5 ms·
Given that this is a typical identity provider, I'm curious there's interest to make this service available to the saas industry at large. For example, I'd rat
by forforthought 9y ago
Given that this is a typical identity provider, I'm curious there's interest to make this service available to the saas industry at large.
For example, I'd rather NOT have to manage login credentials for my bank, mortgage car payment, and various airlines.
I'd rather let login.gov handle it.
Moreover, as a saas provider, I wouldn't mind deferring this liability to someone other than google or facebook.
- castis 9y agoOver the past few years, I have been conditioned to be weary of handing even more control over my personal life to the government than they already have. Assuming they open this up to private businesses (which I don't believe they're planning to), I wouldn't use any business that uses this service. I apologize if this sounds futile or like I'm donning my tinfoil hat, but my guard is way up these days.
- losteric 9y agoI would use this if it was implemented as a federated state-level service, expanding on drivers license/ID card programs. Not everything, but certainly for applications that already require a drivers license (eg airlines, banks, apartment applications).
- Micoloth 9y agoTo me, this is the right attitude towards this. Really? Are you more scared by your own democratic government than by facebook? Besides i'm not even american, so whatever
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- barsonme 9y agoWell, yeah. I can choose to not use Facebook (for the most part). I can't choose to not use the federal government. Plus, disliking and being wary of government is quintessentially American—it goes back to our roots as a country. As an example that just popped into my head, look at DACA: a bunch of undocumented persons told the federal government about their undocumented status (in exchange for something good) and now that information can/will/may be used to deport them. With the government, it cuts both ways.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zbentley 9y agoThose are valid points, but I think they miss the point of the question: are you more scared about data security in an online identity provider provided by the government or Facebook et. al.? Your answers were more about things the government can do to screw you over. It can do those things if your data is stored in Facebook as well: search warrants, compliance orders, subpoenas, etc. will all result in the government having access to your data unless strong encryption is used on your data (which, as we've seen with Apple, is still not enough sometimes). I think (though I may be wrong) that the question had more to do with whether you trust this solution to be more secure against external/accidental breach than a solution offered by Facebook. I don't know the answer to that question, though.
- mdpopescu 9y agoThe point is, a warrant is a tiny bit more difficult to get than no warrant. Having all that data on their own site bypasses the need for one.
- zbentley 9y agoTrue, but having all the data on the government's site may (may) make it more secure from being leaked to sources other than the government. This isn't a statement of the government's software quality, but one of incentives: large private companies have not, historically, suffered much (legally or in terms of growth/revenue) from data breaches. The government losing data that it has independent reasons to keep safe is probably a larger perceptual risks, since government departments/funding can be suddenly cut in the wake of disasters of this nature, and elections can be lost. TL;DR the feedback loop for bad security might be more direct if the government is the one doing the securing. That's a troublesome prospect in several regards, but is plausible, I think.
- antimatter 9y agoWhat you have to realize is that the US government is full of life long bureaucrats who are not democratically elected and are in no way held accountable like the representatives. And the representatives are perfectly happy to throw their hands up and hold hearings every time the bureaucrats do something wrong without actually taking the effort to change anything. To me, this is no different than Facebook and Google.
- Erwin 9y agoThe Danish NemID ("easy ID") uses the Danish SSN, a password and strike list for login to the many government services (you can get divorced online if both parties agree ), banks, contracts (e.g. signing deeds to a house), gambling where you need proof of age or other proofs of identity (e.g. you can validate yourself on the eBay/craigslist equivalent to make your buying/selling more credible). NemID itself is ran by a private party -- the basic pricing is 50 cents per unique user or 15 cents per session if you are a non-government entity. There are some privacy protections -- as non-government entity you cannot get to the SSN, just another ID, but you can ask the user to enter their SSN and verify it's valid for that user. It's working pretty well after they finally got rid of the Java encryption applets. However you need to have a Danish SSN to use it, so you either live in DK or are a citizen.