4 ms·
This is guy is something different (not that it would make his ideas worth any less, more on that later). Some of his recent efforts: Satellite Internet [0] (
by bipson 9y ago
This is guy is something different (not that it would make his ideas worth any less, more on that later).
Some of his recent efforts:
Satellite Internet [0] (kudos whatidonteven) - I don't think he thought this one through. What is wrong with the current approach? Should we really erect wires in outer space?
He is currently kind of harassing the IETF via mailing lists about IPv10, threatening "If the ideas explained on these drafts will be used, discussed or published by the ietf, legal actions will be taken." [1] - not really how the IETF works.
The version number as "ingenious" 4+6 is annoying, IMO. That's not how version numbers work?
His drawing on his his very own routing protocol - KRP - are also something [2]. Although the quality of his drawings has nothing to do with his ideas per se, it seems he rushed it together in an afternoon.
I don't want to say that he is overestimating his own intelligence, rather that he is underestimating the efforts, hard work and intelligence of everyone else working in this field mostly professionally. His proposals can not easily be judged, because they dismiss almost everything that others have done previously. Why should so many smart people have missed these (obvious/simple) solutions? We are where we are for a reason. You need a good chain of arguments to "dismiss" the current state of the art.
[0] https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-omar-si-00 https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-omar-si-00
[1] http://ietf.10.n7.nabble.com/RE-IPv10-KRP-and-RRP-IDs-Removal-td534031.html#a534090 http://ietf.10.n7.nabble.com/RE-IPv10-KRP-and-RRP-IDs-Remova...
[2] http://khaledroutingprotocol.blogspot.co.at/ http://khaledroutingprotocol.blogspot.co.at/
- stephen_g 9y ago> What is wrong with the current approach? He seems to actually be completly unaware that satellite internet exists at all... (Judging from the second and third points of the introduction). Who knows what's going on though - maybe he's just young and inexperienced? This is exactly the kind of thing I might have done as a 13 year old if I had stumbled on the IETF...
- mmirate 9y agoIn other words: "this entire HN submission is spam".
- anoother 9y agoHis address is also interesting: The Road 6th of October City, Giza Egypt
- mcguire 9y agoWell, 6th of October City is a place. (https://goo.gl/maps/z141gu8cMYB2 https://goo.gl/maps/z141gu8cMYB2)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]