3 ms·
> but is there some systematic way to show that they're in fact more successful? Please define "successful." If "success" is wide use, then you have defined yo
by KirinDave 16y ago
> but is there some systematic way to show that they're in fact more successful?
Please define "successful." If "success" is wide use, then you have defined your success in the most un-profound of manners.
> It just seems to me from casual observation that the success of Lisps is disproportionately low (not to be straw-manned into zero)
I'm not going to play this game with you. You've defined nonsensical metrics and then demand we play by them. Any specific examples I give (of which you could easily get for yourself with 5 minutes and a search engine) will be dismissed as "anecdotes" as you move your goalposts.
I do not care what you think, because I do not think you're interested in considering what I have to say. Let's enjoy our mutual indifference.
- WilliamLP 16y ago> Please define "successful." "Profitable", compared to using another language. There are many objective ways this could be shown that wouldn't be vulnerable to being shot down by a non-falsifiability engine (i.e. any data I don't like is just an anecdote). For example, someone could attempt to sample startups at different time periods and look at financial growth over some timeframe. Basically I'm looking for a metric that would show that pure functional language choices matter in a positive way. Any metric would fascinate me. Even success in contest problems of some type, when others had a chance to compete on equal footing would be something.
- KirinDave 16y ago> There are many objective ways this could be shown that wouldn't be vulnerable to being shot down by a non-falsifiability engine (i.e. any data I don't like is just an anecdote). For example, someone could attempt to sample startups at different time periods and look at financial growth over some timeframe. Can you show these for any other language? In a way that's not arbitrary and self-selecting. > For example, someone could attempt to sample startups at different time periods and look at financial growth over some timeframe. Thanks for the laugh.
- WilliamLP 16y ago> Can you show these for any other language? In a way that's not arbitrary and self-selecting. I suspect you could have sampled Java web startups vs those still using C, Perl and CGI back during the time of Java's explosive growth and seen a systematic difference in profitability. > Thanks for the laugh. So any idea that there could be some statistical correlation between language choice and any kind of measured success is, on the face of it, absurd?
- chromatic 16y agoI suspect you could have sampled Java web startups vs those still using C, Perl and CGI back during the time of Java's explosive growth and seen a systematic difference in profitability. Amazon.com has made a lot of money, hasn't it? So any idea that there could be some statistical correlation between language choice and any kind of measured success is, on the face of it, absurd? A relevant statistical correlation? Yes.