3 ms·
I found the writing style of this article a little opaque (and poorly edited in some places), so let me try to lay out the logic as I understand it. There are
by munificent 9y ago
I found the writing style of this article a little opaque (and poorly edited in some places), so let me try to lay out the logic as I understand it.
There are two styles of attack: "conventional" (bombers, soldiers, etc. but no nukes) and "nuclear".
A successful conventional attack on NK could quickly remove its ability to initiate a nuclear attack. Without too much trouble, the US or some other major power could send a bunch of bombers over and completely eradicate NK's nuclear arsenal.
NK may be able to prevent a conventional attack by making a pre-emptive nuclear attack on foreign military targets. I say "may" because I think this is the least-justified claim of the article.
Doing that would not provoke the same kind of international response that a nuclear attack on NK would. If we blew up a base or two in NK, we could say, "We're just try to keep the world safe." and most other countries probably wouldn't do much about it except maybe some stern looks of disapproval.
This means that a conventional attack on NK is more likely, since there is less disincentive for it.
NK has no real ability to respond conventionally. We could take out their entire military without breaking a sweat. Their only noteworthy weapon is nukes. That means they must be preserved at all costs.
So Kim Jong-Un knows:
1. A conventional attack can remove NK's nuclear capability.
2. A nuclear strike on military bases may prevent that conventional attack.
3. NK's nuclear capability is their only weapon against other countries so must be preserved at all costs.
Those logically imply that if NK is to engage in any military conflict, it must strike first with nuclear weapons. Anything else results in defeat.
Add to that:
4. A conventional attack is more likely because there would be fewer repercussions on other countries for doing so.
Combine those together and it implies an NK nuclear first strike on military targets is more likely.
This presumes you believe 2 and 4 to be true. I think 4 probably is true -- the world generally seems to roll over when the US marches troops into random countries, even under dubious justification (Iraq, Afghanistan, etc.).
I don't believe 2 is true. Even if NK used every nuke they got on every base they can reach, I think the US and its allies would still have so much remaining military capability that we could turn the entire country into a glowing slag heap and still be home in time for the weekend.