5 ms·
Because otherwise everything up to this point would've been pointless do we really need an article explaining why the survival of our species is important?
by dogma1138 9y ago
Because otherwise everything up to this point would've been pointless do we really need an article explaining why the survival of our species is important?
- jbreckmckye 9y agoJudging by our current political priorities - yes, we do.
- jblow 9y agoIt was a clickbait headline -- note that it has been revised.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- robertwiblin 9y agoI meet people who disagree with this all the time. And clearly even if we think it, as a species we aren't acting on it.
- speakeron 9y agoThat's the Sunk Cost Fallacy. As a rationalist who seeks to maximize my utility, why should I care about future generations?
- mattnewton 9y agoBecause you likely weight the survival of similar genes highly, being decendant from genes that did
- speakeron 9y agoI'm not sure why I would do that, although there are instincts which rely on that (e.g. sex). My immediate concerns are of my somatic existence rather than my genes. If my personal survival depended on the survival of the species (as an example: cryogenics), that would certainly be a factor.
- bendbro 9y agoBecause if your genes didn't historically result in an organism with a drive to propagate itself, your genes would have a significantly higher likelihood of dying out in an ancestor generation. If you do not have that drive, then it is natural to cull yourself.
- contras1970 9y agoyou shouldn't, it's not healthy. you'll contribute more to future generations if you're happy, and individuals who are concerned about whole generations tend to despair. despair leads to loss of sexual appetite, which leads to selection against said trait. ;) you don't need to care about future generations in general, but you probably deeply care about the future of your children. if you do not have any (yet): i'd said similar things before i became a father. since i've had kids... my urge to preserve the well-being of my children specifically is absolutely visceral, and i can only assume (it does seem so) that other parents feel similarly. no parent needs to care about their children's whole generation, the urge to care is decentralized and spread over the whole generation of parents. the next question might be: why would you care about your offspring? because parental care is a trait that helps carry the DNA which encodes it farther than DNA without this trait will get (all other things equal). in general, we care about (a few particular members of) future generations (our offspring) because people who didn't give a fuck about their own children died out.
- lisper 9y agoThis reasoning ignores the tragedy of the commons: Earth is finite, so exponential growth cannot be sustained indefinitely. Even if we go into space, at best we can expand at O(n^2). So the urge to preserve your children has to be tempered by the self-discipline not to have more than two per couple (on average). And that has to somehow be extended to everyone, because even a single breeding pair whose genes allow them to ignore this fundamental fact puts us back on the path to eventual calamity. Sooner or later exponential growth must stop. If we don't do it ourselves, the laws of physics will do it for us.
- okket 9y agoThere is still the real possibility that life is actually pointless. And there is no real justification why humans should rule this instead of any other species. Except made up ones, of course.
- turc1656 9y agoThere is a scientific theory out that has yet to be proven, but addresses the actual purpose of life. https://www.quantamagazine.org/a-new-thermodynamics-theory-of-the-origin-of-life-20140122/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/a-new-thermodynamics-theory-o... TL;DR (with my philosophical interpretations included) - his claim is that life occurs as a natural process to help dissipate concentrations of energy. This occurs because the universe is on a never-ending march toward higher entropy and life is a tool to help it achieve that goal - the goal being maximum entropy and the effective end of the universe as we know it, a situation where all matter is in its most stable state and no energy can be obtained from anything anymore. So we are here to help the universe and all life die.
- contras1970 9y agolife cannot exist without (outside / away from) energy gradients. is the purpose of life to speed up destruction of its environment? even if the answer is yes which i disagree with, it's only an approximative answer: it's immediately followed by "ok but why is it so?" imo, life has as much purpose as stars have: none. it's the wrong question to ask. life is simply there, just like stars are there. it "materializes" when-and-where there are the right conditions (a narrow spectrum of energy gradients), just like stars do (the spectra are extremely far apart, of course).
- mannykannot 9y agoTo be clear, all of the teleological claims here are your own philosophical interpretations; they do not appear to be in the paper discussed in the link you have given. If we accept your interpretation, then I think we must conclude that the purpose of life is to hasten its own extinction, by accelerating dissipative processes.
- 9y ago
- turc1656 9y agoThe survival of our species is irrelevant on the large scale. It is only important to us - the members of the species. Let's he honest, the world as a whole needs nothing from us. In fact, it was arguably better off before us and therefore would benefit without us around. And it's not true that everything up to now would be pointless. Advancements in technology, science, knowledge, etc. have all been enjoyed by those who are living and have previously lived. Any lack of future humans doesn't mean the benefits of those efforts were not realized or consumed.
- Tepix 9y agoLife's purpose is to self-replicate. If we get off our planet we will ensure the long-term self-replication. Without us it wouldn't happen and all life on Earth would sooner or later vanish.
- Smaug123 9y agoWe're the only things around with the capacity to care about the future of the planet. "Better off before us" is context-dependent: the concept of "better" is meaningless without knowing who is doing the judging. Since you are doing the judging, it seems a bit disingenuous to say that the world is arguably better off without you.
- bambax 9y agoIf elephants or tigers or really most mammals but us, are doing the judging, they would agree we are the cause of all of their suffering.
- hood_syntax 9y agoThem being incapable of judgment renders that point somewhat moot.
- bambax 9y agoHow do you know? Don't you think they suffer and weep when they see their siblings being killed? Don't you think they're capable of happiness?
- loteck 9y agoThere exists a theory that says all the suffering that has been experienced up to this point would have been avoided if our species hadn't survived, and that the scale of human-inflicted horror and injustice, which we are doomed to continue repeating forever, far outweighs the relatively small and inconsequential improvements that humans have contributed to nature.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yters 9y agoDoesn't natural suffering of creatures far outweigh anything humans experience or inflict? Plus, we've made life better for countless animals through domestication.
- tzs 9y agoNot everyone agrees that we need our species to survive: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voluntary_Human_Extinction_Movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voluntary_Human_Extinction_Mov... Note: nothing in this comment should be taken as an endorsement of that. I'm just offering it as an example of people who are making an argument that we should not try to survive as a species.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jolmg 9y agoI was really surprised by this, too. It seems like the majority of people don't care for the fate of humanity. Of the people I've asked in the past, they either don't care because they'll be long dead by then, or they believe that we shouldn't change the course of nature.