5 ms·
The Uncomfortable Truth About Campus Rape Policy
- whymsicalburito 9y agoSo much for innocent until proven guilty.
- belovedeagle 9y agoIndeed, this is "guilty even when proved innocent".
- phailhaus 9y agoThat's because this is a crime that is very difficult to prove either way, and people are erring on the side of caution.
- jackvalentine 9y agoThe side of caution certainly changes depending on whose perspective you take!
- gozur88 9y agoThe "side of caution" is innocence.
- phailhaus 9y agoNo, clearly the "side of caution" people are taking is on the side of accuser. Given that a significant percentage of rapes go unreported, people believe it's more likely that the accuser is telling the truth than not. The problem is that there is very little evidence of rape other than personal testimony.
- gozur88 9y agoOh, I see what people are saying. It's just wrong. You can't convict people of a crime that could put them in jail for decades purely on an accusation.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoIs it weird for me to want more than a journalist finding the most likeable victim/perpetrator and telling the story from his side before launching into their pitch about changing how rapes are dealt with? How is that any different than relaying some horrifying tale of abuse that wasn't dealt with properly under the old system? The only information it provides is telling us what the journalist wants us to think. How about some stats? Some numbers? Some experts?
- Grustaf 9y agoI agree that it's irrelevant that the guy was so gifted, even if he had been a stupid and awful person he shouldn't be punished for something he didn't do. What I don't really understand is why he was punished at all. Even according to her account he hasn't committed any crime. I'm not sure you need stats here though, if the presumption of innocence has been abandoned that is a very serious regardless of how many times it has made a difference so far.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoHave you actually read her account? Or are you basing your opinion on the excerpts in this story alone? If you have a link to more information I'd be interested to read it.
- Grustaf 9y agoOnly on these excerpts. It seems a bit too absurd to not quote the actual accusation if there was one but then maybe the other poster is right, maybe at UMass every sexual act is presumed to be rape, consent needs to be proven.
- bitwize 9y agoPresumption of innocence doesn't mean what you think it means. In most crimes involving consent, it is only necessary that the prosecution show that the defendant committed the act constituting the crime in order to establish guilt. Consent is an affirmative defense which must be proven by the defense. If I take your car it's theft unless consent can be established (i.e., you loaned me your keys). Similarly if I punch you in the stomach it's assault unless consent can be established (i dunno, you said "hit me in the gut! I want to see how strong my abs are.") Rape and sexual assault are the only times when consent is assumed and its lack must be proven. If Bob has sex with Alice, and Alice later alleges rape, that should be taken as prima facie evidence that a rape occurred. It should be on Bob to prove that the activity was consensual. Anything else vastly increases the risk of sexual assault and reduces the likelihood that offenders will be punished.
- squozzer 9y agoI'm beginning to wonder if we'll have to develop new dating norms (neo-Victorianism?) in order to cope with this problem. I don't think the law will help much because presumption of innocence gives rapists too much leeway ("he said, she said") and presumption of guilt invites false accusations, both of which are huge political problems. Or we could accelerate current social trends and develop a formal caste system, whereby a female's word is always accepted prima facie against males ("he admitted to being on the grassy knoll"), and where male testimony is not admissible in court cases involving females.