4 ms·
Why do we need to number people anyway? People are very consistent with spelling their own names. This combined with a birth date and/or a birth city should b
by reaperducer 9y ago
Why do we need to number people anyway? People are very consistent with spelling their own names. This combined with a birth date and/or a birth city should be enough to uniquely identify anyone.
Think about passwords. A SSN is only nine digits, 0-9.
JohnHarrySmith19900101NewYork is far more secure. And doesn't dehumanize the recipient.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> People are very consistent with spelling their own names. Is this true of all people? > This combined with a birth date and/or a birth city should be enough to uniquely identify anyone. For common names and large cities, probably not. > JohnHarrySmith19900101NewYork is far more secure. No, it's not; SSNs aren't passwords, and shouldn't need to be “secure” in that sense, but names aren't secret and birth dates and locations are easily discoverable (and the combination of all three is frequently publicly announced!), so this would be less secure.
- mikeyouse 9y ago> Is this true of all people? Not even remotely.. My name has a space and an accent, it's always different. My wife's name is spelled differently on each of her birth certificate, drivers license, and social security card. And we have 'traditional' names.
- dx034 9y ago> For common names and large cities, probably not. Would be interesting to see statistics for that. It wouldn't be New York in this case, but for example Brooklyn or Queens. Even for the most popular name combinations, the number of people with the same name born on one day in one administrative area will be extremely low. Esp if you require middle names to be included.
- tripzilch 9y agoOr you can just use a number. Because unlike names, you can assume one thing about individuals in a population and that is that they are countable. You still just need 33 bits of information to identify any human on the planet, anyway. (post-singularity, evolved into an ever-merging amorphous network of consciousnesses, we can use multidimensional fractal subsets of R^n, but we'll cross that bridge when we get there)
- acdha 9y agoThis is definitely not reliable in large cities, and it would have privacy concerns not to mention failing to handle people who don't follow the same naming conventions you do or who don't have day-level precision on their birth date. See http://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-b... and especially http://latanyasweeney.org/work/identifiability.html http://latanyasweeney.org/work/identifiability.html Numbers have the nice advantage of not assuming structure, character set, etc. and allow changes for edge cases such as someone escaping an abusive spouse — see the full list of reasons at https://faq.ssa.gov/link/portal/34011/34019/article/3789/can-i-change-my-social-security-number https://faq.ssa.gov/link/portal/34011/34019/article/3789/can...
- thephyber 9y agoThere are 8 billion people on Earth. You are a number sometimes. It's okay for {your passport, your driver's license, your social security card, your credit card, your bank accounts, etc} to treat your account as a number. The SSN just acts as a (largely) unique identifier. In the US, it also serves as proof that someone is eligible to work in the country. It's also the primary key for the account which collects my Social Security earnings over my career. You are asking the wrong question. Neither of the keys you identify, whether it be "123-45-6789" or "JohnHarrySmith19900101NewYork", is "secure". Perhaps the latter has more entropy, but it's not the equivalent of your password when you log into a website -- it's the equivalent of your username. When you fill out a federal form like your tax form, anyone who sees the form sees your Social Security number. If we were talking about making Social Security secure, your Social Security card would be plastic/metal and have a chip in it, similar to an EMV chip. It would have a private key which can be used to sign digital contracts and can be used to generate login tokens. It's effectively a private key that generates different public keys for each interaction/transaction you need to perform with it. Right now, Social Security is entirely about "what you know" with an easy to fabricate "what you have" and has no "who you are" factors.
- dx034 9y agoIn Germany, this is how identification works to some degree. You have an ID card number but this changes with every card. There is a permanent tax number but this isn't used for anything but tax purposes. In the end, identification can be done by name, birth date and place of birth. You'll find these requirements on many official forms. This is fairly unique and ties to birth certificates which can be obtained with this information. Even if all databases were erased, this data could restore registers (as birth certificates have a paper copy).