7 ms·
In Sweden your social security number is public information. What's the reason for it being private in the US? Sounds like a horrible thing to rely on for secur
by Kiro 9y ago
In Sweden your social security number is public information. What's the reason for it being private in the US? Sounds like a horrible thing to rely on for security anyway.
- mmagin 9y agoThe banking industry decided to, in effect, use it as an authentication token. Even though it was stated that it should not be used for such.
- Terr_ 9y agoAnd then, when their shitty "easy signups" authentication is exploited, they attempt to reframe the flaw as the individual's identity being stolen, rather than the bank being negligent. Relevant comedy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E
- unit91 9y agoIn the US, a combination of personal information is taken by most as proof that you are who you claim to be. If you know enough of someone else's information, you can steal money rather easily. We need a better identity solution, but it's what we have right now.
- literallycancer 9y agoThere is probably no way to make that work, without improving the security. Same thing with credit cards, is it so hard to ask for a PIN when trying to pay with them? Or use 2FA like in any internet banking? For what it's worth, here in Europe you could pretend to be someone else as well, if you have enough information, but what's the point when you can't touch their money?
- quuquuquu 9y agoWhat do you mean by, "you can't touch their money"? You can spoof their identity, to instantly acquire material goods / lines of credit. And, if you are extremely persistent, you can spoof identity documents and hack bank accounts.
- literallycancer 9y ago>What do you mean by, "you can't touch their money"? If you had the number of my credit card, my account number, my social security number (or the local equivalent), my address or my name, or whatever else, short of my 2FA device and my internet banking credentials, you won't be able to steal anything. (And at that point, you might as well walk up to my house, break a window and steal whatever the hell you need while I'm somewhere else, why bother with hacking.) If the 2FA device is just a phone, there's a few things you can do, otherwise not really. Are you going to deploy a fake cell tower to steal the code? Probably just conning the cell company support person would be good enough. Not sure whether they'd mail a new SIM to a different address (and they'd probably let me know). Maybe they'd give it to you if you presented an ID. You could have a fake one made, I guess. It would be a bit weird if you didn't speak the local language though. Quite a lot of effort compared to copy pasting a credit card number. Not something you'd do on a large scale. >And, if you are extremely persistent, you can spoof identity documents and hack bank accounts. Yes, but against a determined attacker that singles you out, you are fucked regardless of what you do, especially if it's your bank or similar service provider that screws up even if you don't.
- foota 9y agoYou seem to have jumped over the question of identity theft for applying for lines of credit. I believe this is what most people are concerned about.
- EGreg 9y agoIt should be simple: When applying for new accounts, or logging in from new devices, you should be receiving an email and/or sms on the endpoints of your choice. And then able to stop those things from happening.
- Kluny 9y ago> Or use 2FA like in any internet banking? That's the funny part - there's no 2fa available for most internet banking in Canada or the US. In Denmark we get the NemID card mailed to us, but in Canada it's just your card number+password+sometimes they ask a security question like "what high school did you go to?"
- onebigbug 9y agoThe whole situation is reasonably well explained by CGP Grey's video on Social Security Cards https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus
- alephnil 9y agoIt is not only the US that is like that. Also in Norway it is considered a secret, and you can get a worrying amount of information about someone just by having their social security number. My guess that this is misguided and muddled security thinking behind this, and is something that happens when the involved institutions do not have a coherent understanding of information security.
- boxfire 9y agoTo me the fact that the data was hacked represents no real change, as I've viewed the organizations that had access to this information just as adversarial as the crooks who stole it. At least now anybody can pay the price to see, and that means there is no corporate monopoly on the data about us. It's time to face the world of open data and structure ourselves so that it is to our advantage.
- Avshalom 9y agoWell I mean, what it comes down to is you need someway of establing that it's actually you over a phone or Internet and you can assume that an equifax-equivalent would be storing that info regardless of exactly what it is in Sweden.
- literallycancer 9y ago>Well I mean, what it comes down to is you need someway of establing that it's actually you over a phone or Internet Why do you need that exactly? If you are selling something, it's quite simple: if you receive the money, you provide the service -- if not, you don't. The payment processor can use 2FA (this is actually done by a number of banks in Europe, when you enter the payment information, you get a text message with a code from your bank to confirm the transaction).
- tonyztan 9y ago> The payment processor can use 2FA (this is actually done by a number of banks in Europe, when you enter the payment information, you get a text message with a code from your bank to confirm the transaction). I think 3-D Secure is the protocol they use. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3-D_Secure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3-D_Secure
- Kiro 9y agoIn Sweden you use a special authentication method you install on your phone through your bank to prove your identity. It's basically a national 2FA. So when you for example declare your taxes you enter your social security number and authenticate the action with your phone each time. So no, I don't think there's any Equifax equivalent where a data leakage would enable stuff like this.
- Avshalom 9y agoHow does the bank know it is you or your phone when you open an account?
- 9y ago
- watersb 9y agoID == Authentication Error When I got my first driver's license in Georgia USA, 1986, the license number was my SSN. Every system used it to identify you: banks, doctors... But things started to get weird. As other have already commented, everyone got confused, and let "Identity" = "Authorization". Perhaps in a world of paper records, this system would have been ok. But always more transactions from remote locations. Many stores required you to write the last four digits of SSN on checks, or credit card slips, because they had no way of authorizing the transaction with your bank. Large vendors had these little modems that could dial up and talk to your bank, but small shops only had paper. Anyway, it was in the banks' interest to roll out Point-Of-Sale transaction tech, because USA banking laws committed the bank to pay the vendor. But fraud increased as the tech got faster. Someone noted that Social Security, by explicit law, cannot be used as ID in any situation that is not directly involving a Social Security pension or insurance. The banks and medical systems rolled a lot of the shift away from SSN under their huge Y2K projects. Here we are. Now they all ask for other publicly-available personal information, and still confuse ID with Auth.
- djsumdog 9y agoThe social security cards here use to say "Not for identification." Then the IRS started using it as a Tax ID instead of creating their own (my Tax IDs in Australia and NZ, two places I had work visas for, were public as well). Most countries have some type of citizen identification number, which is attached to some ID with a photo and/or finger prints. The US does not, and the political climate for the past several decades would probably never allow this. The Real ID act has been seen as a sign of the beast by religious fundamentalist and a basic erosion of rights by libertarians et. al. Passport numbers can't be used either because not all US citizens/residents have a passport and the numbers change when you renew them. Most parents get a SSN for their child at birth. Even people I know with dual citizenship overseas have them (all except for one, and you don't really need one unless you want to go to America to work .. and then you'll also need to pay an immigration/tax lawyer to go back and reconcile all your taxes). Here's a great video on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus
- usr1106 9y agoYes, it kind of is public, because you have to use it in many contexts. But knowing a persons name and social security number allows you to do all kind of misuse, i. e. identity theft. I have not lived in Sweden for 30 years, but I assume many things still work similar as here in Finland. Closing other people's credit cards and mobile phone subscriptions typically works by knowing the social security number. Ordering online without credit card and paying the bill (or not) after delivery, too.