4 ms·
This isn't a very rigorous test, and TC's assertion that this may be random is probably untrue given that the results seem to be consistent if you enter the sam
by fastball 9y ago
This isn't a very rigorous test, and TC's assertion that this may be random is probably untrue given that the results seem to be consistent if you enter the same details multiple times. The idea that Equifax has implemented a random yet deterministic checking system seems beyond the pail of belief.
If I had to guess, I would say that Equifax is not checking against a list of people that they know are compromised, but rather against a list that they know have NOT been compromised. So if you check a name, and it is in Equifax's database AND it is known to be uncompromised, you get back a "you are safe message". For everyone else they give a generic "you maybe were effected", emphasis on the "maybe".
Obviously a fictional person with fictional details is not going to be in Equifax's database, so they would just throw the generic maybe message.
- sulam 9y agoI have 5 and 7 yr old girls. To the degree that either exists with respect to the finance industry, they both exist. Neither has credit, obviously, or any interactions with a credit agency. The only people who have their SSNs are the federal government and our health care provider, which has some very strict laws about what they can do with _any_ data they have. Equifax says the 7-yr old "may" have been affected. The 5 yr old comes back clean. This sure looks scammy.
- ams6110 9y agoSadly, "very strict laws" don't have much ability to prevent data breaches due to zero-days or simple incompetence.
- sulam 9y agoSure, but they didn't give data to a credit agency. That would require consent, and even if you assume they ignored HIPAA, if they'd done it for one daughter they'd have done it for both.
- malnourish 9y agoI came back clean.
- belovedeagle 9y agoYour conclusion is entirely unfounded. Returning the same result for the same input does not in any way refute the claim that it's random. It could just as well seed the RNG with the input or any number of other implementations.
- fastball 9y agoMy conclusion fits the facts just as well as TC's does, and my conclusion seems more believable to me.