17 ms·
Why Kim Jong-Un would not be irrational to use a nuclear bomb first
- sharemywin 9y agoSo, his trading partners and the UN wouldn't tighten sanctions after that? Seems like even humanitarian aid would be questioned.
- selectodude 9y agoThe regime is going down one way or another. They’ve backed themselves into a corner. While firing off a nuke would be insane, I would struggle to call it irrational.
- vidarh 9y agoOf course it would. But their argument is that he might end up in a position where it may seem to him that there is no alternative if he wants to secure his own survival. Consider Iraq. Hussein apparently believed the West would eventually believe him when he said he had no weapons of mass destruction. Instead he was killed. Why would any future dictator facing escalation from the west play along? Playing along now has a proven risk of getting you killed. The argument then is that to someone like Kim Jong-Un it may feel like the only alternative is to be so unhinged and so willing to escalate that the price of taking him out is too great for anyone to want to take it. Of course it's a tricky line - overplay your hand and you seem so unhinged that nobody can afford to let you live.
- thehardsphere 9y agoMinor correction: Saddam Hussein did not "play along", he pursued a policy of nuclear ambiguity. The resulting ambiguity is what caused his regime to get kicked over. Libya's Gaddafi did play along though, and still got killed by the US anyway, so the analysis is still correct even though the example illustrating it is wrong.
- jimmytidey 9y agoThis thread seems a bit naive to me. The UK & US knew Iraq didn't have WMDs, but wanted to invade anyway. The intelligence that the invasion was based on was risible. If you look at Bush's approval ratings, you can see the incentive he had to fight his reelection campaign in the context of a military response to 9/11. That was the reason for the invasion. The West didn't care about the facts of his having WMD or not. Now, we're paying the price of a capricious attitude to regime change in other countries: nothing that can be said will persuade NK that it isn't in existential danger.
- vidarh 9y agoHussein gave the UN weapons inspectors sufficient access that their leader in retrospect has pretty much accused Tony Blair of flat out lying based on what he knew at the time. There was no ambiguity.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoHussein wanted the West to believe that he had no chemical weapons. He also wanted the Middle East (especially Iran) to believe that he did have them. He tried to play that game, expecting the West to realize that he was bluffing his neighbors. Instead, the West believed that he was hiding stuff from the West.
- graycat 9y ago> Hussein wanted the West to believe that he had no chemical weapons. There's a standard joke that may be close to the truth. The joke goes, a US official said: "Of COURSE we knew that Saddam had chemical weapons because we still had the receipts from when we sold those weapons to him.", rough quote. The implication was that the US sold chemical weapons to Saddam for Saddam to use against Iran in the Iraq-Iran war. In Gulf War II, George W. Bush, Bush 43, invaded Iraq, occupied the country, captured Saddam, and let some Iraqis put Saddam on trial and hang him, all for whatever reasons Bush said or believed and didn't say or whatever. There are various candidate reasons; here are 10 such: (1) The attack on the US on 9/11/2001 early in Bush's first term made Bush eager to defend the US against terrorism. There were claims, and maybe Bush believed them, that Saddam was working with Al Qaeda on more such terrorist attacks on the US. (2) There were claims that Saddam had started to make biological and/or chemical weapons of his own and so hated the US that he might try to deploy such, via terrorism or whatever, on the US. Bush wanted thorough inspections of Iraq, but Saddam didn't cooperate which made Bush suspect that Saddam was trying to get and deploy such weapons against the US. Part of the issue of did Saddam cooperate were claims that Saddam had shipped biological and/or chemical weapons to some valleys in Syria to evade US and/or UN inspectors and later to retrieve the weapons for use against the US. (3) Like (2) except for nuclear weapons. (4) Saddam was a brutal dictator using tactics borrowed from Stalin. Maybe Bush wanted to stop that. (5) Saddam used chemical weapons against the Kurds in Iraq. Maybe Bush wanted to stop, retaliate against Saddam for that, or conclude from that that Saddam was so evil he should be killed. (6) Saddam was not obeying the rules stated at the end of Gulf War II. (7) Saddam had some sons who were nasty. (8) There were claims that Saddam tried to kill Bush 41 and that Bush 43 wanted to retaliate. (9) Bush 43 saw Saddam as being cruel to the people of Iraq, said that "The Iraqi people are perfectly capable of defending themselves", and maybe wanted to make that possible. For the invasion in Gulf War II, the US military did capture Baghdad, occupy the country, and guide Iraq to create a new constitution and hold held national elections; the US did all of that quickly. Maybe then Bush thought that the US could leave Iraq quickly, but, no, there was an insurgency, and essentially it is still going on. (10) Saddam built several palaces in Iraq, and maybe Bush thought that such palaces were improper and that Saddam should be killed for that. At the end of Gulf War I, US General Schwarzkopf knew that he could take Baghdad and occupy Iraq, quickly, especially if the rest of the coalition would go along but did not want to do that and believed that the coalition would not go along. Five years later in an interview in a two hour program by Frontline, Schwarzkopf said that if the US had occupied Iraq, then that would have been expensive "and, by the way, we would still be there", IIRC. Yup. And we still are. In Gulf War I, Schwarzkopf, and likely essentially all the coalition, wanted (A) to drive Iraq OUT of Kuwait and (B) to destroy the Iraqi military as an offensive force and, in particular, destroy or weaken the Iraqi Republican Guard, a main pillar of Saddam's power in Iraq. Schwarzkopf accomplished (A) thoroughly and (B) well enough for himself and, then, wanted himself, the coalition, the US military, and the US OUT of Iraq, that is, just leave Iraq to the Iraqis for whatever outcome that might be, pretty, ugly, whatever. So, in short, at the end of Gulf War I, Schwarzkopf clearly saw that for the US to occupy Iraq would be a big mistake. But later Bush 43 did just that.
- fortythirteen 9y agoGo home WaPo. You're drunk.
- wslh 9y agoThe problem with this assumptions is that you have only one shot. Edit: when I said one shot I was referring to being right or wrong about if you would be attacked or not. I was not referring to nuclear missile shots.
- eksu 9y agoDid you even read the article?
- thehardsphere 9y agoNo, actually the article clearly assumes that North Korea would have multiple shots, but not enough to eliminate the US. The strategy for them would be to hit Guam first to degrade American conventional war capability and then explicity force a choice of "we can stop now, or you can lose San Francisco."
- Benjamin_Dobell 9y agoClick bait title, article is not actually suggesting Kim Jong-Un will instigate nuclear warfare (or would be rational if he chose to do so), even though the title comes across that way. The article specifically talks about retaliation against military attacks by the US i.e. the article never suggests it would be rational to fire a nuke off as a "first" move, but rather simply fire them before the US does. The title is quite unclear in that regard.
- zzalpha 9y agoClick bait title, article is not actually suggesting Kim Jong-Un will instigate nuclear warfare Actually it does: This scenario to stave off an invasion with a limited nuclear attack on a U.S. military target is not irrational, although it is clearly risky and terrifyingly tragic. One wrinkle is that North Korea’s arsenal is currently small and vulnerable, and U.S. military strategy, reiterated by Defense Secretary Jim Mattis, is to try to find and destroy all of Kim’s nuclear systems in the event of a war. That gives Kim an incentive to go first, go early and go massively if he is not confident about surviving a U.S. attempt at disarming him. If Kim thinks we are coming after him or his forces, he cannot afford to be wrong and he cannot afford to launch second. That last sentence is key, so if you're skimming this comment, go back and read it. To summarize: The basic thesis is that, if Kim believes an attack is coming (not that it has started, that it is simply coming), his rational choice is to use nuclear arms on bases in the region and thus force the US to the negotiating table.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rgbrenner 9y agoI don't know.. maybe. Russia is said to be currently supplying arms to the taliban. Their goal there (to disrupt american efforts) would be the same as in NK. And China is NKs ally today, and has said they would assist if the US restarted the war (except if NK uses nuclear weapons). Both helped them during the Korean war. Both share a border with NK, making it easy for them to do so again. And both have been clear they don't want a pro-american state at their border (in Russia's case, on their western border). If war breaks out, it's very likely it'll be NK+China+Russia again (unless there's a very clear wrong by NK). In other words, NK will likely have more military options than the article admits once a war breaks out. But if NK uses nuclear weapons, that may change. Would China and Russia continue to back someone who used them? That's the question, and it's not a given that they would.
- balance_factor 9y ago> Russia is said to be currently supplying arms to the taliban. Their goal there (to disrupt american efforts) would be the same as in NK. And of course, the original supplier of arms to the people who formed the Taliban was the United States. The goal for the US was to arm and empower the Islamic extremists who had launched a jihad against the secular Afghan government, and to disrupt Russian efforts to support it.
- kharms 9y agoI'm quite sure that the US goal was not to arm Islamic extremists and topple the Afghan government, but rather to arm the resistance against the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan. That they ended up being Islamic extremists was besides the point.
- skrebbel 9y agoSo "yeah we tried to arm the rebels but we didn't realize that they were extremist nutcases until they were swimming in rifles and rocket launchers" You aren't really improving my confidence in American military strategy.
- dalbasal 9y agoI’m not totally convinced that mutual deference is sensible but this doesn’t make any sense, unless I’m missing something: Pyongyang’s conventional inferiority requires it to degrade the United States’ ability to sustain the attack against it. This means it essentially has no option but to use nuclear weapons first against targets such as Andersen Air Force Base in Guam… Pyongyang can’t affect the US’ ability to respond in any meaningful way. Even if Guam sinks into the sea, there’s still South Korea, Japan, ICBs & the US Navy. On top of that, there’s no guarantee that North Korea could even hit Guam without getting intercepted, and trying but failing would certainly means a massive counterattack. I think the big new issues with a Nuclear North Korea is probably proliferation related. North Korea has a tiny economy with exports of just 4-5bn, less than a small US city. Selling an occasional bomb could triple their exports bring in foreign currency, which they are starving for. Even if they got caught, would the US respond to a nuclear armed country?
- vtange 9y agoThe article explicitly stated how North Korea might feel free to hit or try to hit places like Guam, S.K. and Japan without fear of retaliation because the author guesses the average American would be OK with losing Tokyo and Seoul but not S.F.
- stuartaxelowen 9y agoI... I live in Tokyo.
- jdale27 9y agoYou are not an "average American". But really, it doesn't matter what the average American thinks; it's about the strategic calculus of showing that Japan and South Korea are under US protection.
- wil421 9y agoIf any three of those got hit there is no way a US President from any party would not respond with some counter attack. I'd expect the European countries to do the same.
- vtange 9y agoReading this makes me relieved that Nazi Germany did not obtain nuclear weapons - else a regime change ousting Hitler might not have happened at all, and it would've been free to carry on its agenda with less fear of Allied intervention.
- Benjamin_Dobell 9y agoI'm not so sure about that. Nazi Germany invaded many neighbouring countries. You can bet that if North Korea invades South Korea the presence of nuclear arsenal won't cause the UN to simply ignore their actions.
- vtange 9y agoEvery nuclear power since WWII has had the ability to invade many countries with minimal fear of retaliation.. Of course, lots of fingers point to the U.S., but China and Russia have invaded places as well. The article basically postulates that any state with nuclear weapons guarantees its basic territorial integrity. That means sure, we might have landed in Normandy and secured France and the USSR might've secured Poland, but the German heartland would've been a no-go for the Allies for fear of a nuke to Paris or London, and a safe-zone for Hitler and his agenda for Jews, etc.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- trgv 9y agoThe missile NK recently fired over Japan recently was launched at 5:58 AM. At 6:02 AM the Japanese government sent a text alert. At 6:12 it landed in the ocean. We know about NK missiles launches very quickly after they are fired. I wouldn't be surprised if we know about them before they're fired. This suggests to me that these missiles can be intercepted. I don't know what kinds of interception technology is deployed in the area, but I would guess there is some and I would also guess that a (hypothetical) NK ICBM would not have significant countermeasures. I think the real question here is what NK/Kim's aims are. When Iran was actively developing a nuclear capability, it seemed clear that their goal was to get as close to a weapon as possible without actually finishing a weapon. The closer they were, the more bargaining power they had in terms of getting the US/UN to lift sanctions. With NK, I'm less clear about strategy. In the past, it seemed like NK actions had the aim of extorting aid money from the US/allies. That may still be the case. Here's a chart showing US humanitarian aid to NK since 2001: https://explorer.usaid.gov/cd/PRK https://explorer.usaid.gov/cd/PRK
- hacker_9 9y ago> fired over Japan To put it in context, it was fired into space, over the part of the world where Japan resides. Changes the narrative quite a bit.
- gambiting 9y agoEven the best interception systems have a horrible success rate, it's basically a nice system to have but it's not possible to rely on it for protection. There is no better protection than making sure the missile is not launched in the first place.
- rgbrenner 9y agoIt takes 30-40 minutes for an NK icbm to reach the US. About 20 minutes to guam. But the US missile defense has never seen combat.. only tests. They had 10 successful tests (the last 10) out of 18. But those are planned ahead of time (with trajectories already mapped out), and the missiles don't have countermeasures (which they would in a real conflict). So there's a big question about whether the system will work at all. I don't think anyone is eager to find out. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-northkorea-missiles-usa-defense/lack-of-real-world-testing-raises-doubts-on-u-s-missile-defenses-idUSKBN1AP2R3 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-northkorea-missiles-usa-d...
- jlg23 9y agoIn January 1992[1], long after the Cuba Crisis, Robert S. McNamara attended a meeting with Castro. He asked Castro: 1) Did you know the warheads were there? 2) Would you have recommended to Chruschtschow to use the in the face of an US American attack? 3) If he had used them, what would have happened to Cuba? His response: 1) I knew they were there. 2) I would not have recommended to Cruschtschow, I did recommend to use them. 3) What would have happened to Cuba? We would have been totally destroyed! I think this story should be kept in mind when trying to predict behavior, esp. when the stakes are this high. [1] Retold by Robert S. McNamara in "The Fog of War: Eleven Lessons from the Life of Robert S. McNamara": http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0317910/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0317910/
- dalbasal 9y agoInteresting anecdote, Thanks for posting. But, presumably Castro was still playing the game even in 1992 ...at least in his mind. What was he going to say? I was bluffing.. I had to do what The Secretary told me to do.
- edison85 9y agoWe've been a few moments away from world destruction a few times. This was of course one of the biggest but so was that one malfunction when the Soviets believed we had launched a nuclear strike and ordered the same but the soldier declined to do so. Turned out it was an error. Many don't realize just how precarious a world is with ICBM technology. If they did I don't think they would hesitate for 1 minute to destroy NK years ago before they were first able to create mid range missles
- dogma1138 9y agoIt was after the fall of the USSR; AKA How did a Canadian rocket paid for by NASA, launched by Norwegian scientists almost doomed the world: http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/how-boris-saved-the-kremlin-1571317.html http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/how-boris-saved-the-...
- 8ytecoder 9y agoSame Castro in 2010: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748703865004575649141188850372 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748703865004575649...
- hacker_9 9y agoThis is complete and utter media hype. The most that will happen is we will continue sanctions, and NK will develop a nuclear deterrent. They will not actually use it to bomb anyone, but just so they can be safe in the knowledge they will not get invaded because of said deterrent. Like any other country with nukes (there is a lot of us). I do not support their regime, but I also do not support everyone ganging up on them and deciding that military invasion and mass slaughter is somehow the solution. Like with any country, change is slow and has to come from within.
- s17n 9y agoIt could come quickly and from without if the rest of the world (eg, China) cut off oil supplies. Regime would be gone in a matter of years.
- hacker_9 9y agoThat is not the change I mean, that is short sighted and how we would end up with a humanitarianism crisis where people die by the million.
- ben_w 9y agoIf you were leading NK, and your options were either 1) step down and probably get put on trial and die in prison for warcrimes, or 2) have an insufficient army and be hanged or die in a sewerpipe like Hussein or Gaddafi, or 3) have a really good army that will allow you to conquer enough farmland and natural resources to stave off 1 and 2, and possibly make any attempt to put you back in your box a phyric victory, which would you choose?
- phkahler 9y agoAfter thinking about the situation I always fall back on the realization that China continues to support them. Imagine if they used nukes to attack the US bases in the region. China steps in to stop them and takes the islands that were formerly US held. It's all a major incident that can be blamed on N.Korea, but China gain territory and less US military presence in the region. Plausible?
- mullen 9y agoNot plausible at all. If China took Guam, the United States Military would kick the crap out of China from one end of the Pacific to the other. Within 60 days, China would completely defeated on the oceans and in the air. Any resulting peace treaty would be of China accepting Taiwan independence, dropping all support for North Korea and giving all ambitions to the South China sea. China has a lot to lose if it went to war against the United States.
- munificent 9y agoI the US military actually that much more powerful than China's? I'm asking honestly, I don't know much about this stuff.
- jdale27 9y agoYes. China has more manpower, but that's about their only advantage. Navy, Air Force, the US dominates. And as everyone knows, you never get involved in a land war in Asia...
- mullen 9y agoThis. I will add, the US military may not be the largest in the world by manpower, but it is the best equipped, best trained and has a world wide network of allies and military bases. Certain parts of the US military are the largest, for example, the US Air Force is the largest and best equipped air force in the world. The second largest is the US Navy. The only thing China has going for it is that it is not only geographically large, but also has a huge population.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoTangent, but I've always wondered what the cost of dropping rice (or similar) into country to disrupt it is. I'd guess that you can drop enough rice to feed the population of NK for around $1-2bil/mo. The cost of the Iraq war was around $8-10bil/mo. So you're talking about 10-25% of the cost of a war effort. (I'd guess towards the higher side.) But! There's a lot of goodwill to be earned by dropping a steady supply of food across the country during the conflict. At the end of the day, starving people usually care more about food than kings. (Also, for marginally more you can include other kinds of supplies.)
- planteen 9y agoThe regime will simply say the rice is a tribute that the enemy is paying. Or that is is poisoned, etc.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoI don't know if anyone is still watching this, but: It's kind of hard to hide that there's also bombs being dropped, so it doesn't seem like claiming it's tribute would be effective. Claiming that it's poisoned might be viable -- but with enough starving people, someone is going to try it, and some number are going to decide (when it doesn't kill that person, because it isn't poison) that a slow poison is better than fast starvation. It just seems that NK (and a number of other places) keep large segments of the population in near starvation and/or slavery, and suddenly throwing surplus food across the whole country does a lot to disrupt the economics of that. How many people are putting up with NK bullshit because it's the only way to survive? I'm not saying "rice not bombs", I'm saying "25% less bombs, 100% more rice" is probably an effective trade-off in warfare, even in wealthy areas, because many citizens aren't prepared for serious, sustained armed conflicts and you save yourself a lot of trouble if the populace doesn't hate you for generations when the bombing stops.
- gumby 9y agoIn the 1980s I took some classes at MIT on strategic nuclear doctrine and related subjects. Even then it seemed a bit irrelevant, and the more I learned, the more so. It is disturbing to be paging back all that game theory bullshit 35 years later. (At that point MIT was still heavily into public policy rather than entrepreneurship. Though I am far, far from libertarian, that orientation also seemed outdated at the time).
- Thriptic 9y agoI'm perplexed by the logic here. If NK initiated a preemptive strike on local bases, there wouldn't be an opportunity for a second wave of attacks against the US mainland. The United States would retaliate so savagely that there wouldn't be any infrastructure for people to initiate a second strike with.
- rgbrenner 9y agokeep in mind NKs missiles are on mobile launchers like this: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-northkorea-missiles-china-truck/north-korea-appeared-to-use-china-truck-in-its-first-claimed-icbm-test-idUSKBN19P1J3 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-northkorea-missiles-china... They can be hidden pretty easily.
- zzalpha 9y agoI'm perplexed by the logic here I'm perplexed that you're perplexed. The article does a good job of laying out their argument. In short: The claim is that Kim believes the US wouldn't "retaliate so savagely" because the US wouldn't be willing to risk losing a major populated area to a successful ICBM strike. So preemptive nuclear strikes on local bases make sense to degrade the US's ability to stage a conventional invasion, while acting as a deterrent by threatening a strike on the domestic US. You can choose to believe or not believe that argument (it depends on your measure of risk in that scenario), but the logic is clear and reasonable.
- munificent 9y agoI found the writing style of this article a little opaque (and poorly edited in some places), so let me try to lay out the logic as I understand it. There are two styles of attack: "conventional" (bombers, soldiers, etc. but no nukes) and "nuclear". A successful conventional attack on NK could quickly remove its ability to initiate a nuclear attack. Without too much trouble, the US or some other major power could send a bunch of bombers over and completely eradicate NK's nuclear arsenal. NK may be able to prevent a conventional attack by making a pre-emptive nuclear attack on foreign military targets. I say "may" because I think this is the least-justified claim of the article. Doing that would not provoke the same kind of international response that a nuclear attack on NK would. If we blew up a base or two in NK, we could say, "We're just try to keep the world safe." and most other countries probably wouldn't do much about it except maybe some stern looks of disapproval. This means that a conventional attack on NK is more likely, since there is less disincentive for it. NK has no real ability to respond conventionally. We could take out their entire military without breaking a sweat. Their only noteworthy weapon is nukes. That means they must be preserved at all costs. So Kim Jong-Un knows: 1. A conventional attack can remove NK's nuclear capability. 2. A nuclear strike on military bases may prevent that conventional attack. 3. NK's nuclear capability is their only weapon against other countries so must be preserved at all costs. Those logically imply that if NK is to engage in any military conflict, it must strike first with nuclear weapons. Anything else results in defeat. Add to that: 4. A conventional attack is more likely because there would be fewer repercussions on other countries for doing so. Combine those together and it implies an NK nuclear first strike on military targets is more likely. This presumes you believe 2 and 4 to be true. I think 4 probably is true -- the world generally seems to roll over when the US marches troops into random countries, even under dubious justification (Iraq, Afghanistan, etc.). I don't believe 2 is true. Even if NK used every nuke they got on every base they can reach, I think the US and its allies would still have so much remaining military capability that we could turn the entire country into a glowing slag heap and still be home in time for the weekend.
- clavalle 9y agoIf the US didn't act massively and immediately to any strikes to our close allies, our alliances would be rendered meaningless. There would not be time for public debate. The US would respond within minutes of a move like that.
- bauer 9y agoarchive to bypass adblock wall http://web.archive.org/web/20170908173242/https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/why-kim-jong-un-wouldnt-be-irrational-to-use-a-nuclear-bomb-first/2017/09/08/a9d36ca4-934f-11e7-aace-04b862b2b3f3_story.html http://web.archive.org/web/20170908173242/https://www.washin...
- lwhalen 9y agoEvery year, the IQ necessary to destroy the world drops by 1.5 points.
- voxadam 9y agoWouldn't you prefer a nice game of chess?
- graycat 9y agoIMHO: On North Korea (NK), Trump is building rings and layers of responses and forces, at first to defend the US, South Korea (SK), and Japan and then to get rid of Kim and his military equipment, missile program, and nuke program. So, Trump's rings and layers are first defensive and then offensive. The urgent purpose of the defensive parts are to deter Kim from shooting at the US, SK, Japan, Guam, Australia, England, .... Here the message is clear: If Kim explodes a nuke, the US will respond so that Kim's first nuke will he his last one. For the defensive parts, he has been pursuing UN sanctions and lining up other countries against NK. He has positioned off the coasts of NK a Nimitz class aircraft carrier, several smaller ships, an attack submarine (in case Kim does something hostile with a submarine), and an Ohio-class missile firing submarine (SSBN) (in case Kim explodes a nuke). Apparently the British are sending a ship with some Mach 3 missiles maybe able to destroy an ICBM during launch or boost phase. Trump has positioned USAF planes at least in Guam and maybe in other west Pacific bases and held joint exercises with SK. He has authorized SK and Japan to buy some more advanced US weapons and has authorized SK to have more throw weight on their missiles (somehow the US retains some legal rights, soon to end, over SK from the Korean War). SK has been deploying US THAAD anti-missile systems. The US has been testing its anti-ballistic (ABM) systems, the ones designed to intercept a warhead during reentry. Trump had a White House meeting on NK with Mattis and Dunford and likely also Kelly, McMaster, and others and then had Mattis, with Dunford, make a strong statement that, to translate, if NK exploded a nuke then the US would make that first nuke the last one, and for this the US has several options, some nuclear, some non-nuclear. So, maybe for such largely defensive steps Trump's goal is to keep Kim from exploding a nuke right away. So, there are geographical rings from SK to Japan, Guam, and the US, e.g., short range defenses and long range defenses. And there are diplomatic layers from SK, China, Russia, the UN, the US, other countries, etc. For offense, Trump claims he talked with Xi and got him to say that he agreed that NK should not have nukes. It looks like Trump has decided that NK will not have missiles or nukes. If Kim wants to give up missiles and nukes peacefully, then maybe that will be enough. Otherwise Trump will work to have the missiles and nukes destroyed, to have Kim removed from office, say, moved out of the country and/or killed, and to have the NK military equipment, e.g., rockets, artillery, guns, trucks, submarines, other ships, etc. destroyed. The US Navy Seals have been training with some SK soldiers on how to take out someone, likely Kim, like the Seals took out UBL. Broadly it begins to look like the US and SK have decided that SK will do most of the fighting. So, maybe a fight would go: (A) The Seal trained SK soldiers cross into NK and kill and/or capture Kim. (B) Enough of the NK leadership and military command and control will be captured or destroyed to stop NK from shooting missiles, artillery. (C) SK will launch some hyper accurate missiles at the NK missiles ready to be launched. (D) The SK army, backed from the air by the USAF and Navy, will invade NK, take over the government and missile and nuke infrastructure and destroy that infrastructure. (E) China has troops on the NK border to keep NK civilians from entering China. Russia may do something similar. (F) The SK army will destroy essentially all the NK military equipment, e.g., artillery. (G) SK will turn NK over to the UN and leave. All the important steps will be over in just a few minutes or hours. Step (G) will take no more than some weeks. Then Kim and his military, missiles, and nukes will be gone. The NK leadership in missiles and nukes will be gone. The US will never set foot in NK. There will be very few civilian deaths. Little or no radiation will be released. All that is just a guess.