4 ms·
I thought this article was going to be about mouse cursors. The story there is even worse. We've been stuck in a chicken-and-egg situation for a few decades now
by vanderZwan 9y ago
I thought this article was going to be about mouse cursors. The story there is even worse. We've been stuck in a chicken-and-egg situation for a few decades now.
There isn't a single mainstream OS that supports having multiple mouse cursors that I know of, and even if it did, not a single program expects it either - most would break. The closest we have is on-line editors that can have multiple users like Google Docs, and that's not single screen.
And you may be thinking "yeah but why?" and I wouldn't blame you, but that's just because you're not aware of how how much our current input devices limit us and how they are based on a flawed model of handedness.
Yves Guiard proposed a model in 1988 that argues the dominant/recessive model of handedness is wrong: instead, we constantly perform complicated asymmetrical tasks, with one "coarse" reference-frame hand and a fine-tuned "zoomed-in" hand (the latter being considered the dominant one)[0]. Later research has only backed this up (note that the linked paper has over a thousand citations).
When keeping this asymmetrical model in mind designing our input, things tend to just "feel" right. I guarantee you that the best two-handed input methods you use all follow this principle: even if not applied consciously, any two-handed interfaces converges to it. Simple case-in-point: remember 3D shooters before WASD + mouse? WASD = reference frame hand, mouse = fine-tuned input hand. Gamers just intuitively discovered this on their own. In fact, look at button placement on gamepads in general: movement ("frame of reference") on the left, action buttons on the right.
Bill Buxton[1][2][3] did really cool experiments with these ideas and then... well, nearly nothing. And I really believe the main reason is a lack of technical freedom to experiment: even if someone does manage come up with a wonderful intuitive, fluid bimanual interface that isn't limited to a keyboard, a mouse and maybe a touch-screen, who is going to be able to use it on their laptops or desktops?
I'd like to experiment and the fundamental requirements to do even that are missing. Even multi-touch is barely going to help: you cannot tell which hand belongs to which touch-point.
[0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15136274 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15136274
[1] https://www.billbuxton.com/2hands.html https://www.billbuxton.com/2hands.html, video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w0c1Xg9lERY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w0c1Xg9lERY
[2] https://www.billbuxton.com/ToCHI2H.html https://www.billbuxton.com/ToCHI2H.html
[3] https://www.billbuxton.com/input11.2H.pdf https://www.billbuxton.com/input11.2H.pdf
- Splines 9y agoFascinating. Are you familiar with any other ongoing research? I would imagine that a touch scroll pad like in the linked video would be a useful thing to have on the left hand side of a keyboard. I could use it to navigate through a document quickly and use the mouse to pick my target.
- vanderZwan 9y agoI haven't explicitly kept up after graduating from my interaction design masters, but in general the alternative inputs being researched for VR work around two-handed input. Leap Motion for example can distinguish both hands (although often it regresses to "one hand is the touch-menu, the other taps on it"). Games and input devices for games also always design around bimanual input, even if rarely consciously. Side-track: something almost nobody noticed when the Wii came out is that it's wiimote/nunchuck setup works both for right- and left-handed people. I'm left-handed and I automatically switched to a left-handed input method for my games without even thinking, for the first time in my life! I didn't even realise this until a few months in myself! And yes, I completely agree with you! Something I forgot to mention is that for certain types of tasks, this kind of input lowers the mental burden for the user (something that Buxton showed in his papers). If we turn your idea around: laptops come with a trackpad by default. If only OSes would allow for distinguishing between it and and external mouse (for example), then we could already cheaply and easily experiment with this on our laptops!