3 ms·
ICOs are fraud IMHO. I want to ask why this is even legal, but then I think - why shouldn't it be? And then how can people be so stupid? There is no legally rec
by phkahler 9y ago
ICOs are fraud IMHO. I want to ask why this is even legal, but then I think - why shouldn't it be? And then how can people be so stupid? There is no legally recognized thing as ICO is there?
- berberous 9y agoNo, an "ICO" is not a legal term. Filecoin, however, is one of the few folks that tried to comply with US law. They limited their sale to accredited investors and user a new legal document referred to as a SAFT (Simple Agreement for Future Token), analogous to the SAFE documents popular in startup land. Most ICOs are unregistered securities offering that are violating US law by going public without an effective registration statement in place with the SEC, or an exemption therefrom. Some ICOs may be legal to the extent they are not 'securities', I.e. the argument that you are buying a useful network token, not a security. In my opinion, this argument is BS for the majority of ICOs.
- deevolution 9y agoLaws are all made up dude, they aren't real, man.
- EGreg 9y agoNot every coin has to promise to appreciate in price. In fact, I'd argue that bitcoin and other deflationary currencies lead to hoarding behavior, and are not good as a medium of exchange. (However, they make an excellent store of value, and sending large amounts of money once in a while.) Here's who I think should really be issuing securities: local communities. There's an exemption for municipal securities in the Exchange Act, although I think later it was plugged (lawyers anyone?) That's what my company is building. A platform to help communities issue their own currency, like Bristol does. If Detroit had it, it probably wouldn't have gone bankrupt. Would like some feedback: https://qbix.com/blog https://qbix.com/blog What we still haven't figured out is, why would investors buy the tokens if they not increase in value, but perhaps the opposite? It can't be because of any "over and above" value to the investor, in the form of capital gains, etc. But if the communities buy the tokens, then that's a product that they issue to their members. Like kickstarter, it becomes a product and not a security.