3 ms·
The scheme was designed in 1935 as a way of identifying people enrolled in the then-new Social Security program (hence the name), and was gradually made a de fa
by throwanem 9y ago
The scheme was designed in 1935 as a way of identifying people enrolled in the then-new Social Security program (hence the name), and was gradually made a de facto national ID number over the intervening decades as the increasing scale of national population and economic activity prompted a desire for greater legibility to facilitate management and taxation.
Greater legibility, management, and taxation are values not shared by a very sizable section of the US citizenry. Without digressing into a pointless and stupid flamewar over Humean oughts around these points of fact, we can acknowledge that every attempt thus far to implement a national ID scheme has been, and no doubt any future such attempt will be, energetically and, thus far at least, very effectively countered by those who so strongly prefer that no national ID scheme exist. Unfortunately, the US federal bureaucracy being what it is, we will have a national ID scheme whether well-designed as such or otherwise, and the wide adoption of Social Security and (generally) 1:1 mapping between SSNs and citizens made it the obvious candidate for a de facto national ID. Businesses followed government in adopting it as such.
Now, instead of a proper, admitted national identification scheme which would at least have a chance of being marginally secure, we have a motley collection of the world's most hilariously shitty zero-factor authentication methods, making a wide variety of frauds so trivially simple to perform that we've had to spin them off into a new category of their own, "identity theft", which we regard as just one of those unfortunate things that happens sometimes, like cancer. Even after the Equifax breach, it'll
probably still be cheaper to continue looking at the problem this way than to roll back the eight decades of technical debt that have gone into creating it. So it goes.
- codeulike 9y agoThe UK is also heavily resistant to any sort of national ID scheme, and so National Insurance numbers (our equiv of SSN) are also a sortof proxy ID for people in work etc. But the difference is we don't pretend they are secret. In other words: we use it as a primary key, but we don't assume its a shared secret.
- umanwizard 9y agoSo let's say you want to apply for a bank loan or credit card online, or look up information about yourself on a government website - how do you prove you're you? Or is this simply not possible in the UK without visiting a bank branch etc.?
- sanbor 9y agoHere in Argentina you sign the docs and write your name and in case of problems they'll analyze the signature and handwriting.
- codeulike 9y agoYou usually end up sending copies of your passport and proof of address (eg utility bill) by post. Sometimes the copies have to be certified by a lawyer/solicitor, to prove they are true copies of the original document
- pas 9y agoUse SSN for identity, but use a shared secret as authorization to use that identity. Get SSN, name, place and time of birth, and birth name of mother. In theory 1 SSN maps to 1 (name, place and time of birth + mother's name) tuple, unless you have a twin and you are both called John. (Also, identity verification should could also use biometric data.) Banks already issue PINs to users, they should issue one for regular non-ATM interaction too.
- freeone3000 9y agoSSNs of people before 2011 contain place of birth as the first five digits, with the last four digits assigned sequentially. Your method provides no additional security.
- pas 9y ago??? I simply argued that SSN is not security. It's at best identity. But it's a lousy one at that too, because it's hard to check and easy to fake. (You can fake the paper you get from the Social Security Admin easier than you can fake all the other pieces mentioned.) SSN is just dumb because it's a direct function of the mentioned attributes plus a counter, that nobody can really check. (No one can distinguish identical twins based on their claimed SSN.)
- Spooky23 9y agoWhat problem does a national ID solve that a driver's license with linkage to a birth certificate and photo database with facial recognition will not? Identity theft is about the regulatory environment. Banks are allowed to quickly vet credit customers, and consumers hold the bag for cleaning up the mess.