3 ms·
You're confusing violence with coercion. Violence cares about physicality; coercion does not. While others may think the distinction is too thin to care, I care
by threatofrain 9y ago
You're confusing violence with coercion. Violence cares about physicality; coercion does not. While others may think the distinction is too thin to care, I care to elaborate on the nuance, so I prefer to have two terms for what I see as two concepts.
An intersection exists somewhere, but not all violence is coercive, and not all coercion is violent.
When the government collects taxes from you, it is coercive. The underlying threat of violence is gated far from you. Imagine a government that didn't understand the full range of coercion, and only had violence in its tool bin for collecting government revenue. Then you wouldn't need two separate terms, as the government clearly isn't seeing any nuance either.
- sbenitoj 9y agoFair point! The broader point I'm trying to make is that violence (or the threat of violence) is wrong in all cases except self-defense (including the protection of private property).