3 ms·
> I'd be surprised if someone manages to slip in an invalid count and not be detected: Most crucial voting points are monitored by people from polling institute
by majewsky 9y ago
> I'd be surprised if someone manages to slip in an invalid count and not be detected: Most crucial voting points are monitored by people from polling institutes that want results as early as possible.
That particular part does not protect from rigging. What the polling institutes do is taking a very small representative sample of voters and conducting an exit poll (they essentially have another voting office set up where people can vote a second time in secret for their exit poll). However, if you're clever about how you rig the election, exit polls won't notice that because of the small sample size.
- pfg 9y agoYou're right about exit polls not being particularly effective here, unless you're being very obvious with the rigging. Luckily, the published results can also be cross-checked by the volunteers - often, but not exclusively representatives of parties up for election - that actually count the paper ballots and observe the process. This process ensures that a very large number of people from diverse political groups would have to be in on it in order to rig the election. Any attack via this software would be detected with very high likelihood. However, the bigger problem would be the impact on the public's trust in the voting process. It's very likely that such an election would have to be repeated (as has happened recently in Austria, due to procedural reasons).
- usrusr 9y agoYour last paragraph is essential to making sense of this whole story. The same sentiment is also present in the original report, on page four. The institutions who bought that software were like aware of those safety nets, which is why they had no problem buying from a vendor that basically looks like a two-man Delphi shop (no idea what they actually used). Had the system been more critical, we would probably be talking about a whole different set of shocking security problems, in some absurdly overengineered T-Systems monstrosity. Personally I feel less unsafe with paper and the obvious insecurities of a glorified excel sheet than with a titanic money-sink twenty layers deep that is feeding an army of salespersons and lobbyists paid to silence every voice of concern. What the institutions who bought this thing underestimated is the terrible impact a caught manipulation (and even this preemptive disclosure, despite being orders of magnitude preferable to only finding out after a caught manipulation) would have on trust, and the spring time for radicals that would follow. A caught manipulation could destabilize the country more than a cruise missile hitting the Reichstag.
- Xylakant 9y agoNo, polling institutes do not only do exit polls. They also collect the final numbers. I've had that job a fair number of times and my mother actually does that this year at her polling station. They want the official numbers as early as possible, before they are announced on the official site.
- majewsky 9y agoInteresting, thanks for that insight.