4 ms·
I really don't hope that is the future of the desktop. I mean really? Is that what we have to look forward to? In my world there can be no talk about the futur
by ThomPete 16y ago
I really don't hope that is the future of the desktop. I mean really? Is that what we have to look forward to?
In my world there can be no talk about the future of the desktop unless:
The desktop metaphor and the current filesystem disappears.
My machine starts to monitor what I do and actually use this (The Ghost Protocol)
The machine starts to connect everything I do and build contextual maps automatically. For instance, I receive a picture in my mail and throw it into photoshop. When I then want to retrieve it I can not only look for name.psd but also for the context (Phil send it to me by mail)
Then we can talk about a the future of the desktop.
- logic 16y agoYour point about the system watching what you do and doing something useful with that information reminded me of some work a few years back by Nat Friedman on "Dashboard" that had me pretty excited at the time: http://nat.org/dashboard/ http://nat.org/dashboard/ It was a shame to not actually see that go anywhere other than the prototype stage.
- ThomPete 16y agoThat sure is a shame as it seems like it would be pretty useful. There need to be more thinking going into non-interaction. Actually having to interact with the computer as much as we do about the things we do, surely can't be the goal in itself. I want my machine to make plenty of choices for me and present me with information not have me do it manually. I think that is what pisses me off the most right now. There is something wrong and primitive about normal human beings still having to interact with their machines to get proper information.
- dkersten 16y agoThis idea is something I've talked about many times with various people. Even posted about it on stackoverflow and blogged about it once. Computers are better at boring and mundane maintenance tasks than we are - so they should do them. Users shouldn't have to think about such low level concepts as filesystems, directory structures, saving files and so on. It should be managed behind the scenes.
- ams6110 16y agoI think anything beyond the simplest of automatic organization schemes will end up being confusing. I like to organize my files the way I want them organized. I can probably deal with all my pictures showing up under "My Pictures" but if it starts to try to do something like classify my documents by content it's going to depart from what I think "makes sense" pretty quickly.
- anigbrowl 16y agoIt does seem like there will be some tentative steps in this direction. But I agree we need to see more - I like your idea of a content-neutral tagging agent that draws inferences based on my use patterns rather than a committee's agreed use cases.
- mgunes 16y agoTake a look at Zeitgeist and GNOME Activity Journal, which haven't been accepted as modules into GNOME 3.0, but are already usable and will almost certainly be part of the 3.x series in the next few releases. http://live.gnome.org/Zeitgeist http://live.gnome.org/Zeitgeist http://live.gnome.org/GnomeActivityJournal http://live.gnome.org/GnomeActivityJournal
- sliverstorm 16y agoWhy is everyone interested in the filesystem going away? As long as users posses more than 20 files, organizing them is helpful. Notice one of the most requested features on the Kindle was folders for the user interface. The result they gave us isn't folders, and the actual filesystem is abstracted, but it's effectively the same.
- megablast 16y agoThe majority do not understand file systems, that is why. What do you NOT understand about this? Why do people keep making this comment. I like file systems, I understand them, but I used to program dos interrupts, and actually reading sectors of the drive. But I can understand filesystems, a lot of people don't. What people want is an all their photos grouped together, all the vides grouped together, all their documents together. They don't understand the different between the desktop, user folder, trash can etc...
- extension 16y agoSo when I want to attach something to an email, I have to go to the app for whatever kind of data it is and find the "share" button, which will be in a different place for each app, if it's even there at all. Ditto if I want to copy it to a USB stick, add it to my Dropbox, upload it to a website, etc. The fundamental ideas behind a filesystem, packaging all data in a generic container and allowing arbitrary grouping of the containers, are extremely straightforward and intuitive, not to mention incredibly useful. What throws people for a loop is having to share their filesystem with magic invisible gremlins that leave inscrutable files all over the place. Most filesystems come pre-loaded with mountains of this junk, which the user is made keenly aware of when they are banished to some small niche directory. But the gremlins won't even stay out of the niche; they are constantly creating folders and dumping mysterious config files there, behind the user's back. The solution to this problem is clear and simple. A filesystem, from the user's perspective, should be empty when it comes out of the box, or at most contain a few items that the user knows exactly what they are. From then and forever, nothing should ever appear in the filesystem except what the user explicitly put there. The user is free to create, move, copy, rename or delete any file without unexpected side-effects. It seems obvious to me that filesystems should work this way and there would be no big usability issue if they did. The problem is, we have all this old baggage attached to the filesystem, both conceptually and practically, and we are throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
- angrycoder 16y ago"My machine starts to monitor what I do and actually use this (The Ghost Protocol)" Yeah, the last time they tried this it was called Clippy.