2 ms·
Not specific to the web, no. But note how few have done it, and how many people resist it (application-specific firewalls and paranoia over applications "phoni
by Groxx 16y ago
Not specific to the web, no. But note how few have done it, and how many people resist it (application-specific firewalls and paranoia over applications "phoning home"). A large part of the point of all this is how much easier it is for the web, and how much more readily people accept it.
Though how is not having a crack not unique to the web? And before you say you can send different versions of the application, remember there is copy/paste. The millions (billions?) of premium-version pirated copies of applications floating around suggest otherwise. But when was the last time you saw additional Google storage on a torrent network?
And no, currently, browsers aren't up to the task of replacing desktop apps. Nowhere near. NaCl provides a rather large open door for the possibility, though, and you can bet other browsers will follow suit; it's a killer feature.
- dkersten 16y agoThough how is not having a crack not unique to the web? Its not unique to the web. It has little to do with the web and more to do with a thin-client client-server model. Take, for example, MMORPG's - these are typically dificult or impossible to crack (sure, some have replacement servers, but they're rarely as good as the original and you can do the same for SaaS web apps too, if you really wanted to). I'm mainly arguing against the idea that the webs positive features are unique to the web - they're not, they come from the webs underlying technologies (client-server, thin-client..) and these could be implemented by desktop apps, if one really wanted to. The one place where the web wins hands down is user acceptance. Everybody has a browser and nobody minds the browser phoning home, as you said, yet they are paranoid about desktop apps doing so. This is where the browser wins - the rest can be done elsewhere too. NaCl may change everyting, though, when it catches on. That will be certainly interesting to see and, while I dislike web apps right now, NaCl has a good chance of changing my mind. I'm certianly not against the things you mentioned - they ARE desireable traits, after all.