6 ms·
>> The research found that gay men and women tended to have “gender-atypical” features, expressions and “grooming styles”, essentially meaning gay men appeared
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> The research found that gay men and women tended to have “gender-atypical” features, expressions and “grooming styles”, essentially meaning gay men appeared more feminine and vice versa. The data also identified certain trends, including that gay men had narrower jaws, longer noses and larger foreheads than straight men, and that gay women had larger jaws and smaller foreheads compared to straight women.
Besides the fact that this sounds deeply offensive for gay people, it also sounds terribly, awfully unlikely.
In fact, it reminds of the recent "phrenology" paper, where deep nets were used to, allegedly, "identify criminals from their faces":
https://www.technologyreview.com/s/602955/neural-network-learns-to-identify-criminals-by-their-faces/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/602955/neural-network-lea...
Nowadays we know that sexual orientation is something that is neither set in stone, nor absolute (people are known to change throughout their lives, as well as have occasional partners of the "other" sex, whichever is opposite to their normal orientation). So the very idea of an accurate "gaydar" is ludicrous in and of itself.
Finally, I wonder why anyone with an ounce of brains would seriously consider training a machine learning algorithm to recognise peoples' orientation. What morally justifiable practical purpose could there possibly be?
- kowdermeister 9y ago> Besides the fact that this sounds deeply offensive for gay people, it also sounds terribly, awfully unlikely. Offensive or not, sexual orientation is DNA based and so does your facial structure. What do you make of the claim that based on 5 photos they achieved a 90% success rate? That's significant.
- DanBC 9y ago> What do you make of the claim that based on 5 photos they achieved a 90% success rate? I'm reminded of Gerd Gigerenzer's book "Reckoning with risk". It's about medical testing, so forgive the language used: > A condition exists. There is a test for that condition. The test is good, but not perfect. If someone has the condition there is a 90% chance they'll return positive. If someone does not have the condition there is a 1% chance they'll return positive. About 1% of the population have the condition. Bob has the test, and it comes back positive. What's the probability Bob has the condition? Most people, even doctors who give these types of tests, get this wrong. The answer is about 50%, but most people put it much higher at 99% or 90%. I think the Guardian reporting is irresponsible because the general public do not understand percentages, and any reporter using percentages is misleading (albeit inadvertantly) the public. Here's a link to the book: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Reckoning-Risk-Learning-Live-Uncertainty/dp/0140297863/ https://www.amazon.co.uk/Reckoning-Risk-Learning-Live-Uncert...
- junto 9y ago> Offensive or not, sexual orientation is DNA based Sorry, but do you have a source for that claim?
- always_learning 9y agoThere is no source, the gender spectrum is fundamentally based on rejecting science
- hankhill 9y agoSooooo your source is gamergate/redpill bullshit propaganda. Okay. Have fun with that.
- junto 9y agoI think you're confusing biological sex and sexual orientation. The poster above stated that sexual orientation is based off your DNA. There is no gene that determines whether you heterosexual or gay. It has nothing to do with gender. You're just trying to proliferate your opinion that gender = biological sex. Anyone that is transgender would disagree with your opinion.
- kowdermeister 9y agoYes, about 114 sources on Wikipedia. "As of 1999, about 500 species, ranging from primates to gut worms, have been documented engaging in same-sex behaviors.[3][page needed][4] According to the organizers of the 2006 Against Nature? exhibit, it has been observed in 1,500 species.[5]" So if not DNA, then what else? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homosexual_behavior_in_animals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homosexual_behavior_in_animals
- foldr 9y agoThat's missing the point. The question was whether there's any evidence that homosexuality (in humans) is the result of a particular genetic specification. We don't know whether or not that's the case for the worms. All we know is that some worms exhibit homosexual behavior.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> What do you make of the claim that based on 5 photos they achieved a 90% success rate? I'm assuming their model is badly trained and overfitting or they're misinterpreting (though I hope not misrepresenting) their results.
- Houshalter 9y agoHow is this any more offensive or unlikely than stuff like digit ratio research? The idea that sexual orientation correlates with other features is very old, and this paper would seem to prove it. We've known for awhile that identical twins were much more likely than chance to share sexual orientations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biology_and_sexual_orientation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biology_and_sexual_orientation >Nowadays we know that sexual orientation is something that is neither set in stone, nor absolute I don't think that's really correct. Sure there are exceptions, but most people stick to one sexual orientation, or at least somewhere in between on a spectrum. Attempts at converting gay people to become straight were unsuccessful. In fact this was one of the biggest arguments for gay rights, that it isn't a choice and can't be changed. >What morally justifiable practical purpose could there possibly be? This proves a biological origin for sexuality. Which is both scientifically interesting, and a strong argument for gay rights in places where it is still seen as some kind of sin or mental illness. Anyone hypothetically using this tool to discriminate against homosexuals would have to admit the tool works of course. And that would mean homosexuality is biological, which would contradict their own beliefs. Lastly do you have any actual argument against the papers methodology? Or the phrenology paper you link for that matter. Your comment is basically "I don't like the conclusions so I won't accept them". That's not terribly scientific.
- nostromo123 9y ago> Your comment is basically "I don't like the conclusions so I won't accept them". That's not terribly scientific. The whole "gender is a social construct" movement is based on rejecting actual scientific evidence, so don't be surprised...
- yorwba 9y agoThe distinction between sex as biological and gender as social seems useful to me. It makes "gender is a social construct" a tautology, but doesn't in itself reject scientific evidence. It's just that inasmuch you have evidence that some behavior is biologically determined, the behavior is less amenable to analysis in terms of only gender.
- 9y ago
- mobiletelephone 9y agoI also find it ethically troubling. The commercial application is probably advertising.
- nostromo123 9y ago> Nowadays we know that sexual orientation is something that is neither set in stone, nor absolute At best, the only thing we know is that this is true for some people. You say it yourself: "people are known" to change / have sexual partners of both genders -- because such people are an exception! These people are a minority, and you really can't generalise and affirm that this is the rule for the majority.
- hankhill 9y agoSorry, you got downvoted to oblivion because HN now believes phrenology is a valid science. Also, good job downvoters for making yourself look like idiots.