4 ms·
It isn't that uncommon for bad ideas to take root and influence decision making. And I'd say the core thesis of the article is that a bad idea has taken root ('
by roenxi 9y ago
It isn't that uncommon for bad ideas to take root and influence decision making. And I'd say the core thesis of the article is that a bad idea has taken root ('inconsistencies and gaps in the accusation can be ignored because rape is terrible').
That doesn't seem interesting to me. But what is fascinating is considering the difficulties that have to be worked through to organise a rational argument in favour, essentially, of tightening the standards applied to potential rape victims.
I'll show my colours and say that after the James Damore business, it wouldn't be a shock if the university fired anyone who made the arguments in this article couched in anything but the most mild terms.
- bobdole1234 9y agoAnyone daft enough to write manifestos about something as sensitive as the standards of proof for rape is grinding an axe to cause a reaction.
- DanBC 9y agoChed Evans is a UK football player convicted of rape and then found not guilty on appeal. There was a lot written about the case, particularly because the appeal relied on questioning the accuser about her sexual history. Some lawyers have written about the importance of protecting victims from abusive questioning, while also protecting alleged offenders from miscarriages of justice. Those barristers and solicitors aren't grinding axes, they're trying to educate an ignorant public. (In this case they had to correct the mistaken impression that "not guilty" is the same as "innocent".) (I upvoted your comment because I agree that people writing manifestos about rape tend to be grinding axes.)