3 ms·
> It even means a restaurant should be able to refuse to seat (pick one): black people, white people, males, redheads, left-handed people or introverts. Whateve
by Waterluvian 9y ago
> It even means a restaurant should be able to refuse to seat (pick one): black people, white people, males, redheads, left-handed people or introverts. Whatever. They probably won’t stay in business very long, it’s a form of corporate Darwinism.
I think the point of the argument is that you can't pick and choose when discrimination is OK. But then the second half, about corporate Darwinism, is a moral escape hatch, possibly because the author senses how manifestly wrong that argument feels.
There is no one-size-fits-all solution. Right vs. wrong will be a "you know it when you see it" case by case basis. And the test for that will mutate as our society mutates. Things that feel right today will embarrass our children.
What I think is important today is not to rely on capitalist mechanisms to protect minorities from discrimination. Wheelchair ramps are needed by a tiny fraction of our society. Many businesses probably wouldn't bother with accessibility, but it's mandated, because the disabled don't have a large enough wallet to bankrupt companies that don't put ramps in.
- pasquinelli 9y ago"There is no one-size-fits-all solution. Right vs. wrong will be a 'you know it when you see it' case by case basis." this is something i observe people, especially intelligent people, rejecting almost out of reflex, and it bothers me more and more. reasoning from first principles and justifying each step of reasoning is fine, but it is only an exercise in making models and thinking through those models. the general terms you make up along the way are only objects of your thinking. in actual reality there are only unique, concrete circumstances. human judgement has a place, but so often people act as if it doesn't, and they act as if holding that view makes them less biased-- not biased by their own judgement, i suppose. but it doesn't, they only apply that treatment to everything... but for some things it never occurs to them. their biases are still there, hidden in their tepidness, even if they never say this or that is wrong, or because the never say this or that is wrong.