13 ms·
In Defense of Amy Wax’s Defense of Bourgeois Values
- CptBland 9y agoLooking at the Heterodox Academy's blog history, they seem mostly to be interested in advocating for a conservative viewpoint than anything else. To say that they're trying to 'break orthodoxy' comes across as ridiculous when they're based in a country where the current president and congress are the most right wing they've been for decades. The whole narrative of 'free speech' being under attack in academia has just been from right-wingers who really want nothing like free speech - they just want the ability to be racist and bigoted with impunity while shutting down speech in favour of equality.
- random023987 9y agoI think underlying many of these discussions is a fundamental question: "If not all cultures and values are equally successful in modern society, should we (as a society) encourage people to adopt a more successful values, or should we adapt society to make all cultures and values equally successful?" (edit: obviously I have biases, but I tried to phase this in a way that masked my biases. If there's a more neutral way to phrase this, I'd be interested in hearing it)
- 0xbear 9y agoAnd the question below that is, who's "we"?
- marcoperaza 9y agoThe only way to accomplish the latter is to pull the excellent down to the level of mediocrity or worse. How do you propose to raise up a culture that doesn't value creativity and hard work, for example, to the level of success of one that does. Culture is much more than what food you eat and music you listen to. This reminds me of a famous Tocqueville quote: There is in fact a manly and legitimate passion for equality that spurs all men to wish to be strong and esteemed. This passion tends to elevate the lesser to the rank of the greater. But one also finds in the human heart a depraved taste for equality which impels the weak to want to bring the strong down to their level and which reduces men to preferring equality in servitude to inequality in freedom.
- chickenfries 9y agoNot attributing this to you, but you could deploy your argument against abolishing slavery. > How do you propose to raise up a culture that doesn't value diligent hard work Which culture? Don't be abstract. Name what culture you think doesn't value hard work and I will and we'll see if I can't find a counterexample.
- marcoperaza 9y agoI prefer positive examples. It's no secret that the Jewish people have done so phenomenally well, despite two millennia of persecution, because of their strong values of hard work, family, and creativity.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoThey are also benefiting heavily from genetics, their average IQ being roughly an entire standard deviation above average.
- gras 9y agoHow is this at all controversial? The American Jewish minority of 6% of the population owns 25% of American wealth. They've done well. Are the downvotes about attributing it to their values? What else? Their skill at (((accidental))) eugenics? The selection pressure put on them by other groups? Other theory: KGB or Mossad votebots that want to suppress discussions about Jews not only being victims.
- marcoperaza 9y agoI was only speaking admirably of the Jews. I'm not sure what you're getting at, or what's sarcastic or not in your post. But I don't see the need for the triple-parentheses.
- baddox 9y agoI'm not saying it's controversial, but I'd rather see strong evidence that just make assumptions based on general cultural stereotypes like "Jewish people work hard" or weak evidence like "they own a disproportionate amount of wealth."
- steanne 9y agosuccessful cultures don't necessarily scale within a society if some of what makes them successful is taking advantage of other cultures.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- contravariant 9y ago>should we adapt society to make all cultures and values equally successful? Given that this includes people who value a society where particular values aren't successful, it is probably not possible to have a society like that.
- taylodl 9y agoIf 'all cultures are not equal' is a false statement then we're stating 'all cultures are equal' which I interpret as saying there is no metric by which we can measure the 'goodness' or 'effectiveness' of a culture. So let's accept the statement 'all cultures are equal' at face value: all cultures are equal and therefore there exists no metric for measuring 'goodness' or 'effectiveness.' If C(now) captures my current cultural state and C(future) captures my future cultural state and we're saying both of these states are equal - because all cultures are equal - then where's the impetus for any new legislation? Where's the drive for change? In the United States our past culture included slavery, which we'll call C(slavery). Are we really saying C(slavery) == C(now)? I bet most people would claim C(now) > C(slavery) and if so should be suspect of any claim that all cultures are equal. This isn't a rigorous proof, but I do think it calls into question the notion that all cultures are equal. But maybe that's not what the phrase actually means: maybe what they really intend to say is we've yet to identify unbiased metrics by which we can use to measure cultures and thus correlate them. Presumably most people would bias the metric in such a manner that their culture turned out to be the best. If that's what's actually meant by the phrase 'all cultures are equal' (and I've never heard of anyone presenting it that way) then it should be stated as such because then we can work toward identifying those metrics so we can objectively improve our own culture.
- RandomInteger4 9y ago> If 'all cultures are not equal' is a false statement then we're stating 'all cultures are equal' Not necessarily. There is a system of logic where a double negation doesn't yield the same result. (e.g. if A = True, then !A == false, but !!A == true is not necessarily true) #Pedantic #ImProbablyWrong
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- danielam 9y agoThere are two propositions you can entertain here. 1. All cultures are equal in the sense that they are equally as good. 2. There is no way to compare the merits of any two cultures. (1) is a claim that attributes equal merit to each culture. It is then necessary to establish what exactly these merits are. (2) is a claim that does not per se exclude the possibility of there being a matter of fact about which culture is superior in which ways w.r.t. other cultures. It denies the possibility of establishing what the fact of the matter is. (1) admits only two possible presuppositions. Either (a) all cultures are equal because the good they impart onto individuals and societies is ultimately the same and thus differences are merely cosmetic, or (b) cultures are not a good (that is, neutral or inert w.r.t. the good). (2) admits two possibilities as well. Either (a) our ability to know is limited or impaired or (b) we cannot know because there is nothing to know, i.e., (1b). I think focusing on (1) in this context is a waste of time because clearly no one in this context actually believes it. Protests have a motive and motives only make sense w.r.t. to some end. As you point out, what's the impetus when change produces no change in the good? Protesters and revolutionaries may hold incoherent and confused beliefs, they may have ulterior motives, they may be wrong, but ultimately there is a belief that what is now is evil and what they aim at is better. Ultimately, to be able to judge the merits of any culture requires (at least) a sound philosophical anthropology. You need to understand the nature of man to know what he requires to flourish. Only then can you judge whether, in what ways and to what degree a culture enables that flourishing.
- dibujante 9y agoLarge, pluralistic societies create a new kind of natural-selective environment that pushes cultures towards greater fitness in their niches or rewards cultures that expand into or create new niches. You definitely can't expect all cultures to behave the same way and exist in all niches. See e.g. the enormous propensity of Mormons towards dentistry - "be a dentist" is not a valid universal cultural attribute, but can be adaptive for a small group. There are many routes to success.
- AdeptusAquinas 9y agoA lot of the people who hold these sort of viewpoints in the US would benefit immensely from visiting and even living for a while in literally any other western democracy, or even just the English-speaking ones. I can't think of any country in the western world who has a social welfare system on the same low level as the US - and yet we don't have such a 'decline in social indicators'. Quite the opposite. And we are not perfect: the upcoming NZ election is pointing out all the remaining flaws in our society, along with futile attempts to fix them by empty-promising politicians. But no one would ever say we are not vastly better off than the average US citizen, so clearly 'social welfare' is not the problem. Maybe having a society where a random illness or infection doesn't destroy you economically - unless you are slaved to your employer with health insurance - might help fix things? Or maybe endless foreign wars and an influx of PTSD veterans along with an outflow of patriotically brain washed kids is not healthy? Maybe a political system where a egotistical demagogue can hijack the government is a flaw to correct?
- darawk 9y agoIt's hard to compare a country like NZ to the US in a fair and meaningful way. NZ is a small, ethnically (and therefore more importantly culturally) homogenous country. Now, it's not completely homogenous, but it is much more so than the US. Being a democracy, the policies of the country are inseparable from its culture and demographics. You say universal healthcare might stem the tide of cultural breakdown. But we cannot be sure the causality doesn't flow the other way. Unfortunately, it's likely a feedback loop. We have bad policy in part due to the cultural and social decline the author describes, and we have cultural and social decline in part due to bad policy. Simply proposing policy changes neglects the complex interdependencies of these things, and is why national demographics are so important in a democracy. Part of the reason NZ is able to cohere around its policy more than the US is because everyone in NZ (to a greater degree than in the US) shares the same values and cultural identity. This is why you see similarly idyllic societies in the Scandinavian countries. High social cohesion due to shared cultural and ethnic identity. Same in Korea and Japan - although Japanese culture is a good example of some of the downsides of ethnic and cultural homogeneity as well.
- 9y ago
- Cacti 9y ago"if understood within their sociocultural context" is akin to saying "if you agree with all of our assumptions". It's a bullshit, vapid argument no matter how you use it, and the students should be embarrassed to be using such childish arguments. But of course they're aren't, because they're children.
- danfolkes 9y agoHere is a follow-up article written by one of the 33 members of the University of Pennsylvania Law School faculty to sign a letter criticizing Amy Wax: Don’t Care if Amy Wax Is Politically Incorrect; I Do Care that She’s Empirically Incorrect https://heterodoxacademy.org/2017/09/03/i-dont-care-if-amy-wax-is-politically-incorrect-i-do-care-that-shes-empirically-incorrect/ https://heterodoxacademy.org/2017/09/03/i-dont-care-if-amy-w...
- coldtea 9y agoWhat hypocrisy. All they care is that she is "Politically Incorrect" -- they could not care less about the facts. Not to mention that when someone is wrong about facts you correct them, you don't fire them or ask for their condemnation. Professors are not supposed to be correct, just to probe for what's correct. In fact they should be encouraged to be boldly inquisitive and incorrect in that pursuit, and use dialog to sort out the ultimate answer. And of course even "incorrect" ideas can be considered correct in an era -- in the 19th and up to the mid-20th century there were all kinds of facts and studies showing how some races were genetically inferior available to racists (that is: almost everybody). Now we laugh at them, but how many similar (or even in the reverse direction) BS we take as fact because social "scientists" just put things under the rug and only give facts and statistics that are compatible with current cultural norms?
- mannykannot 9y agoIndeed - if Prof. Klick really "[doesn't] care if Amy Wax is politically correct", why did he sign a letter that says "We categorically reject Wax’s claims", instead of refuting them? Refutation is so much more effective than condemnation. It is strange and disturbing to see academia joining the alt-right in its attempt to resurrect a pre-enlightenment age of dogma and allegations of heresy. For academia, it is a losing proposition.
- gertef 9y agoProfessors are expected to have some self-awareness and avoid stating their opinions as facts.
- padseeker 9y ago"Nor are the single-parent, antisocial habits, prevalent among some working-class whites; the anti-“acting white” rap culture of inner-city blacks; the anti-assimilation ideas gaining ground among some Hispanic immigrants" Already you lost me. There are plenty of single parents out of wedlock children in very white states like West Virginia, Kentucky, etc. How is rap culture or black people responsible for the actions of white people in these areas? I live in a big city, my kids go to a bilingual school. Every parent there, hispanic or not, want their kids to do well, to get a good education, go to college, succeed professionally and personally. All of them have absorbed some American attitudes to one degree or another. The few parents who don't speak english well want their children to do so. None of these people are against assimilating. There may be legitimate concerns of substance here, about having children out of wedlock, parents who are stretched thin. But this paragraph right here reads like thinly veiled racism targeted towards blacks and hispanics. All the sociological rhetoric does not hide this at all.
- coldtea 9y ago>Already you lost me. There are plenty of single parents out of wedlock children in very white states like West Virginia, Kentucky, etc. How is rap culture or black people responsible for the actions of white people in these areas? Where did the author said it is? They said there are "single-parent, antisocial habits" that are prevalent among some working-class whites" AND an "anti-“acting white” rap culture of inner-city blacks" AND " anti-assimilation ideas gaining ground among some Hispanic immigrants". Three kinds of issues -- not an issue and two explanations for it. >None of these people are against assimilating. Hence the phrasing "anti-assimilation ideas gaining ground among SOME" -- the author did not write "prevalent in ALL".
- padseeker 9y agoAmy Wax said it, quoted by the author. It's in the article. 7th paragraph down.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoYou are misreading it, she is listing three distinct groups, note the semicolons in the list. She is in no way saying one group is affecting the other, just that they all share non-bourgeois values. Regarding being "not suited to a First World, 21st-century environment." she adds: Nor are: the single-parent, antisocial habits, prevalent among some working-class whites; the anti-“acting white” rap culture of inner-city blacks; the anti-assimilation ideas gaining ground among some Hispanic immigrants
- notthegov 9y agoAll cultures are not equal and few cultures are uniformally isolated. Civilization is a byproduct of cultures interacting and blending. And human happiness and quality of life is most supported by improving our diets, our education, our expressions and our psychologies. Enlightenment ideals built the modern world, not relativism. We should be criticizing all cultures and our everyday actions. "Culture" in some ways is just a random repetition of behavior and ideas. It may conform to environmental pressures but there is nothing intrinsic about it in regards to any ethnicity or race. All humans are lazy, hardworking, intellectual, superficial, selfish and selfless. The difference is which ideas push us in the right directions of our better nature.
- ABCLAW 9y ago>"Does that make Wax a white supremacist for saying that culture matters for poverty-related outcomes, that not all cultures are equally good for escaping poverty, and that the 1950s American “bourgeois cultural script” was particularly good for that purpose?" This is the core premise of the article, the conclusion, of course, being 'no'. Unfortunately, it does not accurately deal with the fairly clear subtext being delivered by Ms. Wax. > "In an interview with The Daily Pennsylvanian about the op-ed, Wax was quoted as saying that “Everyone wants to go to countries ruled by white Europeans,” because, in the phrasing of the DP article’s author, “Anglo-Protestant cultural norms are superior.” … [they then affirm Wax’s right to express her opinions, then say:] We categorically reject Wax’s claims." This, in particular, is striking. Why is 'being ruled by white Europeans' the draw to migrants over, say, the relative wealth of the west in the aggregate? France and Germany certainly offer troves of opportunity, but is Greece really more of a destination for economic migrants than, say, Singapore? Would India's quasi-british culture provide a counter-example when compared with China's? The lack of any of these comparative examinations leads us immediately to question the argument provided. Ms. Wax doesn't even make case compelling to show that it was the 1950s script itself, rather than other causes before she jumps into discussing the superiority of the white european ruling establishment. Could it be that America's economic rivals had just been bombed to ash which led to an influx of capital to the country during an era where unions had clout? Nah, its just the fact that it was ruled by white europeans (/s). Give me a break.
- ameister14 9y agoI think the evidence of mass emigration from White European countries in the recent past does enough to prove her point wrong.
- wsxcde 9y agoLet's not get bogged down by the all cultures are not equal strawman. That is not at all the key point here. Amy Wax/OP's argument is problematic because it conflates very different things using a subtly disingenuous argument. She starts off by saying something completely uncontroversial: kids from stable marriages do well in school. But she then plays on the audiences implicit biases to imply -- but not explicitly articulate -- a completely unsubstantiated racist claim: inner city blacks are incompatible with an advanced free market economy. This sleight of hand where the speaker/writer stops just short of an explicitly racist implication that deliberately confuses causation and correlation in the presence of multiple confounding factors is a standard white supremacist parlor trick. That is why Amy Wax was roundly condemned. And the OP's claim that saying anything negative about the (lack of) black marriages is taboo in academia is quite blatantly false. Read for example this gushing review (https://nyti.ms/2kbBHRP https://nyti.ms/2kbBHRP) of Ralph Richard Banks' book on the very same topic by Imani Perry.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- s17n 9y agoThe question that the article raises is, should the Amy Wax face professional repercussions for making a racist argument? I think that as a law professor, the answer is yes - she should be held accountable for incompetence in op-ed writing in the same way that a scientist should be held accountable for incompetence in conducting an experiment. If she were a math professor or something, I would say that she had the right to her opinion.
- overgard 9y agoThe idea that she made a "racist argument" is a HUGE leap. She argued that marriage is important. You might agree or disagree, but ruining somones career because they have social views you disagree with is just gross.
- s17n 9y agoAs a specialist in, among other related fields, "social welfare law and policy" her social views are the substance of her career. If a mathematician believed that 1 + 1 was 3, I'd want her fired. This is similar.
- jxramos 9y agoI think this is a key motivational paragraph from the article... "The students are certainly correct that claims by a professor about the value of bourgeois culture could be misused by racists to say that one race is inherently superior to another. But does that make any discussion of cultural differences taboo? Does that make Wax a white supremacist for saying that culture matters for poverty-related outcomes, that not all cultures are equally good for escaping poverty, and that the 1950s American “bourgeois cultural script” was particularly good for that purpose? No, and here’s why."
- jancsika 9y ago> All cultures are not equal. Or at least they are not equal in preparing people to be productive in an advanced economy. So for which statement is the author providing evidence? The first or the second? They are two completely different statements.
- pamqzl 9y agoNo they're not, the second is just a clarification of the sense in which the first was meant. By comparison, take the statement "All men are not equal. Or at least, they're not equal in their ability to play football". The second statement is obviously true, the first is controversial. Why is that so? How can all men be equal if they're so obviously unequal in just about any metric you might choose to measure them on? Because they're equal in one specific sense: that we (most of us) believe they should have equal rights.
- johnminter 9y agoDecisions and choices have consequences. These are not made in a philosophical vacuum, they are made according to the values the individual holds - which are largely influenced by the culture from which the individual comes. Indeed the term "culture" arises from the Latin "cultus" which is a religion or value structure. A culture that passes on default values of industriousness and a high regard for education will generate individuals that are more motivated and perhaps more resilient than one who does not. A culture that values consistent parenting of children will likely pass on more deliberate traits than a culture that does not value active parenting. One should not be surprised to see different distributions of outcomes from different groups who hold different values. One of the advantages of living in a multicultural society where people live together peacefully and actually listen to one another is that we can learn which choices lead to the best outcomes and encourage our children to emulate those and to avoid choices that lead to dependency and addiction. The Brookings Institute can hardly be considered a right wing think tank and yet they published a well reasoned piece on the behavioral aspects of poverty [1]. [1] https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-behavioral-aspects-of-poverty/ https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-behavioral-aspects-of...
- exelius 9y agoI don't think there's inherently anything wrong with the original author's thesis: not all cultures are created equal. But the author does make a critical conservative assumption by implying that economic output is a proxy for "value". This is honestly the critical point: our culture defines how we value things. Some cultures are not bothered by things like social welfare or socialist policies because the base unit of society is considered to be the family rather than the individual. Cultures like this may value things like "familial harmony" more than "individual prosperity". So it's obvious that someone like the original author -- who likely grew up in this "bourgeois culture" -- would attribute everything bad in society to the decline in things she holds valuable. It's part of the definition. As a counterpoint, American culture is much better for the individual than it was 30-40 years ago for anyone who isn't a straight white male. Those people have the viewpoint that things have improved. Bourgeois values aren't meaningful to these people because they never really applied. So really, we're back to where we already knew we were: globalization had winners and losers. The losers were primarily located in the western middle class (i.e. the bourgeois class).
- weberc2 9y agoCould you clarify your argument? It sounds like you're saying something to the effect of "The author is just upset that life is better for people with different attributes than her; no one can legitimately hold her point of view". I don't think that's what you mean, but I want to give you the opportunity to clarify.
- exelius 9y agoI'm trying to say that her argument simply isn't very interesting :) Look, the only people who think America was better off in the 60s/70s are the ones who benefitted from the systemic discrimination inherent of that era. It's perfectly reasonable for them to feel that way, and I'm not even saying I blame them for feeling left behind. Is America actually better off today? It depends who you ask. It's just not intellectually very interesting to talk about. All she's doing is imposing cherry-picked aspects of her chosen value system as objectively "better" while ignoring the whole point that any definition of "better" relies on a subjective personal value system to begin with.
- ianbicking 9y agoFrom the article: "Of course we are always free to dispute each other; Wax’s colleagues could certainly have written essays or a collective essay debating her claims and pointing out flaws in her reasoning, but when is it morally and professionally appropriate to issue a collective public condemnation of a colleague? "I think such collective actions are only appropriate when colleagues have clearly and flagrantly violated their professional duties. I mean things like data fabrication or taking bribes to produce dishonest academic papers desired by a trade association." Well, that's just your opinion man. This is one of the key claims of this article, and it has no support. Why is a collective response inappropriate here? Why should those students and professors who disagree with Amy Wax not band together intellectually and through collective speech? Why is a collective response only appropriate when someone is clearly and vagrantly violating their professional duties? The author is making a very extreme assertion, but does it as an aside.
- stinkytaco 9y ago> Why is a collective response inappropriate here? I think that the default should be to allow a discourse that is wide ranging and open, and to only censure in cases that are truly extreme (such as incitement). Institutional censure carries with it a huge weight, and potentially the ability to silence opinions. Though I strongly disagree with this person, I must also try to imagine a situation where the roles are reversed, where I am in the minority and having my opinion censured. I believe that to live in a society that is truly free, it guarantees you will come into contact with opinions and beliefs that you find repugnant. It troubles me that the left has so aggressively mobilized against speech, not just disagreeing with it, but demanding that it be institutionally silenced. That said, this school (being a private institution) and these professors (being individuals entitled to their own opinions) are also within their rights. Free speech does not free you from criticism for your views.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoWhy is that an extreme assertion? Until maybe two years ago, it would have been considered extreme to call for a professor's head for anything short of real misconduct.
- drawkbox 9y agoFrom the original article: These basic cultural precepts reigned from the late 1940s to the mid-1960s. They could be followed by people of all backgrounds and abilities, especially when backed up by almost universal endorsement. Adherence was a major contributor to the productivity, educational gains, and social coherence of that period.[1] People attach happy ideas during this time because during good economic times, things just work on all cylinders. However, two major things were happening that actually led to the advancements and fruitfulness of the time mentioned from 40s to mid 60s. 1) World War II happened and ended, everyone was obliterated but the US. This led to massive gains in all areas of wealth and industry. It was a war that took us to a superpower, and at the time, everyone owed us money. Good economic times lead to more ability to have kids and a solid consumer base to support middle class housing/restaurants/retail etc. 2) Women started entering the workforce and diversity started to happen opening up the workforce that was previously built for 1 person to provide for multiple people and salary needed for that, to suddenly having sometimes 2 in the house that brought in double the money needed for a time. You could say a move away from family focused housing and middle class retail/restaurants is a problem, but that is more to do with wage stagnation and the internet/productivity. People can't afford to get married and have multiple kids as they could before, wages have not truly kept up and been steadily dropping since the 70s as well as share of productivity/GDP gains[2]. People have more kids in good economic times and less kids in bad economic times[3][4], same reason there was a baby boom in the time they mentioned from the 40s to the mid 60s. The 90s are similar in terms of good economic times, people had more kids, people bought more homes, more products, people were getting wage increases, new technologies/innovation that gains advantage worldwide etc. In the end it is economics and timing, whatever is popular during those times people will attribute it to their own confirmation biases. [1] http://www.philly.com/philly/opinion/commentary/paying-the-price-for-breakdown-of-the-countrys-bourgeois-culture-20170809.html http://www.philly.com/philly/opinion/commentary/paying-the-p... [2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=2Xa https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=2Xa [3] http://www.prb.org/publications/datasheets/2012/world-population-data-sheet/fact-sheet-us-population.aspx http://www.prb.org/publications/datasheets/2012/world-popula... [4] http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2011/10/12/in-a-down-economy-fewer-births/ http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2011/10/12/in-a-down-economy-...
- 9y ago
- door 9y agomarriage has declined largely because women don't as often have to stay in shitty abusive marriages for financial reasons anymore. this is a good thing.
- anigbrowl 9y agoOf course we are always free to dispute each other; Wax’s colleagues could certainly have written essays or a collective essay debating her claims and pointing out flaws in her reasoning, but when is it morally and professionally appropriate to issue a collective public condemnation of a colleague? Whenever the signatories of such a communication agree upon the idea, surely? Political agency only exists to the degree that one is willing to exercise it. I find it perplexing that conservatives on the one hand deplore restrictions on speech that seem to stifle the expression of conservative ideas and so forth, but then complain about improper forms of speech when they find their ideas rejected. If it's OK for Wax to co-author a lightweight op-ed that expresses support for bourgeois (capitalist) moral values and breezily dismisses the downsides thereof, why should her critics limit themselves to scholarly analysis but abstain from making moral arguments of their own? Why is it OK for Wax to claim that "things are likely to get worse for us all" thanks to "the academics, media, and Hollywood", but not OK for Wax's colleagues to say they consider her to be giant hypocrite? I have gone to great lengths to show that Wax’s central claim about culture is probably correct because the necessity of protecting dissent is clearest when the dissenter brings an important and neglected truth into the conversation. In reality, Haidt takes one aspect of Wax's claim (about the value of marriage), shows some bipartisan/broad-spectrum support for the idea that promoting marriage can have social benefits, and treats this like an empirical result. I don't think that comes anywhere close to validating Wax's broad claim that the hegemonic post-war culture is the best cure for today's social ills, or that its shortcomings are incidental rather than inherent, or that its desiderata of modest obedience and productivity are the acme of human experience. It's fine with me if he agrees with Wax, but this doesn't give him the right to dictate the terms of discourse. If Wax can write a "provocative essay" why must her critics restrict themselves to the language of theoretical discourse?
- WillPostForFood 9y agoYou are a little disingenuous - no one would be complaining if someone on the law faculty wrote a counter opinion piece. What's happening isn't an expression of disagreement, which would be fine, but an attack on Wax to try and suppress her POV. Her critics made no "moral argument" they simply condemn her. http://www.thedp.com/article/2017/08/open-letter-penn-law-faculty http://www.thedp.com/article/2017/08/open-letter-penn-law-fa...
- Veelox 9y agoI have not read Amy Wax's original letter but my understand is that she made the claim that people in the lower social-economic classes have been rejecting the "Bourgeois" culture. She then went on to say that this rejection has and will have negative affects on those groups. Would someone be willing to point out how that claim is offensive? Or is it how she made the claim that is the issue?
- wmf 9y agoSome people translate "bourgeois culture" as "white culture" and thus interpret her conclusion as "if you don't act white your kids will be doomed". That's offensive to people who believe that diversity and multiculturalism are superior.
- Veelox 9y agoAhh, your phrasing of "if you don't act white your kids will be doomed" puts it in a way I can understand it, thank you. Part of me feels like the idea "white culture is harmful" is harmful. I think it would be much better if we could split it along economic lines "lower vs upper class" instead of racial lines "black vs white" that would help us draw parallels between the plight of rural Tennessee with inner city Detroit. But it feels like if I started talking about class people would accuse me of using class as a mask for being racist. Which just so happens to be the case here.
- Jimmie_Rustle 9y agoNo one that doesn't spend every waking moment lying to themselves about the realities of our existence would have a problem with anything in that paragraph. Left eating itself