3 ms·
This is certainly an intriguing and creative proposal. But as the paper notes, it is mainly around referendum voting. And referendum voting can be viewed as op
by crazygringo 9y ago
This is certainly an intriguing and creative proposal.
But as the paper notes, it is mainly around referendum voting. And referendum voting can be viewed as opposed to representative democracy. Voters will happily vote yes on one referendum for higher benefits, and yes on another referendum on lower taxes, and the end result is laws that don't make sense. This can be seen as an example of the Condorcet Paradox [1]. But the point is, referendums are generally a terrible way to make decisions.
So on page 45 of the paper [2], the authors discuss that democracies are generally run according to representation, not referendums. So first they suggest using QV to elect candidates. Yet when given a choice between 2 (or even a handful) of candidates, do we really expect QV to make a difference? Republicans and Democrats are both extremely passionate, so I'd call it a wash. There's such a mix of social and economic issues large and small, QV doesn't seem to help untangle that.
The second thing the authors suggest is for representatives to "put their constituents' money at stake" when voting on laws. The authors wisely don't go too deeply into this, because it's clearly nonsensical when representatives are from a district which contains significant members of both sides. They actually admit as much ("QV in representative
assemblies would probably make more sense in a parliamentary system than in a presidential system") but actually get their terminology wrong -- it would make more sense in a proportional representation system than in a first-past-the-post system. (Presidential/parliamentary refers to the relationship between the legislature and the executive, which this proposal has nothing to do with -- which reveals their amatueur-ish level of analysis in this case.) At least they're honest in saying "many details clearly need to be worked out".
But I have an even more basic question, even for deciding referendums: who determines the base price of a vote? If a single vote cost $0.10 or $100, I imagine that could drastically affect outcomes, and I don't see them address this question anywhere.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Condorcet_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Condorcet_paradox
[2] https://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=287114112074116088083081078093027028127035061037007087028124077125100068075086098105101029122061103047118074117001004065016074013074027021053114119097009025082072058089039087066113081004111112107026019118092094008080003119026104024028079005074103100&EXT=pdf https://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=2871141120741160...