2 ms·
The are a subset of the expected functionality in modern email systems. The list leaves out all of the other features that we expect in a modern email system m
by eesmith 9y ago
The are a subset of the expected functionality in modern email systems.
The list leaves out all of the other features that we expect in a modern email system meant for non-technical users, like a GUI interface including drag&drop attachments, spell-checking as you type, and rich text.
Where do you draw the line? Which UX features are critical before saying something is "email", and which are non-essential? The thesis, which I strongly disagree with, is that all of those features are required to have email.
Once you weaken those hyper-specific requirements somewhat, he is no longer the inventor of email.
While if you strengthen those requirements, email didn't happen until a decade or more later.
You write: "And the fact that he (supposedly) implemented them ahead of even the systems you were using in the 80s is worth note."
No, it it not worth a note. It means I was a student with only access to crappy systems. I was asking why I was wrong to say that I was using email on such a crappy system that did not implement all of the required points of Table 1.
That SIGCIS link you pointed to shows a 1 minute ad about Laurel, from Xerox PARC. It's a mouse-driven email system with, among other things, group support ("everyone on the routing list should see this"), local message sorting, and WYSIWIG output to a laser printer. In 1978.
That's what's of note. The flip side to my question is, why wasn't Laurel or other systems from 1978 also email?