3 ms·
I think we're mixing two different purposes here. Authentication through knowledge of a SSN is an absurd practice, and is a non problem in countries which have
by cm2187 9y ago
I think we're mixing two different purposes here.
Authentication through knowledge of a SSN is an absurd practice, and is a non problem in countries which have a national ID card scheme. Introducing ID cards would be my obvious response to this leak. Not re-issuing SSN until the next major leak.
Having a universal unique identifier for every individual across systems is a different matter and I am not convinced this is even desirable. In a world where no organisation is able to protect its data (or even willing since most organisations now are looking for ways to monetize it), this is making it too easy to link an identity across breaches. I don't think your utility companies have any need to know your SSN.
- thirtyseven 9y agoFor the purposes of fraud, it's fairly easy to link accounts across datasets even without a unique key like SSN. You can just guess based on name and address or something and if you're only right 90% of the time that's still a pretty big win.
- cm2187 9y agoPeople move home, particularly in the US which has a quite mobile population. Many people have many variants of their names, including middle names or long composed last names, and you have a huge number of homonyms. So while you may get a 90% hit rate on two, perfectly current, and breached at the same time datasets, I would expect that number to reduce greatly in a typical real world breach.
- vilmosi 9y agoYou would be surprised how difficult that problem is.
- newman8r 9y agoperhaps allowing tokens/passwords to be established for existing SSNs would be an alternative to national IDs. You could even create a separate token each time you needed to supply the SSN, so that if it's ever leaked, the source of the leak could be investigated.
- cm2187 9y agoAnd the social security system would become the paypal of identity. I don't know if they want that. But an ID card is exactly that. It is a time limited, physical token issued by the state that identifies you to third parties. You could make it more secure with public-private key cryptography, by signing the information on the card, including the photo, such that forgery would become impossible (under 21 kids would hate that).
- yxhuvud 9y agoHaving a unique identifier is separate from being able to use it to identify as the holder of that identifier. Yes, having it may simplify tracking, but tracking is a hell of a lot lesser problem compared to identity theft.
- alkonaut 9y agoHave a unique public identifier for everyone. An identifier is not a verifier. Just because I know my neighbors id number doesn't mean I can e.g open a bank account in his name. The act of validating that you are the person with the given ID requires some form of id validation (drivers license, passport, digital id). I can't even understand how you even keep a reliable customer database that works through name and address changes without having a single immutable identifier for everyone. I can understand how people started using SSN if that is the only number there is. Here I just record bob the customer as 123467890 and he can change name, address etc all he wants without telling me. I can still send him his bill because I can lookup both a name and address for any id at any point in time by just asking the tax- (and id-) authority for the details for that national id number. If my customer db is leaked it's considered "bad" but it's not disastrous. All those addresses/names/ids were mostly public anyway (there could be protected identities etc so one shouldn't assume all is public)
- cm2187 9y agoYou call it public, I call it universal. We are talking about the same thing.
- alkonaut 9y agoRight: universal (everyone has one) and merely an id, not a secret used for verification. An important thing is to keep a 2fa tied to each id. An address works, because then mail can be used as 2fa.