5 ms·
That's because the US government doesn't provide a convenient and reliable way of proving physical identity. And that's mostly because the people don't want it.
by GuB-42 9y ago
That's because the US government doesn't provide a convenient and reliable way of proving physical identity. And that's mostly because the people don't want it.
Most countries have some form of universal photo ID, and a copy of it is usually required, along with a signature that matches. Not perfect but better than a simple number.
Some countries like Estonia include a cryptographic token in their ID, protected by a PIN. That's the 2 factor security you wanted.
But people in the US tend not to like the idea of government IDs. But when such a thing is needed, they use the closest thing they have, and that's the SSN.
- mindcrime 9y agoThat's because the US government doesn't provide a convenient and reliable way of proving physical identity. And that's a Good Thing. Government should exist to protect property rights, provide rule of law, and maybe to enforce contracts. Managing everyone's identity is clearly not something that the State should be involved in.
- wyager 9y agoAgreed. Any company worth its salt should allow me to authenticate myself purely cryptographically if I want to do so. This is easier, more secure, and more human-friendly than a centralized government ID registry. Unfortunately, most companies aren't worth their salt.
- spiralpolitik 9y agoHow do you enforce such things without being able to identify and validate that the parties in the dispute are who they say they are ? Example how do you make sure that the crime ends up being recorded against the right John Smith ? The US government actually does have a a convenient and reliable way of proving physical identity (a Green Card for example serves the purpose of identifying permanent residents), they've just declined to deploy it more widely.
- Amezarak 9y agoUS citizens can legally exist without any government identification or documentation whatsoever - no SSN, no birth certificate, no driver's license, no state ID, no nothing. It deals with them the way the government dealt with such cases before government identification ever existed - who do you say you are, and who do other people say you are? Where do you and other people say you live? In your example, in the modern age, "John Smith" would have an arrest mugshot to aid with identification. Whatever criminal records are kept would probably just have the missing information blank. It's not as if there's a big database of citizens with Felon? Y/N as one of the fields, making you run the risk of marking the wrong John Smith as a felon. The world is a very messy place - the US system does an okay job of treating it as one.
- KSteffensen 9y agoIt's not clear to me. Care to elaborate? Seems like a good thing to know how many citizens are in the country, for keeping track of voters if nothing else. In Denmark we have a government sponsored two-factor authentication system linked to the Central Person Register or CPR number which every citizen gets assigned at birth. The two factor authentication is used for all communication with state and municipal and for all banking. Works quite nicely from my point of view. Makes a lot of things a lot easier.
- gnaritas 9y agoYour position makes sense if you trust your government, many of us don't trust ours thus his position.
- gglitch 9y agoIt seems to me that all three of the above depend upon being able to certainly verify someone's identity.
- robaato 9y agoSame in UK. We don't need to carry passport or visual ID with us. https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/589/in-uk-is-it-a-requirement-by-the-law-to-carry-an-id https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/589/in-uk-is-it-a-re... https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/libertycentral/2010/jun/09/what-information-am-i-obliged-to-give-to-a-policeman https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/libertycentral/201... https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/libertycentral/2009/jan/19/stop-and-search-civil-liberties-law https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/libertycentral/200... I still have a paper driving certificate, and it is still legal (https://www.gov.uk/exchange-paper-driving-licence https://www.gov.uk/exchange-paper-driving-licence). I used it 2 days ago in Germany to hire a car. I have resisted "upgrading" to a photo drviers license because my address is still valid, and the photo driving license isn't (at least wasn't) valid without the paper extra anyway. If it ain't broke... In reality I carry my passport in my briefcase because I both travel overseas fairly often, and visit customers where it is necessary to show a photo id and that is all I have. As I recall, you may be required to report to a police station and show an ID or proof of identity if necessary - within a few days. But without evidence to the contrary (and subject to powers listed above for police), you are believed when you identify yourself.
- Amezarak 9y agoIncidentally, even SSNs are not universal. You are not required to have an SSN, and some religious groups opt out.