4 ms·
After thinking about the situation I always fall back on the realization that China continues to support them. Imagine if they used nukes to attack the US bases
by phkahler 9y ago
After thinking about the situation I always fall back on the realization that China continues to support them. Imagine if they used nukes to attack the US bases in the region. China steps in to stop them and takes the islands that were formerly US held. It's all a major incident that can be blamed on N.Korea, but China gain territory and less US military presence in the region. Plausible?
- mullen 9y agoNot plausible at all. If China took Guam, the United States Military would kick the crap out of China from one end of the Pacific to the other. Within 60 days, China would completely defeated on the oceans and in the air. Any resulting peace treaty would be of China accepting Taiwan independence, dropping all support for North Korea and giving all ambitions to the South China sea. China has a lot to lose if it went to war against the United States.
- munificent 9y agoI the US military actually that much more powerful than China's? I'm asking honestly, I don't know much about this stuff.
- jdale27 9y agoYes. China has more manpower, but that's about their only advantage. Navy, Air Force, the US dominates. And as everyone knows, you never get involved in a land war in Asia...
- mullen 9y agoThis. I will add, the US military may not be the largest in the world by manpower, but it is the best equipped, best trained and has a world wide network of allies and military bases. Certain parts of the US military are the largest, for example, the US Air Force is the largest and best equipped air force in the world. The second largest is the US Navy. The only thing China has going for it is that it is not only geographically large, but also has a huge population.
- phkahler 9y agoI didn't mean they actively fight the US, but instead just kind of walk in to the nuked islands and say "hey, we'll hang on to this since it got nuked and nobody's here now". But yeah, it's known to be US territory so that really wouldn't fly. But I don't doubt they'd find some way to benefit if there is a conflict in the area that doesn't directly involve them.
- yourapostasy 9y agoUnlikely. China has no experience and insufficient infrastructure to project power over an ocean to take and hold land against the US Navy; logistics would get difficult once the US Air Force and Marines enter the picture, as well. Also, they currently enjoy a highly-advantageous position by keeping their relationship with the US somewhat ambiguous, by turns friendly and icy. This strongly advances their mercantilist posture, while giving them cover to engage in low-intensity conflict (like the South China Sea islands activity) with impunity. If they openly turned hostile against the US like that, then their economy would have to do without much export trade in a short amount of time, months instead of decades. Doable, but a mess, and it's not clear that the initial domestic support the current regime would enjoy from a war would outweigh and outlast the longer term economic adjustments to be made. They're trying to pivot away from exports at the moment, but it's pretty addictive. I tend to buy more into arguments that the PRC enjoys the cognitive/attention bandwidth NK occupies within US leadership, and if NK happens to first strike US, successfully or not, the resulting chaos would net benefit the PRC's global power position. They keep the benefit of a buffer state by insisting the US not take pre-emptive action, while simultaneously refusing to take stronger action (using the avoidance of absorbing a NK humanitarian crisis as shield) against NK, yet not actively help NK beyond the current nominal assistance levels, so I don't see significant downsides for the PRC and RUS to let the status quo reign. I suspect the PRC's unofficial statement that if NK struck first, then the PRC would not oppose a US reaction, is a thinly-veiled threat to the US: even if you or an ally absorb a nuclear first strike, you're not going to replace our buffer state. We'll intervene to topple the Kim regime, perhaps even help you do that, and then we'll ensure we control the agenda going forward of what emerges to replace that regime in NK. Before we get all doom and gloom over ICBMs, the chances are greater NK will ship a nuclear bomb to the US inside an ISO shipping container crossing in by ship, train or truck than lobbing it with a missile. The difficulties from this point in their ICBM development program are still substantial: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A00QWVHem3A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A00QWVHem3A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elEh4EBrqTQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elEh4EBrqTQ I agree with other comments here that the bigger, long-term threat is nuclear proliferation. We might successfully enter a MAD scenario with NK, only to get clocked by a Hezbollah-assembled device painstakingly purchased and gleaned from multiple sources including NK among the list. It's not even the materiel or finished devices that has me wondering as much as the practical knowledge that sits in scientists', engineers' and technicians' heads. We could magic away all of NK's nuclear infrastructure, and that still won't solve the problem of they have all these people that know the how-to's of building the devices. That's going to be a tough problem to solve.