doesn't work and it should not be even considered as a solution, because internet is not for tech-savy people and this discussion is about marketing and internet advertisement which is for all people. so no, it doesn't work on a larger scale. it's like suggesting to hack MS Windows checks if provided licence key is valid in order to use OS. It works, but for narrow audience, and we should discuss about how to solve issue for all users.
- dredmorbius 9y agoFor desktop. Not mobile. (I had, at one point, some 2,000 or so personally modified wepage CSS files under Stylish for just this sort of crap.)
- mikewhy 9y agoNot to defend the ad industry, but I don't think these are equivalent. YouTube ads don't block content so much as they delay it, much like inline ads. The equivalent YouTube ad would be if it started playing and didn't pause the video you're trying to watch.
- tyingq 9y agoNot sure I understand. Both are an overlay blocking content. I suspect Google would still punish an interstitial overlay with a countdown timer that dismissed it. If you don't click, YouTube sometimes makes you watch 30+ seconds of ads. Here's Google's post about it: https://webmasters.googleblog.com/2016/08/helping-users-easily-access-content-on.html https://webmasters.googleblog.com/2016/08/helping-users-easi...
- vertex-four 9y agoI've seen a couple of five minute long ads on Youtube. I really doubt anyone intentionally watches them.
- charrondev 9y agoTo be honest I've seen a couple advertisements that I watched the full ~5 minutes. Both were game trailers that were really interesting. I would have rather had a "click here to view the actual trailer video instead of the ad version" button though. I was sold after the first 2 minutes, but couldn't see the full name of the game until the end.
- dlp211 9y agoIt could have to do with the fact that video and text articles are different mediums.
- tyingq 9y agoI'll bite. Visually blocking text vs video. Either requires a click (or long wait) to get to the content. What is different? In fact, there's often less waiting with overlays on top of text content.
- dlp211 9y agoThe difference is how advertising has been done traditionally. Think about TV vs. print. Advertisements need to be interspersed in both mediums, but how it is accomplished is different based on the medium. Why would it be different just because we now consume both on a different platform?
- nathcd 9y agoMaybe Google Search is punishing search scores for YouTube videos because of ads, but since most online videos exist only on YouTube, those results generally still rank highly regardless of the penalty?
- drawnwren 9y agoI think the difference is the potential for abuse. It's not possible for a YouTube advertiser to make a YouTube ad appear to be a system popup or for it to attempt to take over my browser experience by full screening. Keep in mind, Google has been fine with popup ads until 2017.
- woranl 9y agoDo as I say, not as I do.
- woranl 9y agoI say non-skippable YouTube video ads are more annoying and affect more people. Go punish yourself Google. Pathetic.
- synicalx 9y agoI suppose it's a matter of practicality - with most text heavy sites you can put ads around the text and it works just fine. But with something like Youtube, that approach isn't really going to be as effective because people generally won't be scrolling around the page.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]