9 ms·
I think this highlights how expensive living is and how little income is. If we're going to have a "free economy" without an end of life safety net (i.e. Social
by ianai 9y ago
I think this highlights how expensive living is and how little income is. If we're going to have a "free economy" without an end of life safety net (i.e. Social security) then it has to be possible to work a lifetime and retire on savings made. But most indicators show little to no saving for most people. It sure seems something is deeply wrong.
- njarboe 9y agoThere are most certainly many things deeply wrong. Most people have negative savings every year. They have more debt. If one has bought a house, then it is very easy to go into more debt every year, when house prices are rising. Then they fall. Since the beginning of written history (the first written records are records of debts) there are stories and parables about the evil of debt and the need for debt jubilees. Also the idea that lending with interest is immoral is found through out time. Having such easy access to debt/credit from strangers seems not to work well over the long term for human societies. I mean, is it a good thing that one can get a "Rocket Mortgage" where you can "Get Approved Fast. Get an approval to buy a home or refinance your mortgage in minutes."? [1] [1] https://rocket.quickenloans.com/ https://rocket.quickenloans.com/
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Since the beginning of written history (the first written records are records of debts) there are stories and parables about the evil of debt and the need for debt jubilees. Also the idea that lending with interest is immoral is found through out time. Having such easy access to debt/credit from strangers seems not to work well over the long term for human societies. I suppose shrimp and pork and beef are also unquestionably evil... Debt didn't historically work because property rights were poorly recorded. This meant enforcing one's debt involved mafia tactics. Modern debt is cleaner and subject to bankruptcy, a process that occurs on a case-by-case basis when it's needed, a far better solution than randomly cancelling debt every so many years.
- meric 9y agoWell, the trend is now removing bankruptcy on certain forms of debt as an option, replacing it with cancelling it after X years. This is student debt.
- WalterBright 9y agoEasy access to credit is an important component to a free market. Making borrowing illegal just leads to all sorts of inefficient contortions to do it another way. For example, businesses often need to borrow money in order to get started. For another, "bridge" loans and "revolving lines of credit" allow a business to operate when the timing of receiving payments does not line up with the timing of when bills are due. Forgiving debts means that interest rates must rise to cover those losses.
- ekianjo 9y ago> Forgiving debts means that interest rates must rise to cover those losses. Exactly. Interests rates are way too low at the moment.
- njarboe 9y agoI agree credit can be very useful and good, but most people are not using debt to try an investment that allows them to pay back the debt and make some profit. They are buying consumables: dinners out, clothing, gadgets, vacations, cars, even housing is really a cost of something you are using. A depreciating asset and not an investment. I think it would be really good to use some of this education everyone gets to get across the fact that consuming using debt with is very bad. Some counter to all the other marketing in the world that says, "Buy, buy, buy". Not immune to it myself.
- AstralStorm 9y agoThe problem again is that consuming using available funds is not possible if you need to work 10 years of median salary for it - that in the more affordable states. The figures mentioned use full salary, in reality you might get some 50% of that possible to allocate to paying off the debt. You still get to pay utilities, cost of life for the family, transportation, education and probably extras. Note I've even ignored any savings - and with high mortgage debt, you can be wiped out by any more expensive health problem.
- njarboe 9y ago
- greedo 9y agoMany people simply spend what they make and live paycheck to paycheck, even when they make quite good money.
- conanbatt 9y agoI think you are having the wrong mindset. A stronger social net would not solve this problem of relative cost of housing. Already, there are many many homes that are very affordable for the median income.
- pcsanwald 9y agoMost people I know that don't have white collar jobs don't have any expectation they will ever be able to retire. I'd be very surprised if the majority of americans were in a position to be able to retire.
- PoachedSausage 9y agoI'm in my thirties and work for a government funded research organisation doing work on a particle accelerator. I don't expect or want to retire, but then 'retirement' means different things. I would definitely want to retire if I worked as a brick layer. Pensions are a Ponzi scheme, don't fall for it. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-41204209 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-41204209
- Retric 9y agoNo, the math is very different from a Ponzi scheme. Pensions are awesome if you don't have kids. Consider if you have a 5% chance to die at or before 65 who get's the money? Well what if you could get together with 10,000 people and split it with those who live. Now your investments are boosted by those who die and there is no downside as who cares what happens after you die. Unfortunately, such schemes are illegal unless it's though a company. Because really the long tail is living to 120 which means you don't want to aim to be broke at say 95 then turn 95 and be in good health. PS: Remember, returns after inflation can be <3% over 20 years. I want a hedge for that risk other than just having a massive amount of money I can't really spend.
- uiri 9y agoI agree that private pensions are not necessarily Ponzi schemes. It is possible that they are operated that way. It is also possible that they are operated like an actual investment fund. Without looking at the books, it is difficult to tell. However, social security and other government funded pensions are Ponzi schemes. The money you pay in is given to people who are retired at that time. The money you get out is paid by people who are working at that time.
- vlunkr 9y agoMaybe for SF. The article indicates that homes are quite affordable in much of the country.
- icantdrive55 9y agoYea they are more affordable, but the jobs went overseas for most of us. I've gotten so desperate, I was thinking about the whole living off the grid thing. A step above Homelessness? The property taxes nixed that pretty quick, along with all the other restrictions and fees one needs to pay just to live with respect. We have people in jail for fishing without a licence. Crazy? All this wouldn't bother me if America had a viable safety net. We decided Globalism was fine. (Allowing China to live like we use too, and build up their defence. I just don't know?) We are now allowing technology to eliminate jobs. We are going to have a group of wealthy people who live like kings, and the rest of us will be the beggars. In my world, we are already there. The other night I saw something about the countries with the highest taxes, or countries that taxed their wealthiest citizens the most. I believe France, Switzerland, and Germany were near the front. Just happened to be the three countries I admire. Don't get me wrong, I love America's system of checks, and balances, but this is not the best country for guys like myself anymore. Sorry about going on, just in the gutter today. Don't feel well. Plus, I'm detoxing from a prescribed drug I was on for 10 years because my physician got cold feet. (If any doctor prescribes an addictive medication--think twice before taking it. They change their minds for the wrong reasons, and they will drag you in for mandatory office visits. Visits that have no real purpose.)
- pamqzl 9y agoYou can always buy a house in an expensive area to work and then sell it to retire in a cheaper place. That's my plan (maybe).
- gozur88 9y agoI have very little sympathy for the 40% or so of the population who could save for retirement but don't.
- buildbot 9y agoCitations for that number? Why don’t they save for retirement? Can someone on minimum wage with a family save for retirement? Does someone who makes bad choices deserve to be homeless and destitute later in life?
- gozur88 9y ago>Does someone who makes bad choices deserve to be homeless and destitute later in life? The rest of us don't deserve to pay for their bad choices.
- sn9 9y agoBad choices don't happen in a vacuum any more than good choices do.
- gozur88 9y agoI have other things I'd rather do with my money.
- muninn_ 9y agoSure but a bad choice can be buying a new BMW while I put 25% of my savings away to retire and now I'm stuck paying for you to retire because you didn't save your money. What's the incentive? I'm a democratic socialist, and I support safety nets and wealth redistribution where it makes sense, but it's important to keep in mind that we need to make sure we are continually incentivizing good practices. If you make a bunch of money and save nothing, you should live in poverty in you're retirement. Sure you can be fed and clothed and have your healthcare taken care of, but aside from that? You made a poor choice in the face of very clear information telling you to save for retirement. Frankly I think people need to be scared of what happens when they retire: they should be thinking "crap if I don't save money I'm going to live very poorly when I retire". Right now it's "the government will take care of me so let me go buy this unaffordable thing". Even worse is that the government encourages this because without consumerism our economic charade falls flat. Keep buying poorly made, cheap goods from China and overpriced homes and cars with low interest rates!!
- seanp2k2 9y agoGood thing that so many smart people are working so hard on this! /s
- 0xbear 9y agoI know a dude who makes $800k/yr and still lives paycheck to paycheck. Lack of savings is not necessarily caused by lower income. People tend to shovel money out the door as quickly as it comes in.
- adrianN 9y agoWow, I wouldn't even know how to spend that much. If I made that much I'd retire after two or three years.
- 0xbear 9y agoLots of travel to exotic destinations, huge house in an expensive neighborhood, fancy car upgrade every couple of years, huge tax bill. All gone.
- Mz 9y agoMaybe. Or maybe not. I read a great article at some point that advised people who wanted to be writers to just go do that while they were young and poor and not wait until they had saved up money to finance it. Because the reality is that once you have the fancy high paid job and the fancy house, car and clothes that not only go with it but are essentially required, the amount you thought you needed changes. For certain jobs, expensive suits and other things you might think are frivolous luxuries are nearly impossible to do your job without. It can be nigh impossible to unhook your income from this treadmill where the faster you run, the further behind you fall in certain metrics. Millionaires are sometimes like the guy who needed the cart to carry cart repair supplies: Once you are rich and famous, now you need that mansion, not for the space or prestige but for security purposes, and you may also need a bodyguard, a bullet proof limo, etc.
- discordance 9y agoGolden handcuffs
- woodpanel 9y agoOn Topic: is the house paid, rented or is he paying off a mortgage? :-)