3 ms·
I don't think the author was claiming to be the first to recognize this situation, but as you've noted there is very little published work on it. A lot of scien
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I don't think the author was claiming to be the first to recognize this situation, but as you've noted there is very little published work on it. A lot of science is like this, in that there is an effect or behavior that several people have noted over the years, but no one has sat down and tried to analyze it.
In the case of Ralston-Saul, they speculated that the ants were 'thinking about what to do next'. It is an interesting hypothesis, but untested. In the paper the authors removed 20% of the idle ants and observed they were not replaced. There was also no mention of the activities of the hive slowing down. I think it would be a fair argument that if the ants were 'thinking' then removing ants would slow down their execution. But given that it doesn't, then the hypothesis that they are is probably incorrect.
So we have an observation and a hypothesis in 1994 but no science. Going back and testing those observations helps us learn what is really going on and "know" with more certainly what isn't.
So perhaps it would be better to call it new research on previously speculated about behaviors.