5 ms·
Yes. Why would you doubt it? (i.e. why would you doubt that I'm seriously suggesting it, not why would you doubt that what I am suggesting has merit) (Oh, an
by lisper 9y ago
Yes. Why would you doubt it? (i.e. why would you doubt that I'm seriously suggesting it, not why would you doubt that what I am suggesting has merit)
(Oh, and BTW, before you completely dismiss the idea that my suggestion might have merit, you might want to look me up. I didn't just fall off the turnip truck.)
- zebraflask 9y agoI am intrigued by your ideas and would like to subscribe to your newsletter. Jokes aside, a 3 value Boolean conditional could have some useful applications.
- eropple 9y agoFWIW, for the downvoters: you really should look 'lisper up. I'm not sure I agree with him but the incredulity shown here is unwise.
- ng12 9y agoSmart people can still say dumb things.
- lisper 9y agoYes, they can indeed.
- curun1r 9y agoThe down votes are likely for trying to invoke an ad hominem argument. No matter someone's credentials, it's still a logical fallacy and something to be avoided. If he is an authority on the subject, it should show through in his comments. I'm sure he's a very smart and knowledgable person. But there are a lot of smart and knowledgable people here and by invoking his credentials, he's presuming that the people he's talking to are less knowledgable, intelligent or entitled to their opinions. It's insulting and he's earned his downs. Full disclosure: I downed his 'look me up' post and upped his more substantive posts.
- eropple 9y agoExcept 'lisper wasn't making an argument. He was responding to a case of somebody being socially jerkish in a way that was pretty gentle, even for HN's coddling standards. That's important, because downvotes don't fix jerks--only pointing out the behavior does. Coming in hot with "oh but fallacies, hmm hmm, heaven forfend" when what's being suggested is "maybe don't be a jerk?" is not a great look, don't you think?
- curun1r 9y agoHe was making an argument and its disingenuous for you to suggest otherwise. Go back and look at what he wrote. He basically said, "before you dismiss my idea as not having merit, go look me up." Ideas have merit independent of who has them. That's the point. He was citing his credentials to back up his earlier argument. I'm not saying that the comment that he was replying to was right or even civil and had he left off his second "Oh, BTW..." line, it would have been a reasonable response. But including it not only speaks to the comment he was replying to but also to everyone who disagrees with his idea. BTW...parodying what I said followed by condescension is also not a great look.
- carapace 9y agoI'm sorry but I think your pattern matching for "Argument from Authority" is misfiring here. Lisper wasn't saying, "I'm right because I'm me." He was saying, "Adjust your prior[1] for my statement given additional data about its source." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prior_probability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prior_probability
- curun1r 9y agoQuoting directly: > Oh, and BTW, before you completely dismiss the idea that my suggestion might have merit, you might want to look me up. He wasn't saying "I'm right because I'm me." He was saying, "I'm me so don't assume I'm wrong." It's still an appeal to authority. Had his credentials been part of the first line, where he was confirming that he was serious about his previous post, then your interpretation would be correct.
- fenomas 9y ago> I didn't just fall off the turnip truck Don't get me wrong - I don't know who you are but your username is in my mental bucket of "people worth paying attention to" just from past comments. I ask because the idea of a three-valued boolean seems rather more "magical" than whatever sins JS already commits by defining comparisons such that (a<=b || b<=a) can be false, and so on. I mean, isn't it a contradiction in terms to begin with, to call such a beast a boolean?
- lisper 9y agoIt doesn't matter what you call it. What matters is that you somehow distinguish between situations that are clearly true or false and situations that are not clearly one or the other. The exact mechanism by which you do this doesn't really matter (and what you call it really doesn't matter). What matters is that you don't discard the potentially valuable information that you just tried to do an operation that doesn't make sense. Making null>=0 return TRUE is like making 0/0 return 1.
- ng12 9y agoCan you provide an example of when this would be useful? For example: if (foo.bar.length >= baz.buz) { ... } otherwise { // what am I supposed to do here? } How do I disambiguate if the "broken" type coercion was actually what I wanted? How do I tell what circumstances conspired to make this statement not-clearly-true?
- lisper 9y agoYou'll have to provide some more details. Why would you want this broken type coercion? What are you actually trying to do here? But in the absence of this information, my first guess would be: if (foo.bar.length >= baz.buz) { ... } otherwise { alert("Something unexpected happened. Either foo.bar.length or baz.buz is not a number.") }
- ng12 9y ago