3 ms·
Interesting. Search engine providers who are also advertisers have a agent problem -- there is moral hazard. Anybody who has money betting on where an item sho
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
Interesting.
Search engine providers who are also advertisers have a agent problem -- there is moral hazard. Anybody who has money betting on where an item shows up in a result list should not also be able to create the list. This is like going to the Ford car dealership and asking for an analysis of all the types of cars to buy. Even if the Ford guys give you an independently-created report recognized as the world's best authority on car purchases, it doesn't feel right. In ethics, if it looks wrong, it is wrong.
Having said that, regulating anything that returns a list is idiotic. Even regulating Google because of it's gatekeeper status doesn't work -- these things always sound good for the edge cases, but once you let the camel's nose in under the tent, the rest of the camel is soon to follow
I think what's called for here is an industry-sponsored certification program. Use outside auditors, establish quality metrics, create a set of public ethical guidelines. You can always have trusted outsiders check your work against those guidelines, even in IP-rich, and trade secret areas. Companies do this all the time.
Google's (and Microsoft before it) main problem is that it is successful. Lots of political-type folks see that success and imagine all sorts of ways that the government can/should get in there and muck around. In this case I'm on Google's side.
But as far as thinking Google is somehow magic, that SEO is evil, that "writing good content" is all you need for rankings? All of that is bullshit put out by Google to make themselves more of an authority than they actually are. They run a program to put things in an ordered list. People are going to hack the program. Neither of these two things are good, bad, or especially interesting. The interesting thing here, to me, is the degree of Google fanboy-ism that some folks have. Wish I could bottle that up.
Google is just an advertising agency who had some cool ideas on ranking a decade or more ago. They are not a bunch of knights riding in on white horses. Oddly enough, their success is the very thing that's hurting them.