5 ms·
>How is this any more offensive or unlikely than stuff like digit ratio research? Because it's based on the idea that gay men aren't real men. You have to be a
by foldr 9y ago
>How is this any more offensive or unlikely than stuff like digit ratio research?
Because it's based on the idea that gay men aren't real men. You have to be a little suspicious when scientific research comes out with findings that happen to exactly match the prejudices of the experimenters and/or the broader society. There used to be lots of "scientific" evidence for racist ideas too (see e.g. http://lrc.ohio.edu/lrcmedia/Streaming/lingCALL/ling270/myth13.pdf http://lrc.ohio.edu/lrcmedia/Streaming/lingCALL/ling270/myth...).
>Which is both scientifically interesting, and a strong argument for gay rights in places where it is still seen as some kind of sin or mental illness.
It's only an argument for gay rights if you presuppose that "fixing" gay people would be the right thing to do if it were possible. If you don't presuppose that, then it makes no difference whether or not people are "born gay".
- yorwba 9y ago> Because it's based on the idea that gay men aren't real men. If a study found that male, violent criminals had wider jaws than average men, would you think that the study was based on the idea that average men aren't real men, unlike criminals? I think it's quite likely that both sexual orientation and jaw size are influenced by the same hormones (e.g. testosterone), since both features are involved in sexual dimorphism. Essentially, if a person is similar to average members of the opposite sex in one dimension, they are likely to be similar in other dimensions as well. That doesn't make anyone inferior or less "real", it just means that the averages of two groups are slightly different on a certain axis that roughly corresponds to the feminine-masculine distinction. On that axis, you will have (most feminine woman) (average straight woman) (average gay woman) (most feminine man) (most masculine woman) (average gay man) (average straight man) (most masculine man) That axis is very different from the inferiority-superiority axis, where you have (nobody) (everyone else)
- foldr 9y ago>I think it's quite likely that both sexual orientation and jaw size are influenced by the same hormones Ok. I think it's also quite likely that they're not. >(most feminine woman) (average straight woman) (average gay woman) (most feminine man) (most masculine woman) (average gay man) (average straight man) (most masculine man) Are you serious about this? Gay men are just men who are sexually attracted to men. You'd think that the idea that gay men are sexually attracted to men because they are more feminine than other men would have died in the face of all the obvious counterexamples, now that fewer people are hiding their sexuality, but it seems surprisingly persistent. The problem with this kind of thing is that despite representations to the contrary, no-one is really interested in the group means for their own sake. They are interested because they want to pedal the tired old theory that gayness is a defect resulting from a lack of masculinity. People are often too polite (or afraid?) to say that now, but gay people are capable of reading between the lines.
- yorwba 9y ago> The problem with this kind of thing is that despite representations to the contrary, no-one is really interested in the group means for their own sake. I'm interested in group means for their own sake. Or rather, I'm interested in them because they hint at underlying mechanisms, and I'm interested in mechanisms for their own sake. FWIW, I'm asexual and do not regard homosexuality as some kind of defect. Otherwise, what would I have to think of myself? Additionally, I don't think you can "lack" masculinity in the sense that you "need" some amount and are deficient otherwise. There are some people who are closer to one extreme than to the other, and if likelihood of attraction to a specific sex changes somewhat monotonically with position on this axis, that tells you very little about individuals, but a bit more about biological interactions, which, again, I find interesting for their own sake.
- foldr 9y agoBut the supposed mechanism in this case basically boils down to "not manly enough to put pee pee in vajayjay". Even if group means differ slightly, there are so many feminine straight met and masculine gay men that it's very doubtful that this hints at an underlying mechanism. It is rather like noticing differences in haircuts between straight men and gay men and surmising that grooming makes you gay. The idea that effeminacy is the underlying mechanism makes sense only given the homophobic stereotype that all gay men are limp-wristed pansies (which of course it is perfectly ok to be, gay or straight).
- Houshalter 9y ago>Ok. I think it's also quite likely that they're not. And this study and other similar ones would seem to prove you wrong? >You'd think that the idea that gay men are sexually attracted to men because they are more feminine than other men would have died in the face of all the obvious counterexamples A few exceptions don't disprove a statistical correlation. Besides it's more complicated than just "gay people are more feminine". There are various hormones and biological interactions other than just testosterone. And the effects happen early on in development; Whether an adult has lots of testosterone and muscles is irrelevant. As this study shows, humans are much worse than this algorithm at identifying gay people. It's not merely a matter of "that face looks feminine" or human scorers would have done much better. Presumably many of the correlations are very small or subtle, but in aggregate they can get surprising accuracy.
- junto 9y ago> I think it's quite likely that both sexual orientation and jaw size are influenced by the same hormones (e.g. testosterone), since both features are involved in sexual dimorphism "Gay bears" would disagree with you: https://www.google.de/search?q=gay+bears https://www.google.de/search?q=gay+bears