10 ms·
Scotland plans to make petrol and diesel cars obsolete by 2032
- stretchwithme 9y agoI've decided to reduce the use of internal combustion engines by 90% worldwide in the next 50 years. That's right. I'm setting this goal. But then it's easy to set goals in the distant future when there are inevitable trends that will already make it happen.
- prawn 9y agoA headline/goal is unlikely to come without practical, supporting actions which nudge people towards that goal. The headline is something though that spreads and is repeated frequently, getting more and more people thinking about their actions - collectively these things will get people to that goal. I don't think it's without value.
- stretchwithme 9y agoThe move away from ICEs is already well underway, in my opinion. Headlines aren't going to slow it down or accelerate it. Companies like Tesla make it happen.
- jkingsbery 9y agoThe article didn't say what the source of the energy powering those charging stations will be in 2032. Presumably much of it will still be carbon-based.
- fish_fan 9y agoMuch of is a nice hedge word here; it could be anything from supplying power off wind peak to providing the majority of power on average.
- mikeyouse 9y agoNah, less than 30% of their electricity is carbon based today. They won't have any problem decarbonizing entirely over the next 15 years. They actually just shuttered their last coal plant in 2016, so I'm curious what last year's generation numbers looked like. http://www.gov.scot/Topics/Statistics/Browse/Business/TrendElectricity http://www.gov.scot/Topics/Statistics/Browse/Business/TrendE... https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/environment/2016/mar/24/longannet-power-station-closes-coal-power-scotland https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/environment...
- jkingsbery 9y agoCool, I didn't realize. Learned something new today.
- pjc50 9y agoScotland is something of a leader in renewable technologies. Mostly wind, although there have been various attempts to extract power from the tides and waves that have not yet been competitive.
- sparkzilla 9y agoYes, it's great how our world-leading scenery has been enhanced by massive wind farms. I look forward seeing them on every hilltop. Save the planet!
- pjc50 9y agoQuite a bit of the scenery is itself an artificial environment of grouse moors. Or previous bits of energy generation like the "byngs" (mining spoil heaps) or the now-demolished Cockenzie power station that was visible from basically anywhere on the firth of Forth. And let's not forget the world-leading aesthetic beauty of Torness' modernist coastal cube.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gozur88 9y agoThat's a weird headline. Governments can ban technology, but they can't make it obsolete.
- iainmerrick 9y agoSounds like you're assuming a ban on combustion engines is the only thing a government can do, but they have plenty of other options. They could offer tax incentives for EVs, for example, or fund research into EV technology.
- afsina 9y ago...by subsidizing with oil exports. Like Norway.
- pjc50 9y agoThe revenue from the oil fields goes to the UK government, not the Scottish government, a subject of some controversy.
- afsina 9y agoThanks. No wonder they could not secede before.
- pjc50 9y agoSecession or "UDI" as some people keep talking up would give the Scottish Government the oil revenue, as well as several billion other headaches and be a disaster. The only viable route to independence is the legal one. Unless we get the "full collapse" Brexit.
- therealidiot 9y agoDoes any manufacturer make 'simple' EVs? I mean that as in fewer computers. My current car is about 18 years old and besides the ECU there's not that much going on. No touchscreen controls, no telemetry. I hope that one day I'd be able to switch to an EV but I'm disappointed by most of them (and yes I understand I'm a minority in disliking smart everything)
- kagamine 9y agoYou're not as alone as the media might lead you to think. There is a lot of hype and marketing going on with EVs to get people to adopt this change in technology that is consumer funded. I agree with you, there are too many nice-to-have features in cars that add to the [unnecessary] complexity of these vehicles. Late 90 cars started with this, adding air-bag suspension and corner-leveling systems and it has since grown into automatic windscreen wipers when it rains, automatic lights when it gets dark (like you aren't sitting there looking out the big window), touch screens and gadgets. Some things are useful, for example electric mirrors, others not so much for example 5 different memory positions for the driver's seat where before you just pulled the lever under the seat to move it forward or back. IN case you think this is not a problem it can cause problems with other critical electronic components: I had a dealership's workshop turn off my electric seats in the BCU (BCU = body control unit, the PC of the car) and this meant that because the ABS is linked through the seat, something to do with collisions and the seat moving, the ABS warning light came on leading to a MOT/EU-control fail. I had to buy a code-reader machine to turn it back on myself. On models of this car without electric seats this is not a problem. So many other things I could mention like this example. Simplicity, as I a m sure HN coders and the like will agree, is best.
- WalterBright 9y agoI've had several cars with electric windows. Most of them would fail, usually when it was raining and you needed to raise them. None of my cars with hand cranked windows has never failed at getting the windows up :-) I've had a car that had sensors for everything. Half of the failures requiring expensive repairs were sensor failures. Sigh.
- yCloser 9y agoAll the "plans to do stuff by 2050" are completely useless. The one who did the plan will not be in charge till that date, someone else will take over and change/destroy the plan (or worse, add +20 years), and in politics this is simply the way to go. This is procastination at his finest and means "doing nothing now".
- michaelt 9y agoIf you introduce a ban on petrol vehicles that starts immediately (or within the life of one parliament) people will bitch that that you've destroyed the value of the car they expected to drive for years, the world doesn't have enough EV production capacity, that the mechanics aren't set up for it, that there aren't enough charge stations, that there isn't enough electricity production capacity, etc etc. I agree it's politically difficult to do this slowly - but it's even harder to do it quickly :)
- smcl 9y agoI see the point, but this doesn't necessarily mean its an empty gesture as there is a precedent. Back in 2005 the Scottish government aimed for 18% of electricity consumed to be generated by renewable sources by 2020 (later adjusted to 50%). This was met and exceeded in 2015 (59%). Granted this is a smaller timeline but there is real backing for renewables here, especially since the collapse of oil prices hit the local oil industry
- andygates 9y agoIn the case of electric vehicles, the long timeline means they can ease charging facilities in without having a massive spend - they just come in when infrastructure gets renewed. Visible charging facilities are one of the things that breaks the "chicken and egg" adoption problem.
- StephenMelon 9y agoGreat to see the Scottish Government leading on renewable energy again. I was worried that adding over 30 million cars to the grid would cause problems but having looked into it it looks like it would add less than half a percentage point onto UK energy consumption at current utilisation rates. I do wonder how it will affect the PCP market though as the future value of petrol and diesel cars will presumably become more difficult to predict?
- pjc50 9y agoI'm very much in favour of this, but the article alludes to one of the problems: the "long tail" of remote life. The majority of the Scottish population lives in commuter range of Glasgow or Edinburgh. Here in Edinburgh we already have some hybrid buses so I can see a change to pure electric happening gradually as they become available. There's also no shortage of renewable energy to power the things. But there are also some people who live remarkably remote lives in the Highlands and Islands. In the Highlands "range anxiety" is very real if your nearest large shop is 100 miles away. Whereas the islands may have limited generation capacity. I can see there being a range of exemptions for these circumstances, although once petrol cars start to become unusual the petrol pump prices will go up.
- jacquesm 9y agoOne immediate consequence of transportation revolutions of the past is that some regions that were considered un-inhabitable before suddenly became viable possibilities. It stands to reason that if in the future the 'energy budget' per person gets reduced to the point where vehicles that can do 800 Km un-interrupted are extremely expensive that such locations will only be affordable to the rich with poorer folks condemned to living in or around the cities.
- andy_ppp 9y agoMore likely people will just share self driving buses.
- jacquesm 9y agoBus lines to isolated communities of few people 100 Km away from major cities are typically not feasible. In NL those have all but disappeared when in the past they were a mainstay of public transport. And this country is about as densely populated as it gets.
- pjc50 9y ago> 800 Km un-interrupted That's half the length of the UK! More realistically the longest journey required for a remote place to be habitable might be a round-trip from Durness near Cape Wrath to Inverness, which might require a 400km range. Or half that if you can rely on recharging. Much of that would be on the A9 which the article mentions will have chargers added to it. Already you have the dynamic that much of the really hard poverty is urban. People already move to cities if possible to be where the support facilities are or, if all else fails, to beg on the streets. What I expect we might see a bit more of is modern self-sufficiency and techno-crofting, where people's cash flow looks low but they grow their own food and don't have to pay rent. Already renewables are making this easier on islands. H&I also seems like a good place for medium-range air cargo drones; rather than send a van on a 100km trip round the mountains, send a drone 25km over them.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoA pragmatic money saving decision. The price of batteries is falling steadily. EV prices are falling as a result. By 2022 a new EV will cost less to buy than an equivalent ICE car. It would be foolish to get to that point and have people wanting to buy the cheaper option but not feel able to do so due to lack of charging points etc. Of course, if you take into account the lowered fuel costs and maintenance, then the EV car becomes cheaper even earlier (though it depends on exactly how far you drive and the relative costs of electricity and gasoline) but figures like 2020 are mentioned for the TCO to be lower on a new EV. Of course that figure doesn't take into account costs/benefits like reducing pollution in cities, health impacts, higher imports of fuel, meeting carbon obligations, balancing grid electricity and other externalities, which is why governments are currently subsidizing EVs to make them cheaper than ICEs (and should probably continue to do so, even after they are cheaper than equivalent ICE cars pre-subsidy, though it probably makes more economic sense to further raise gasoline prices and introduce a carbon tax).
- merrua 9y agoIs that the same as the India deadline?
- nmeofthestate 9y agoPedantry - the UK government isn't the "English" government as it's referred to in the article. England isn't the same thing as the UK.
- edh649 9y agoI've heard that these future 'bans' on ICEs are actually just bans on pure ICEs and apparently vehicles with even just stop-start technology are classed as 'Micro-Hybrids' which would be allowed after these 2032, 2040 dates.
- djrogers 9y agoObsolete is a pretty strong term, as is the date: "Come 2032, not all cars will be ultra-low emission, but Scotland hopes that the majority will either be powered purely by electricity or have a hybrid option." Good goal, bad headline.
- andygates 9y ago"Obsolescent" is the right word, but it doesn't have the zing.
- cag_ii 9y agoObsolete does not mean nonexistent. If the goal as the article claims is to "phase out all petrol and diesel car sales", then obsolete seems about right.
- djrogers 9y agoObsolete is defined as: "no longer produced or used; out of date." No longer sold in Scotland does not equate to no longer produced or used, and even at that they do not actually plan to forbid sales of ICE vehicles by 2032.
- trapperkeeper74 9y agoBanning all FFs sounds like a worthy objective overall but it seems like bikeshedding to ban small ICEs yet trains, tractor trailers, farm and mining equipment, jet aircraft and industrial sources receive little regulation. Instead, the average person is taxed, penalized, inconvenienced and regulated for the tiny amount of pollution they produce in comparison to greater polluters.
- ManlyBread 9y agoBanning is easy. Right now the ban is irrational, the EV tech is in it's infancy and nowhere near ready for mass adoption, it needs to be on pair or better than the current solution otherwise it makes no sense to enforce it.
- tobyhinloopen 9y agoCars are major polluters, right? Or is my life a lie?
- bmh_ca 9y agoThe top seven or so shipping ships produce more air pollution than all the worlds cars combined ... So one could say yes to your question, depending on what you call "major".
- Retric 9y agoThat's a false statement. They produce a lot Air pollution of a very specific type because their fuel includes a lot of sulfur. In terms of total pollution ships are actually a small fraction. Further, releasing sulfur over the ocean does not impact human or animal heath significantly.
- bmh_ca 9y agoI take it you believe the Guardian is wrong / misleading / imprecise here? (as are a dozen or so more recent articles) - https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2009/apr/09/shipping-pollution https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2009/apr/09/shipping... > One giant container ship can emit almost the same amount of cancer and asthma-causing chemicals as 50m cars, study finds > Confidential data from maritime industry insiders based on engine size and the quality of fuel typically used by ships and cars shows that just 15 of the world's biggest ships may now emit as much pollution as all the world's 760m cars.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIf they have the desire to make this a priority and are willing to sink the money to pull it off then power to them. IIRC CA had a similar target about electric cars for 2000ish and we all know how that worked out. It's easy to dream big. That dirty thing called reality likes to get in the way. Being an early adopter is expensive.
- DaiPlusPlus 9y agoI recommend watching "Who Killed the Electric Car?" - it explains most of the history of EV cars in California. I disagree with its conclusion that battery technology was not to blame - I feel that range-anxiety is a real concern and the GM EV1's range of under 100 miles using bulk lead-acid or 140 miles using NiMH batteries was, and remains, inadequate. Compare to today's Telsa's S and X 250-300+ mile range. That - and the program was open to easy sabotage.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y ago> I feel that range-anxiety is a real concern The term "range anxiety" seems crafted to make people not take it seriously. The implication is pretty clearly that range is actually fine and it's your feelings about it that are the problem.
- DaiPlusPlus 9y agoIt's both. My commute is 30 miles a day (15 miles each way) and about once or twice a week I'll drive further - perhaps 60 miles in a day - by that logic I would be happy with the Ford Focus Electric as in practice that car gets 70 miles per charge. But this assessment completely disregards the times, often at unpredictable occurrences, when I need to drive 100-200 miles (or more) at short notice and when there is not a time allotment to spend 4-8 hours to have the car recharge sufficiently. I would need to rent a car at very short notice in that case - which can be impossible. Things like a family emergency, a server crash at a data-center, a friend urgently needs a ride from Seattle to Portland and back, etc... Remember, even if an ICE car and an EV have the same range, if both have zero fuel/energy left, the ICE car can be refilled from a hand-portable gas-tank or AAA truck enough to get to the next fuelling station - and you're free to carry additional fuel in your storage space, an EV car does not have that option: there's the prospective of expensive towing and hours waiting for it to recharge. I'd be less concerned if Tesla made some kind of "towable" extended battery or drop-in for the frunk or trunk, or even a portable Honda generator - but it doesn't. I think it's naive to expect that while the majority of American car owners have no need to travel more than 100 miles per day - that they also have no expectation of travelling that distance - and you only need to travel that distance a few days in a whole year to make the purchase of an ICE vehicle worthwhile so long as EVs take longer to recharge without any kind of fast battery-swap feature. I'm in the market for an EV myself - I wish I had gotten on to the Model 3 waiting list sooner - but it would have to be a Model 3 because the range of the Chevy Bolt, Volt, Leaf and the Focus Electric is not sufficient for those occasional long-distance journeys, and I imagine that a plurality (if not the majority) of the car-owning public feel the same way I do.
- melling 9y agoThe real push for electric cars is coming from China, the world’s largest. They are requiring 8% of cars next year need to be electric or plugin hybrid. They want to get that to 20% by 2025. https://www.cnbc.com/2017/08/29/renault-nissan-to-set-up-new-china-jv-with-dongfeng-motor-for-electric-cars.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/08/29/renault-nissan-to-set-up-new...
- dmoy 9y agoOh man that will be glorious, I can't wait for future trips to Beijing without getting respiratory sickness. So far I'm like 7 for 7 on getting sick in Beijing.
- sien 9y agoIt's been pushed back to 2019. https://cleantechnica.com/2017/06/06/china-will-delay-electric-car-mandate-2019/ https://cleantechnica.com/2017/06/06/china-will-delay-electr... But this is far more significant than politicians legislating 'All bad things to end 10+ years away when many of us have retired'.