5 ms·
I've dropped this comment elsewhere here today, already, but: All the more reason to enable people to signal their wealth (sexual fitness) and raise taxes at t
by Nomentatus 9y ago
I've dropped this comment elsewhere here today, already, but:
All the more reason to enable people to signal their wealth (sexual fitness) and raise taxes at the same time - by repurposing "Sumptuary Laws." For example: If you want a car that's white, yellow or blue, no extra tax. If you want a red car that's a significant tax. If you want a purple car, that's a really big tax. Note that, with Sumptuary Taxes, you don’t have to be wasteful or conspicuously consume, or pour a large amount of carbon into the atmosphere in order to signal your wealth - the red paint and purple paint don’t cost much more than blue or grey. So this is also a very green proposal.
With Sumptuary Taxes you can show people you're rich and they're not and help the commonweal at the same time: showing that you're one of the responsible, caring rich.
(Sumptuary – related to the word sumptuous, of course.)
Sumtuary Laws were tried in England in the Fourteenth Century, but for almost the reverse purpose – merely to prevent poor people from wearing clothes that resembled the clothes rich people wore. This didn’t raise any revenue and was intended to save rich people money while increasing social barriers. The laws weren’t very successful and they didn’t last long.
- Trundle 9y agoI've thought for a while now that charities should do something similar and get in on the wealth signalling market. Not so much cars but I think fashion would be a great industry for them to take on. Instead of dropping $200 on a shirt and feeling guilty, the rich person gets to drop $200 on a shirt and feel good about it.
- milkytron 9y agoThe only problem I see with this is so-called "charities" charging $200 for a shirt and claiming an obscured donation to charity. The person buying the shirt can feel good about it, and the company selling the shirt can donate $1 and still keep their promise that they made a donation. Maybe I'm just cynical, but I think with the current economy and business practices going on that I have a right to be.
- sxates 9y agoKind of like (RED).