6 ms·
>The system is corrupt and should be burned to the ground. Ok, so we burn the system to the ground. Then what? Crown bitJericho king?
by krapp 9y ago
>The system is corrupt and should be burned to the ground.
Ok, so we burn the system to the ground. Then what? Crown bitJericho king?
- bitJericho 9y agoNothing. Having nothing is better than what we have.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoYou can't have nothing. Something will fill the power vacuum.
- krapp 9y agoYou can't have "nothing." Humans are social animals - we naturally organize ourselves around families and into cultures based on common geographic, linguistic and ideological heritage. We create power structures to more efficiently organize labor, manage resources, create and interact with markets and form economies, create myths to entertain one another, wage war, marry, etc. Apes form systems, they're an emergent property of our being, baked into our DNA. So, what then? As soon as a system emerges, burn that down as well? And the next? What about the system that allows you to destroy all the others, is that an exception to the rule? I get the feeling you haven't actually examined your beliefs beyond wanting the catharsis of seeing the status quo overthrown.
- bitJericho 9y agoSays the guy who's obviously never had to deal with the justice system.
- krapp 9y agoThat makes me privileged, and lucky, and maybe a bit square, but it doesn't prove me wrong.
- dang 9y agoOk, since now you're crossing into personal attack, I've banned this account until we get a commitment from you that you'll follow the site rules at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. You can email hn@ycombinator.com if you want to do that.
- bitJericho 9y agohe literally admitted never having dealt with the court system. Fuck you. (There's your personal attack)
- BeetleB 9y agoSaid many Iraqi Joes before the US invasion.
- simonh 9y agoHaving a flawed legal system is what you call a first world problem. For comparison in China prosecutors have so much power that the conviction rate is a tiny almost immeasurable sliver of a fraction below 100%. Conversely with weak rule of law you get lynchings, vendettas and retributive violence. Incarcerating innocent people is terrible and I appreciate the sentiment that it's better that 10 guilty people go free than one innocent is incarcerated, but not that no guilty people are ever brought to justice. Anarchic theories are premised on the idea that everyone would act as individuals and treat each other equally, but that's not what happens. People naturally form alliances, tribes, religious groups or out and out criminal gangs. The prosecutorial assumption of infallibility is just one symptom of a wider malaise. IMHO what America needs to appreciate, as a nation, is that it's nothing special. It's just big and therefore powerful, but it really doesn't have any special moral status or exceptional ethical immunity. You see the ideological belief that it does throughout American History from Manifest Destiny to America First, both the isolationist movement of the 40s and today. America is a great nation, yes. It's a bastion of democracy, true. But it's a very long way from moral infallibility. There's the perception that e.g. Europe is a corrupt den of elites, born from America's struggle for independence from and conflicts with European Monarchies such as England and Spain, but it's ludicrously out of date. The American allergy against Communism is a symptom of this. At it's root communism and socialism is about individual freedom and a caring society, but communism got infected with totalitarianism early on. Individual communists have often been as shocked and appalled by Soviet excesses as anyone else. George Orwell, who wrote Animal Farm and 1984 as critiques of Stalinism was himself as communist, but the distinction between Communists like Orwell and ones like Trotsky is lost on American ideological anti-communism. You really can have a fair and caring society, and real meaningful individual freedoms. They're not absolute, utterly opposed principles and in fact they need each other. You can't have guarantees of real individual freedom without a society that cares about making that guarantee and takes actual steps to protect it. Even Ayn Rand accepted welfare support when she needed it. You can't have a well functioning system of state care and support for individuals without individual freedoms to hold that system to account and drive change when it's needed. What makes change in the justice system so hard, as in other areas, is this assumption of ideological purity in the American system, mainly by American Republicans I have to say. As a British lifelong Conservative voter I find this hard to cope with but in the post-Reagan era I find very little common ground between myself and mainstream Republicanism these days. It's a bit bewildering realy.
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoWrite a new Constitution given the lessons of the last few centuries.
- krapp 9y agoBut we already have a method in place for changing the Constitution, no revolutions necessary.
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoThe architects who wrote that method also claimed that it would inevitably become ineffective.
- scotty79 9y agoThen adopt saner system like the ones in most european countries. It's such a silly mindset. Do what we currently do in US or anarchy. There are over hundred other countries on earth and significant fraction of them is doing way better than USA in most aspects.
- krapp 9y agoWhat seems silly to me is the premise that completely destroying the existing system would somehow result in a saner and more just system replacing it. Adopting something more akin to European style democracy (which is what I assume you're mostly referring to) is already possible within the US system. That it hasn't been done yet isn't evidence of corruption within that system, but of the culture of the US simply not wanting it.
- scotty79 9y agoYes. It's a silly premise. But almost equally silly is the premise that, a system where so much money and power relies on its insanity can be gradually turned into something different, saner. You need really a lot of disregard of previous system and power to make any significant changes. You'd need either revolution or invasion. Obama inaptitude shows that the system can't be touched from within even by smart person in position of highest legal power.