11 ms·
If 'all cultures are not equal' is a false statement then we're stating 'all cultures are equal' which I interpret as saying there is no metric by which we can
by taylodl 9y ago
If 'all cultures are not equal' is a false statement then we're stating 'all cultures are equal' which I interpret as saying there is no metric by which we can measure the 'goodness' or 'effectiveness' of a culture.
So let's accept the statement 'all cultures are equal' at face value: all cultures are equal and therefore there exists no metric for measuring 'goodness' or 'effectiveness.' If C(now) captures my current cultural state and C(future) captures my future cultural state and we're saying both of these states are equal - because all cultures are equal - then where's the impetus for any new legislation? Where's the drive for change?
In the United States our past culture included slavery, which we'll call C(slavery). Are we really saying C(slavery) == C(now)? I bet most people would claim C(now) > C(slavery) and if so should be suspect of any claim that all cultures are equal.
This isn't a rigorous proof, but I do think it calls into question the notion that all cultures are equal. But maybe that's not what the phrase actually means: maybe what they really intend to say is we've yet to identify unbiased metrics by which we can use to measure cultures and thus correlate them. Presumably most people would bias the metric in such a manner that their culture turned out to be the best. If that's what's actually meant by the phrase 'all cultures are equal' (and I've never heard of anyone presenting it that way) then it should be stated as such because then we can work toward identifying those metrics so we can objectively improve our own culture.
- RandomInteger4 9y ago> If 'all cultures are not equal' is a false statement then we're stating 'all cultures are equal' Not necessarily. There is a system of logic where a double negation doesn't yield the same result. (e.g. if A = True, then !A == false, but !!A == true is not necessarily true) #Pedantic #ImProbablyWrong
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- danielam 9y agoThere are two propositions you can entertain here. 1. All cultures are equal in the sense that they are equally as good. 2. There is no way to compare the merits of any two cultures. (1) is a claim that attributes equal merit to each culture. It is then necessary to establish what exactly these merits are. (2) is a claim that does not per se exclude the possibility of there being a matter of fact about which culture is superior in which ways w.r.t. other cultures. It denies the possibility of establishing what the fact of the matter is. (1) admits only two possible presuppositions. Either (a) all cultures are equal because the good they impart onto individuals and societies is ultimately the same and thus differences are merely cosmetic, or (b) cultures are not a good (that is, neutral or inert w.r.t. the good). (2) admits two possibilities as well. Either (a) our ability to know is limited or impaired or (b) we cannot know because there is nothing to know, i.e., (1b). I think focusing on (1) in this context is a waste of time because clearly no one in this context actually believes it. Protests have a motive and motives only make sense w.r.t. to some end. As you point out, what's the impetus when change produces no change in the good? Protesters and revolutionaries may hold incoherent and confused beliefs, they may have ulterior motives, they may be wrong, but ultimately there is a belief that what is now is evil and what they aim at is better. Ultimately, to be able to judge the merits of any culture requires (at least) a sound philosophical anthropology. You need to understand the nature of man to know what he requires to flourish. Only then can you judge whether, in what ways and to what degree a culture enables that flourishing.
- contravariant 9y ago>If that's what's actually meant by the phrase 'all cultures are equal' [...] then it should be stated as such because Not to split hairs, but you were the one who phrased it like that.
- coldtea 9y ago>we're saying both of these states are equal - because all cultures are equal - then where's the impetus for any new legislation? Where's the drive for change? To play the devil's advocate (since I don't agree that all cultures are equal), three answer: 1) Mere preference/taste. 2) Who said "change is required"? 3) Within a culture we might have criteria to stand as impetus for change/legislation etc inside the culture. So the statement just means that we can't use them to judge another's culture but only our own.
- chickenfries 9y ago> But maybe that's not what the phrase actually means: maybe what they really intend to say is we've yet to identify unbiased metrics by which we can use to measure cultures and thus correlate them. > If that's what's actually meant by the phrase 'all cultures are equal' (and I've never heard of anyone presenting it that way) then it should be stated as such because then we can work toward identifying those metrics so we can objectively improve our own culture. I agree with you about "all cultures are equal" being a hard statement to defend if you take it to literally and nihilistically to mean that there is no objective way to measure good or bad. Not a lot of people are that nihilistic. Most people believe in some degree of moral relativity and some degree of moral absolutism. It's hard. I don't have a rigorous proof for my feelings towards this, but I feel like the goal shouldn't be to reduce CULTURE down to KPIs. I don't think we should be putting culture on a scale and asking how it effects the economy because I think it's the kind of bad social science that people on HN usually detest. This is a good letter from one of Wax's critics, posted to Heterodox Academy: https://heterodoxacademy.org/2017/09/03/i-dont-care-if-amy-wax-is-politically-incorrect-i-do-care-that-shes-empirically-incorrect/ https://heterodoxacademy.org/2017/09/03/i-dont-care-if-amy-w...
- StephenMelon 9y agoI think that the belief that all cultures are equal is usually a mistake based on fuzzy thinking. The underlying thought is that “all cultures have value”, which mutates into “all cultures have equal value in terms of increasing insight into how humans interact with the world and each other” and this gets universalised via a mental shortcut into “all cultures have equal value” and then anyone who questions it gets shouted down. Additionally, cultures are porous, overlapping aggregations of chaotic, abstract and mutating human created concepts which resist analysis almost by definition. Assessing a culture based mainly on its economic expediency seems like a startlingly narrow criteria?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rhizome 9y agoI feel like this should all be short-circuited by the fact that cultures are not a fixed value that can be compared for equality. Congruence, perhaps, but there are too many moving parts in culture to be able to rank them, which is an implication of solving for a single (imaginary) term.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- colanderman 9y agoRight. For example, there is no one "white culture". I'm white, and there are plenty of white people in my home town with whom I share little to no cultural values. Any conversation about relative values of "cultures" is probably better cast as a discussion about cultural memes (in the original Dawkins sense [1]), with the understanding that the flow of memes tend to follow social contours as clusters, and interact with one another. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meme
- theseatoms 9y agomeme : atom :: culture : physics I agree that it's best to inspect culture from the bottom up rather than the top down. Start with the most granular units. Is anyone here acquainted with the current sociological orthodoxy or is that population mutually exclusive with HN commenters? :)
- chc 9y agoI think you probably mean "meme : culture :: atom : physics" (i.e. memes have the same relationship with culture that atoms do with physics).
- colanderman 9y agoTo be fair, in the pure mathematical sense of “ratio”, A ∶ B ∷ C ∶ D and A ∶ C ∷ B ∶ D are equivalent statements.
- BadassFractal 9y agoThe issue here is applying logic to actions that are predominantly displays of virtue driven by fear of being marked as not belonging to the in group. Reason isn't going to win here unfortunately.
- apoverton 9y agoGood and bad is in the eye of the beholder and what you value. Is American culture (a loaded term because American culture is the product of numerous sub-cultures) better than all other cultures because of our economic strength? If not, then what are the objective measures that define a "good" culture. I'm very glad slavery doesn't exist, because I value equality and freedom. Yet still, I'd ask who is the authority that determines that one culture is better than another because they hold that value? Europeans via too many systems to name here (e.g. colonizing much of the world, forcing religion on indigenous people, slavery, apartheid, etc.) imposed their cultural values on the world and then held them up as the best. Ultimately, it's not right to conflate what you believe with what is objectively good. It all depends what your solving for (e.g. profit, equality, harmony, etc.)
- Brakenshire 9y agoFrankly, a world in which we are not confident enough to say that slavery is worse than freedom, is a dystopia. It's valid to talk about difficulties of analysis, fragmented values, fallacies, edge cases, caveats, caution etc, but we cannot and should not abdicate from judgment.
- icebraining 9y agoI'm not confident enough to say that slavery is objectively worse than freedom. I have no reasons that lead me to consider that an objective answer exists. I'm still completely opposed to slavery and willing to fight it, by force if necessary. Is that dystopic?
- kareemsabri 9y agoThat's called moral relativism. It does't get you very far, because it is a belief system with no values, and therefore nothing to aim at. There are some tools for objectively judging morality aka "good and bad". One is the principle of universality. So an outcome is moral if you can reasonably state that you would be equally happy to be on either side of the table. Slavery generally fails this test, since most people would prefer not to be slaves. Virtually everyone on either side of the slavery divide (slave/free) valued freedom, some of them just didn't value the freedom of other people.
- ewzimm 9y agoYou have a good point, but the next sentence clearly states the metric: "Or at least they are not equal in preparing people to be productive in an advanced economy." It's not a statement about the artistic or spritual value of cultures, only their ability to create economically productive individuals, which is easy to measure.
- StephenMelon 9y ago“Or at least they are not equal in preparing people to be productive in an advanced economy” is problematic because it can be rephrased as “Or at least they are not equal in preparing people to be (successfully exploited by those who control capital) in a (specific type of) advanced economy (which is rigged in favour of those who are already wealthy and/or educated/connected/privileged in a particular way for historical reasons)”. As a parent, I can vouch for the fact it’s difficult to successfully raise children but there are many other possible ways to support the young in becoming net contributors to society because there are clearly many viable cultural alternatives to the nuclear family that could thrive under a system other than the kleptocratic oligarchy of late US neoliberal globalist vulture techno-capitalism. Wax argues competently but is guilty of a slight lack of imagination as most conservative thinkers are; the preference to move backwards towards a solution based on a mythical idealised point in the past, letting their preferred outcome dull their analysis of their cognitive biases. Unfortunately shutting down debate seems to be the favoured approach of those who are over-engaged with identity politics at the current time. It’s almost as if the left have been infiltrated by self-loathing alt-right 4chan agent provocateur trolls who are so scared of choice and diversity that they want to speed a “return” to a totalitarian hegemonic monoculture by getting the left to do their work for them. I think that the actual situation is maybe more prosaic, a case of undergraduate courses teaching critical theory without first teaching the fundamentals of critical thinking (with social media is turning the heat up across the board). It is clear that cultures can be valued against one another only when metrics can be agreed. Wax seems to unsafely assume that there is a consensus on metrics and I think there is a need for more science and philosophy in that area before real progress can be made. There is such a thing as legitimate authority based on domain knowledge but cultural legitimacy doesn’t seem to quite work in the same way. New generations will experiment with solutions to the problems (and privilege) they are faced with in their time. The debate has become more shrill as the web has accelerated change and revitalised sub-cultures, and conservatism will act, as it always has, as a speed brake on change.
- cirgue 9y ago"Culture' is an exceptionally poorly defined term, and there is no hope of applying any kind of rigor here. Most of the time it's shorthand for a constellation of behaviors that a) exist independently of each other across cultural groups, and b) aren't actually as consistent in practice as one might think.
- Nomentatus 9y ago"Good and bad is in the eye of the beholder and what you value." - Now put your hand on a hot stove and say that again. Nature forces some values. (quote from apoverton but the principle, vs Hume, applies to many other comments here.)
- rxhernandez 9y agoAnd some people would view getting put on a hot stove as a fun and exciting thing, so no, not really. Unsure of why I'm getting downvotes.. Are people completely unaware of the fact that some people enjoy pain?
- TwelveNights 9y agoYou made a pretty contrived comment to refute the parent poster, considering how unlikely it is that someone would find it a fun and exciting thing to do.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kelnos 9y agoYou make a good point that there are rarely any absolutes, but your example ends up reinforcing the parent's point: everything that "we" consider good or bad amounts to collective opinion. You can probably find a fringe group that has just about any opinion you want to dream up, but if it's rejected by the vast majority of the population, it's going to be considered "bad". You can also examine things from other perspectives. Darwinian, perhaps: does enjoying pain give any kind of evolutionary advantage? Maybe in a few niche areas, but overall, no, since pain is a way for our brains to signal damage, or future damage if we keep doing what we're doing. Ignoring pain up to a certain threshold can be useful, but enjoying pain to your detriment is not. Or maybe just economic: does enjoying pain give any kind of economic advantages? And so on... I think it's important to acknowledge that there are no absolutes when it comes to opinion, but sometimes you just have to observe near-unanimity and go with it.
- 9y ago
- weberc2 9y ago> I bet most people would claim C(now) > C(slavery) Without defending slavery, the obvious problem with your line of reasoning is that most people (implicitly most people alive today) are influenced by C(now). Even if you identify a group of values that are relatively constant across cultures (including bygone cultures), the best you can do is say "culture X better conforms to the majority values than culture Y". It's probably worthwhile to be able to make such a statement, but it's still not an objective statement. If you want to make objective statements about morality and cultures, you need to subscribe to a philosophy of moral absolutism, which is antithetical to liberal tradition prior to a few years ago.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoTrue, but that doesn't help. Whether or not due to influence by C(now), there are very few people currently alive who would not say that C(now) > C(slavery). Those people cannot (validly) also argue that all cultures are equal. Worse, I'd guess that there is a liberal/conservative element here. Liberals are more likely to believe that C(now) > C(slavery); they are also more likely to believe that all cultures are equal.
- weberc2 9y agoI think my post agrees with your first paragraph, but your post reads like a rebuke. I disagree that conservatives are more likely to believe that C(slavery) was better than C(now), but I agree that conservatives are more likely to process an absolute morality position (with liberals it seems more complicated--most would say they support moral relativism, but they seem to view other moral systems as fundamentally racist and thus evil, which can't be far from moral absolutism). This is more an elaboration on your point than a correction, I think.
- icebraining 9y agoevil, which can't be far from moral absolutism Why? I can consider something subjectively evil, that is, I can feel a strong moral repulsion without considering that judgment to be universal.
- narrator 9y agoIt's been almost 90 years since Antonio Gramsci designed the culture war in his prison notebooks[1], so things have morphed a bit and the centrally planned communism he advocated is out of favor as an end goal, but the blueprint is still pretty much the same. To quote Wikipedia a little: "Capitalism, Gramsci suggested, maintained control not just through violence and political and economic coercion, but also ideologically, through a hegemonic culture in which the values of the bourgeoisie became the 'common sense' values of all. Thus a consensus culture developed in which people in the working-class identified their own good with the good of the bourgeoisie, and helped to maintain the status quo rather than revolting." In his theory any culture C (!Hegemony)>C (Hegemony). When he refers to Hegemonic culture he was talking ato the time about what he called "Fordism" which was the state of the art in enlightened capitalism at the time meaning treating and paying workers well with the workplace working in tandem with the family to re-enforce the traditional family unit. Gramsci was trying to figure out a way to cause communist revolution at the time and he said that in order to attack Fordism they must get together everyone who is opposed to the dominant culture, including socialists as well as all cultural minorities including civil rights activists, feminists, libertines, homosexuals, radical islamists, some criminals, etc who felt they had some greivance with the dominant culture. It really didn't matter if they were morally justified or not by any philosophy. The point was is that they were opposed to the hegemony and that's all that mattered. Thats because the point of their activity was not to change laws within the current system, but to create discontent to foment a socialist political revolution by any means. Now these days this strategy has morphed into something that is not a communist plot, but just a general strategy to seize power in organizations. The reason you can't say any culture is better than any other except the hegemonic culture is because it ideologically undermines the means of political revolution that has been picked up by several generations of political opportunists who use this strategy to build and maintain a powerbase. [1].https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prison_Notebooks https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prison_Notebooks
- gertef 9y agoThis is a classic reactionary comment that doesn't understand the asymmetry between the "bourgeoisie" and the lower classes. The "hegemonic" "bourgeoisie", secure in the status quo, sees politics as a game for "opportunists", while the oppressed classes lay aside their differences so they can try build enough power to overthrow the oppression and end their suffering. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1013753/quotes/qt1525548 http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1013753/quotes/qt1525548 [City Councilman Dan White is complaining that he is having trouble getting re-elected because his base doesn't have any problems that need government intervention, while 'lucky duck' Harvey Milk has the natural support of the gay voter base who want the police to stop murdering them.] Dan White: You have an issue [gay rights]. Harvey Milk: It's more than an issue. This is our life we're fighting for.
- ouid 9y ago"Any moral dilemma can be rephrased as an evil maximization problem" -Zach Weinersmith
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoHere's another culture. C(not equal) is a culture that believes that all cultures are not equal. But those arguing that all cultures are equal are in fact arguing that their culture, C(equal), is better than C(not equal). That is, by the act of making the argument, they refute the argument they are making.
- anigbrowl 9y agoLet's recall that that assertion was made in the context of a "provocative essay" (Haidt's words, not mine) in a newspaper rather than in the context of a rigorous scholarly argument. You're building a very elaborate theory on the corpse of a rather obvious straw man in Wax's original article.