6 ms·
So I've only ever seen articles lambasting the guy for claiming to have invented email (and rightly so from my view as well). I'm curious, is there anyone who
by jedberg 9y ago
So I've only ever seen articles lambasting the guy for claiming to have invented email (and rightly so from my view as well).
I'm curious, is there anyone who supports his claim other than him and his family? Is there anyone on his side?
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoGiven we have documented evidence of ARPANET transmitting electronic messages before his claimed invention of them, there isn't much room for rational disagreement.
- jedberg 9y agoYeah I literally know the people who invented email long before this guy, I guess my question was more along the lines of "is anyone fooled by him".
- joatmon-snoo 9y agoI remember a couple of articles by CNN etc when this whole shitshow started that couldn't tell left from right about his claims.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoRead the judge's opinion [1]. It's well-reasoned and goes into the fact that there is no singular "inventor" of email as well as some sources, e.g. Noam Chomsky, who agreed with the plaintiff's claims, at least in the past. [1] https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/3987555-Gov-Uscourts-Mad-185980-48-0.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/3987555-Gov-Uscourts...
- joatmon-snoo 9y agoAlso the fact that he has literally nothing to do with SMTP or any email protocol that people have actually used, ever. Ayyadurai is a pathetic, miserable excuse for a joke. His lawsuit should have been dismissed as a matter of summary judgment; the fact that it has made it this far is so, so very sad.
- abalone 9y agoIn fairness, it depends on how you define "e-mail". Some of those early ARPANET messaging systems were not exactly usable by a typical office worker with the conventions we take for granted now. That's really the crux of the issue here, and there's certainly room for debate about the minimum feature set.
- throwawayknecht 9y ago> is there anyone who supports his claim other than him and his family? Is there anyone on his side? The law firm backing him is the one that seems to have been founded / bankrolled by Peter Thiel primarily for the purpose of suing Gawker. And Ayyadurai was also suing Gawker, also represented by the same lawyer. Techdirt also not having been particularly kind to Thiel, there's a good chance he's at least one supporter of Ayyadurai.
- moomin 9y agoIndeed, and ultimately someone that rich doesn't need to win every case. He can just keep racking up the costs.
- hyperpape 9y agoI've never been able to find anything definitive about Thiel and Ayyadurai. I did a longer search last year, but here are links I dug up just now. http://gizmodo.com/peter-thiel-wont-say-if-hes-bankrolling-lawsuit-against-1791652277 http://gizmodo.com/peter-thiel-wont-say-if-hes-bankrolling-l..., http://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-hiltzik-email-invention-20170227-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-hiltzik-email-.... That said, to my knowledge, Thiel has refused to publicly deny it. If SV had more scruples, he'd be forced to go on the record about it, because funding Ayyadurai would be indefensible.
- throwawayknecht 9y agoIt's definitive that Thiel put Harder on retainer with a mandate to find people interested in suing Gawker. When the Bollea case proved promising, that got further support. Regardless of whether Ayyadurai's cases got more support from Thiel, without Thiel Harder isn't there to do this in the first place.
- johansch 9y agoWe have Noam Chomsky, who of course, has no idea whatsoever about this (it is very far from his field), but still has no issue supporting him: https://www.theverge.com/2012/6/13/3082157/noam-chomsky-shiva-ayyadurai-email-inventor https://www.theverge.com/2012/6/13/3082157/noam-chomsky-shiv...
- lern_too_spel 9y agoThe source for the Chomsky endorsement is the charlatan "inventor's" own website. The Verge doesn't check it's sources.
- lightbyte 9y agoAnecdotal, but my Indian-American coworkers strongly believe him.
- AstralStorm 9y agoMisguided nationalism has many adherents.
- abalone 9y agoYes. Chomsky knew him when he was at MIT and has come to his defense.[1] I admit my initial reaction was "of course this guy's a charlatan," and read 10 things that seems to support that. For example here is a review of the development of e-mail primitives prior to Ayyadurai's work.[2] It starts out pretty level headed, but later on in the updates to Ayyadurai's responses it gets more defensive and flustered in tone, and the technical arguments become impenetrable -- which to me are signs that there's more substance to Ayyadurai's claim than you might think. The heart of the matter is that many of the primitives of what became e-mail developed in the 70s, but the question is what constituted a fully integrated user-friendly inter-organizational system. Ayyadurai's showpiece of evidence is that Dave Crocker stated in 1977 that "At this stage, no attempt is being made to emulate a full-scale inter-organization mail system" that confirmed to the "cognitive model of a regular office-memo system".[3] Crocker has since walked back[4] that claim and said his report doesn't say what it says... It's very odd. It very clearly states, right in the summary, that the "cognitive models" and "psychological aspects" did not yet match what "typical users" expected of messaging systems. And looking back through [2], I see a lot of words but no evidence that there was a functioning, user-friendly system that addressed these "psychological aspects" prior to Ayyadurai. So basically, it does seem plausible that he brought these concepts together in a way no one had quite done before, in his basement when he was 14 or whatever, and him being all self-congratualtory about it really pisses the "establishment Internet guys" off that worked on all these primitives. Maybe it's me, but honestly this all smacks of the classic "engineers don't appreciate UX design" conflict. "Oh you just figured out some UI stuff.. that's not real engineering..." [1] http://www.inventorofemail.com/noam-chomsky-on-invention-of-email-va-shiva-ayyadurai.asp http://www.inventorofemail.com/noam-chomsky-on-invention-of-... [2] http://www.sigcis.org/ayyadurai http://www.sigcis.org/ayyadurai [3] https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/3318894-R2134.html#document/p18/a338655 https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/3318894-R2134.html#d... [4] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/06/shivas-war-one-mans-quest-to-convince-the-world-that-he-invented-e-mail/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/06/shivas-war-one-m...
- scj 9y agoReading your post, and the linked article, I'd be interested in examples where the previous systems failed to provide expected functionality... My expectation of email today is "I enter some address(es), define the addresses as TO, CC, and BCC, type a message into the body (or extend an existing message) and send the contents to a server which then re-transmits it as necessary." That's the core of email... Every email program I've ever used can handle those elements, sometimes with only plaintext, but that's the core I learned decades ago. I wonder when that would have been available. I suspect that multiple people should be credited with advancing this tech. It is likely that the title "inventor of email" is a one-sided and incorrect view of history. Sutherland and Engelbart pioneered GUI technology, but I wouldn't want to use the system either created. However to deny them credit in the development of the GUI (Engelbart in particular), would be re-writing history.