4 ms·
Well, obviously it sucks that it took so long, and so much damage has been done, but nonetheless... this is great news, if true. Let's just hope that this new
by mindcrime 16y ago
Well, obviously it sucks that it took so long, and so much damage has been done, but nonetheless... this is great news, if true. Let's just hope that this new cap holds up until the relief wells are finished and things are truly under control.
Wonder how long the cleanup process will take? Can something of this magnitude even ever be completely cleaned up?
- mrfish 16y agoI think it can. But the damages are too late to prevent.
- thetrumanshow 16y agoI was under the distinct impression that this was only a test to gather data, and even if things go well, the cap is coming back off in 48 hours or less.
- shaddi 16y agoIf everything goes well, they (Adm. Allen) announced they would be leaving the cap in place. Only if things go wrong will they reopen the seals. Even if they need to reopen it, the plan is to capture the oil into ships using pipes connected to this new cap. Edit: I can't remember the source for this; I believe I heard it on the Diane Rehm show yesterday. If I can find the source I'll update.
- thetrumanshow 16y agohttp://www.cnn.com/2010/US/07/15/gulf.oil.disaster/index.html?hpt=C1 http://www.cnn.com/2010/US/07/15/gulf.oil.disaster/index.htm... "BP cautioned that the oil cutoff, while welcomed, won't go beyond the 48 hours." Yeah, you're right... it did go on to say that 'valves' will be opened and oil would be siphoned off. I didn't realize there were going to be pipes either. :)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- uxp 16y agoThinking from an engineer's perspective, this cap has effectively shut off oil flow from the wellhead. We've heard before, that the pressure of the oil spewing from the wellhead is very high. Possibly the reason that this well has had so much trouble to begin with. So the longer this cap prevents oil from leaking out, the longer there is a possibility for the pressure to cause damage to the cap and start the cycle all over again. It seems like a very responsible thing to open up some valves on the cap and collect some oil to reduce the pressure on the cap.
- Psyonic 16y ago"Can something of this magnitude even ever be completely cleaned up?" Likely no. Certainly improvements can and will be made, but there will be irreversible damage, at least on a human timescale.
- ams6110 16y agoCrude oil is a natural substance. It leaks out of the earth all over the place. This is obviously an extreme case, but I think that with time, the environment will absorb this and return to some sort of normalcy.
- ericd 16y agoOn a long enough timescale, most things can be handled by the environment. That timescale may extend past the human timescale in many instances, which is generally viewed as unacceptable.
- code_duck 16y agoThere is never going to be a return to normalcy for this area. It has already been under relentless pressure from human activities, to the point where we have a dead zone the size of Rhode Island floating around near this area already due to criminally irresponsible over-use of agricultural chemicals. Way too much pollution has already been coming out of Houston and New Orleans for a long time. BP wasn't satisfied dumping millions of gallons of oil into the water, they also felt it was necessary to dump hundreds of thousands of gallons of unnecessarily toxic dispersant chemicals into the water, mainly for cosmetic PR purposes. Louisiana's marshes are already in serious physical decline from the change in water flow and silt buildup caused by hydrologic engineering in the area. As far as something being natural, that has little to do with it's ability to destroy ecosystems. Sure, many synthetic chemicals are worse, but don't we have plenty of examples of very harmful natural phenomena? Radiation is natural, for instance. Perhaps you'd like to absorb a couple thousand rems, and see if the naturalness makes a difference in your return to normalcy. Or drink a big glass of oil, why not! It's natural! Several thousand dolphins, sea turtles, jellyfish, fish, sting rays, eels and octopi surely gave that a try recently.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- fletchowns 16y agoI don't know about calling it great news...it's just not more bad news.