7 ms·
Reducing congestion? Self-driving is going to make congestion much, much worse. Self-driving makes driving cheaper, safer, easier & more accessible. Anyt
by bryanlarsen 9y ago
Reducing congestion? Self-driving is going to make congestion much, much worse. Self-driving makes driving cheaper, safer, easier & more accessible. Anytime you do that for anything, usage increases dramatically, often in ways that are difficult to fore see. But it's not hard to predict a few:
- cheap delivery will be used for everything
- people will send and summon vehicles from everywhere. I might drive to work, send my vehicle home so somebody else can use it, summon it at the end of day, and drive home.
- et cetera
- jon_richards 9y agoI think the main hope is improving the parking situation. I wonder how much congestion is caused by people driving around slowly looking for parking.
- shuntress 9y agoJust because there is no person in the car, that won't stop it from driving around looking for parking. After my car drives me 45 minutes to work it still needs to park nearby to pick me up after work.
- ensignavenger 9y agoIt can park much further away, and it could even wirelessy locate and reserve a parking spot.
- Jtsummers 9y agoAnd park closer together. I imagine my office parking lot's physical capacity would increase by at least 60% if we didn't have to get in and out of the vehicles. It already has capacity for around 1000 workers (maybe more). Even if they didn't move the lot, my car could drop me off at the entrance and then go find an available spot. The lot is huge, close to a 1/4 mile walk from the furthest available space to my entrance. I wouldn't mind not having to worry about that on those days I'm running late.
- ensignavenger 9y agoAnd they won't need as much space for backing/driving- especially if they can communicate with each other- a car that is blocked in could signal the other cars that it needs out, and they could move to make space for it to get out.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoMaybe it won't be your car, but part of a fleet. So it drops you off and then picks someone else up, perhaps someone doing the reverse commute. Even if it has to go park itself at some fleet lot outside the city center, it should be a marginal improvement over circling, looking for a spot.
- cr0sh 9y agoYou'll change your mind about it not being your car the first time you get into one, it takes off, then you're like "sniff...sniff...ohgodwhatzatsmell", suddenly realizing some drunk person puked (or worse) in the back seat area.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoThat's one reason I avoid public transit in San Francisco. However, it hasn't been a problem in my use of taxis, rental cars, Uber, or Lyft, so I presume it won't be a problem with autonomous cars. They'll either drive themselves to the car wash when someone has an accident (spills, pees, vomits), or if for some reason a "wet" car arrives, then you'll report it, and get the next one.
- sliverstorm 9y agoYet on the other hand many people have proposed parking will be eliminated- instead of parking your car, you'll just send it off to drive in circles around the interstate for a few hours! Wouldn't that be marvelous!
- baldfat 9y agoThey will be driven more efficiently. People are VERY inefecint with driving. Self driving cars won't: 1. Increase their space when the traffic slows down to where there is 300 feet between cars. 2. Less accidents to cause shut downs and lane closures. 3. Merge properly instead of slamming on the brakes and putting on their turn signal 1/4 mile from the merge point. Merging will happen while moving instead of from a stop. 4. Touching their brakes even though they aren't slowing down.
- ufo 9y agoI'm not sure if those would lead to really major changes to congestion, specially once you consider that there will be increased demand for driving once self-driving cars are ubiquitous. The only approach to truly reducing congestion is to switch towards denser public transit. BTW, I suspect that the bigger impact of self-driving cars would actually be the reduced need for parking space.
- baldfat 9y agoI don't see how this causes LA or suburbs to have more cars. It must be well over 99% of people own cars.
- YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 9y agoQuite funny you'd go as far as capitalize your emphasizing, considering that people are the only group of drivers able to drive everywhere. Touching your brakes to flash your brake lights when braking with your engine isn't an altogether bad idea on congested road with traffic waves – it's a good signal to the car behind that you're slowing down (before they can actually see that) so that you can together help mitigate the propagation of the wave.
- Jtsummers 9y agoThat is a valid reason to flash your brake lights. I do that, particularly when I know I'm slowing or will be slowing and someone is following too closely or can't see what I see (that there are brake lights being hit 5 cars ahead and my car is too big for them to see around/through). But I do my best to be a courteous driver. Here in GA, most people don't even seem to understand that the left lane on the highway is the fast lane. Every time I'm on I-75 for more than 5 miles I'll be going speed limit to speed limit +5 and get stuck behind someone doing speed limit - 10 in the left lane. I do not believe that the majority of people tapping their brakes are doing it for a valid reason. It's more often (based on them accelerating at the same time) because they're riding their brakes.
- kcorbitt 9y agoAgree with everything you say. Personally, I hope that self-driving cars are introduced alongside a road-use tax that moves the true cost of road construction and maintenance (and the opportunity cost of all the last currently dedicated to roads) to users, rather than the general public.
- shuntress 9y ago>moves the true cost of road construction and maintenance ... to users, rather than the general public. Public infrastructure should not be a la carte.
- ecshafer 9y agoBuses and trains are. why should roads be purely subsidized? Why should free parking be subsidized. Car driving is massively subsidized and it has a hugely negative impact on the environment, it's expensive, does not scale, and difficult to maintain. Reducing car use, and shifting to a transit and walking focused style of living is better on every front.
- jessriedel 9y agoWhether or not car driving is subsidized, it's incorrect to suggest that it's levied uniformly across the population. Gas tax makes up a very large fraction of public spending on roads. Also, although buses and trains charge per user, they are also heavily subsidized.
- Fricken 9y agoBusses are part of the public transportation infrastructure, just like roads, sidewalks, bridges and everything else. It's weird that they aren't fully subsidized.
- hueving 9y agoBut roads aren't fully subsidized. That's what the gas tax is for. Drivers of electric cars are currently free-riders, which is something that will have to be addressed if they become a significant fraction of drivers.
- cosmie 9y agoWhile true, self-driving vehicles should be able to optimize the flow of traffic more efficiently than humans do. There are known methods for improving the flow of traffic, such as the zipper merge, that are really hard to get humans to do consistently. As well as the cascading effect of different reaction times to going and stopping, delays caused by too aggressive or too conservative lane changing behavior, etc. Once you remove the inconsistent skill level, distractedness, irrationality, and emotional reactions that accompany human drivers, you can increase road utilization considerably without a noticeable increase in congestion.
- tempestn 9y agoThat's true, but most of those measures require near 100% adoption, which obviously will lag significantly behind introduction of fully autonomous vehicles. It is possible the reduced need for downtown parking could significantly reduce congestion in cities though.
- adrianN 9y agoThere is some reason to believe that even a small percentage of "good" drivers can reduce traffic problems such as standing waves on highways: http://trafficwaves.org/trafexp.html http://trafficwaves.org/trafexp.html
- ensignavenger 9y agoLanes dedicated to self driving vehicles could get many of those benefits with relativly low adoption. As adoption increases, more lanes can be dedicated to autonomous mode.
- cosmie 9y agoWill it though? A lot of resistance to more efficient driving patterns is due to emotional reactions (or the fear of emotional reactions). The zipper/delayed merge being the quintessential case[1][2][3]. It works better, a lot of people know it works better, and the only argument against it seem to be "it's dangerous because people are irrational assholes and road rage is a thing"[4]. Once you have self-driving cars around, it might break some of those irrational fears and habits. A self-driving car isn't going to get mad at you if you merge late, it's just going to react to your merging and be done with it. So you're no longer the asshole cutting someone off at the last second, you're just another car that's merging at the point where you have to merge. Road etiquette shifts from emotionally driven to pragmatic, since the self-driving cars around you will also be acting pragmatically. It's not going to slam on the gas and brakes to ride the person in front of them in order to be an asshole to the guy next to them trying to "unfairly get ahead", it's going to maintain a safe driving distance and accelerate and decelerate in a controlled manner to optimize for wear and tear, ride smoothness, fuel economy, and maintaining a safe distance. Self-driving cars will not only be better drivers on the whole, but also allow human drivers to break through inhibitions related to "proper road etiquette", since it's a whole lot easier to do something subjectively rude to a machine than a human. [1] http://transportation.ky.gov/zippermerge/Pages/default.aspx http://transportation.ky.gov/zippermerge/Pages/default.aspx [2] https://arstechnica.com/cars/2014/07/the-beauty-of-zipper-merging-or-why-you-should-drive-ruder/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2014/07/the-beauty-of-zipper-me... [3] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/13/us/why-last-second-lane-mergers-are-good-for-traffic.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/13/us/why-last-second-lane-m... [4] http://jalopnik.com/stop-trying-to-make-the-zipper-merge-happen-1785205684 http://jalopnik.com/stop-trying-to-make-the-zipper-merge-hap...
- Clubber 9y agoNo, but a work from home act would certainly fix congestion at the two busiest times of the day.
- mmanfrin 9y agoBut those cars can drive in tandem. When humans drive, every start and stop has a delay between each driver, and inattentions compound those little delays. Additionally, traffic caused by rubbernecking, by trying to cheat lanes, by not zippering, by reaction inequities all are human problems.
- randyrand 9y agoDisagree entirely. Yes, the number of cars on the road and trips driven will increase, but this will not overshaddow the traffic advantage from SDCs. All in all SDCs should increase road bandwidth about 5x by my estimates. SDCs can drive much, much closer together. They will also never be the cause of phantom traffic jams. For every human that switches to SDC, phantom traffic jams get less likely - a main cause of traffic - which again increases road capacity. We don't have to wait until 100% SDCs to start increasing road capacity either. SDC "convoys" travel as a single unit, and interact cleanly with human drivers. Regardless of SDCs, when road capacity is reached, traffic will happen. But SDCs have the potential to greatly increase road capacity.
- saosebastiao 9y ago> With only self driving cars on the road we have the ability to fix #2, and thus greatly increase road capacity and reduce traffic. Parity would be reached at, say, 4x more cars. This is fantasy land. This idea has been perpetuated by a few layman websites and extremely simplistic closed-loop simulations, but have never been validated by the more sophisticated traffic simulation systems used by traffic engineers. In fact, quite the opposite. Bad reaction times contribute to waves, but waves are just annoying and feel like the cause of congestion to the driver. According to the traffic engineers I know: 1) You can't ever fully get rid of traffic waves because reaction time is only a fraction of the speed mismatch correction problem, physics still dominates. 2) You can't ever fully get rid of speed mismatches. Even a plastic bag flying on the roadway is enough to cause them. 3) Traffic waves only feel like congestion to those who experience them first hand. Minimizing traffic waves doesn't decrease travel times significantly, it merely moves congestion to harder bottlenecks like traffic signals, highway on and off ramps, or merge points. 4) Braess' paradox only manifests itself when agents are acting rationally. As rationality increases, whether through better mapping and routing systems like Waze or by algorithmic rationality of SDCs, more bottlenecks appear that didn't previously manifest themselves under a lower rationality state. Unless you can somehow centrally control SDCs (which is unlikely IMO), this will only become more prevalent.
- bryanlarsen 9y ago5x seems extreme, but I'll certainly grant you 2x on the freeways. But if you put twice, or worse 5x, as many cars on the freeways, that'll just jam up the urban core even worse than it already is. And self-driving cars are probably less efficient than human-driven cars in the urban core simply because they're much less aggressive in their interactions with pedestrians and cyclists. This is a good thing, but it will increase congestion. Efficiency improvements can only add increase capacity by a fixed percentage. The massive improvements in cost ($0 in labour!) and convenience will cause usage to increase by orders of magnitude, IMO.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoYes, also longer commutes, when an hour was acceptable before perhaps 90 minutes is now if you can check your email or read the paper on the way.
- 1_2__4 9y agoThis is what Americans want. Anti-car zealots need to stop thinking you're going to pack the entirety of the country into trains and buses. It's not going to happen, so stop trying to make things painful for the 80%+ of Americans who drive, want to drive, and are interested in government making it easier and more convenient for them to drive. I cannot possibly fathom how the left (which I usually include myself!) went from loving the idea of self-driving electric cars to "no! no! we need to stop people from driving at all costs!".
- mahyarm 9y agoCars are also unused for over %90 of the time, taking up space in some parking spot on premium land close to people's workspaces and homes. On almost every road in america, 2 lanes of traffic are taken up by car parking. In a self driving car future, we can free up those lanes and put excess cars in parking / maintenance towers. The software system managing can predictively dispatch them based on previous demand curves to prevent traffic jams. The amount of cars we would need as a society will equal the peak demand curve, much like electricity demand today. It will also be very likely that those cars will have multiple people in them since a large part of the cost savings will come from car sharing. In the future, we will probably have 1 motor vehicle serving 10 households, vs the almost 1:1 to 1:0.5 ratio we have here in the US today.