8 ms·
The commonwealth countries are all facing a property bubble (Canada, New Zealand, Australia, etc). The household debt levels and property prices didn't taper of
by dmix 9y ago
The commonwealth countries are all facing a property bubble (Canada, New Zealand, Australia, etc). The household debt levels and property prices didn't taper off nearly as much following the 2008 US housing crisis and has pretty much continued unabated: http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/stephen-punwasi/real-estate-bubble-commonwealth_b_12385078.html http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/stephen-punwasi/real-estate-bub...
Which is fascinating to consider that the Bank of Canada, et al, have let this happen for so long and are only reacting now...
By artificially keeping rates near 0% the idea was to 'stimulate' the economy by making capital freely available, so for example, banks can more easily loan money to businesses generating long term economic growth and add new jobs. But the side effect has been that retail banks were incentivized to hand out cheap mortgages and the public was incentivized to speculate on the 'hot' property market.
If this bubble doesn't deflate smoothly this will be yet another very expensive side effect of mainstream monetarist policy.
- benlorenzetti 9y ago> By artificially keeping rates near 0%... I agree with your sentiment and artificially is a powerful word for conveying that. But strictly speaking the rate the central bank sets for lending new money is artificial, or fiat, no matter what we decide it should be (So long as it is > 0).
- e_d_e_v 9y agoYou could set the rate for lending new money algorithmically based on a set of other observed statistics of the credit markets. Then it would not be artificial or fiat. The algorithm might be artificial but the rate itself would not. This is not (to my understanding) how it usually works.
- benlorenzetti 9y agoI would say the rate is still artificial. If windows were the only allowed OS and Linux and Apple users were regularly jailed, I think we would say the price for windows was artificial, no matter if it were set by a government approved algorithm or not. My point is that the connotation we associate with the word artificial varies with our opinion of the legitimacy of the monopoly in question. People who are disinclined toward the federal reserve will read artificial differently from those who think it does a good job.
- bobbles 9y agoAustralia hasnt had 0% interest rates or even close, and all banks compare you against an 8% interest for seviceability comparisons - and the prices still skyrocketed with so much foreign investment. They are doing the right things here and targeting increased rates for investment owners over home occupiers
- kitcar 9y agoI believe the official stance of the bank of Canada is inflation is below target hence the low rates being acceptable for so long. What I don't understand (and I hope someone can shine some light on!) is the basket of goods they use to measure inflation doesn't seem to be very impacted by low interest rates - therefore how will the low rates increase inflation? i.e. banks will only lend to me at below 5% if I'm buying fixed assets like a house - which isn't included in the inflation measure. If I want to borrow to buy groceries, gas, or the other things they measure for inflation I would be borrowing at >19.99%. Therefore all low rates does is cause the price of fixed assets to skyrocket. But those assets are tremendously difficult to convert into consumer spending - i.e. You sell your now inflated house, but rather then spending that "profit" (due to the value of your house increasing) on more groceries and gas most people just roll it into another expensive house as they gotta live somewhere. I guess ultimately there will be a trickle down where everything will get more expensive, but seems like it would be a very long process...
- benlorenzetti 9y agoLow interests rates don't directly cause inflation. For one thing it may not even expand the monetary base, if there are few expansive areas of the economy in need of capital or if there are other even cheaper sources of capital (like trade deficit money returning from overseas). For another thing, if the monetary base is expanding, it could be that all the new cash gets sucked into fixed asset wealth like land and stock value, but the number of transactions fall so that these price increases don't leak out into broader consumer prices or wages. Finally it could be that technological change is causing deflation on the same order of magnitude as the banker's monetary inflation.
- ac29 9y ago>If I want to borrow to buy groceries, gas, or the other things they measure for inflation I would be borrowing at >19.99%. In the US, credit cards are often a fixed + prime rate, so changing national bank interest does affect credit card rates. As as aside, ~20% is an insanely high rate for credit card purchases (again, in the US).
- sunir 9y ago
- cthrow 9y agoAlternative in 2008 was to let the banking system collapse, then rebuild from scratch. Personally I believe many older/sick people would have died if central banks hadn't dropped interest rates and embarked on QE asset purchasing schemes to keep the system afloat. Credit/lending would have all but disappeared for a while, many would have lost access to financial instruments necessary to secure housing, healthcare, insurance. As a young person I'm not happy that we've propped up the status quo, that my rent is stupidly expensive, and that the majority of recovery has gone to the wealthy/those who owned existing equity/assets/real estate, but I can see why it was necessary.
- mempko 9y agoQE didn't increase money supply. The reason we had recovery at all was Obama running huge budget deficits.
- shrewduser 9y agoQE does increase money supply by definition
- mempko 9y agoNo, fed bought bonds. That's like moving money from your savings to your checking account. In fact it likely decreased money supply because more money would have been created if bonds were held longer.
- pishpash 9y agoDropping interest rates, backstopping systematically important institutions during the immediate crisis, and even the first QE were arguably necessary. The subsequent QE's and eight years of 0 interest rates were not.
- cthrow 9y agoWhile it's easy to blame CB's for the past 8 years of stagnation in developed economies, I don't think it's their fault. It's also very hard to say what exactly is the right amount of repurchasing through QE (1.3T in QE1 vs. 4.5T total). CB's just kept repurchasing until unemployment bottomed out, and now that we've hit the bottom, they will start to shrink their balance sheets. That's their mandate - maximize employment, keep consumer prices relatively stable. All CBs can really do is make sure banks have enough money to lend into the economy by adjusting reserve requirements and interest rates. They could massively screw up the economy by jamming interest rates up right now, or dumping all their purchased QE assets back on the market, but they can't really improve the economy strictly through monetary policy. That would require better fiscal and regulatory policy, such as tax code reform, increased spending on R&D and infrastructure, spend on education, etc. Even then it's not guaranteed this spending would lead to any technology-advancing breakthroughs that could raise the standard of living across the economy. Ultimately I believe that low productivity (we've hit a ceiling on the returns to the internet, computer, and smartphone for the moment), plus a lot of the rest of the world catching up in terms of infrastructure, is to blame for the stagnation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nickik 9y agoI'm sorry but you seem to have no idea about the what and why of montary policy. A central bank has to conduct montary policy for the economy as a hole. Attempts by central banks to 'clamp down' on bubbles have generally been catastrophic. Also the low interest rates are simply not just 'artefically low' because of central banks. The montary effect of the interest a central bank sets is determained by the difference to the natural rate. Propery bubbles or any other bubbles by themselfs don't relay cause much problems beyond the markets in question if montary policy stays on target. Aditionally the idea that all these things are bubbles is quite suspect in a lot of places there is real demand for property. Contracting montary policy in order to fight a property bubble would lead to the hole economy going into a recession. The last time the 'fighting bubble theory' was really popular was in 1929. I'm not saying that was the only reason for the Great Depression, but its one of the major reasons.
- FooHentai 9y ago>Additionally the idea that all these things are bubbles is quite suspect in a lot of places there is real demand for property. What do you define as 'real demand'? There are three main areas of demand for housing property: 1. People requiring shelter (i.e. people who will purchase a property to live in themselves) or 2. People purchasing property to extract rents (landlords) or 3. People purchasing property to later on-sell for a greater amount (property investors) It's the third class of buyer that many believe is driving demand, and there's certainly a strong argument that the property investor class is bigger today because of depressed interest rates. Because of this increased demand, prices increase. But that price increase is driven only by the perceived future sale value of the property. This is why it's a bubble - The returns are predicated only on continued buy-in to the market. It's little more than a ponzi scheme. This assertion falls apart if you don't accept the premise that current activity is being driven by investors, of course.
- nickik 9y agoI dont know if something is a bubble or not. At some time in the future the value will be lower then now, is that in 1 year or 10 years, or never. Nobody knows that. That however had nothing to do with montary policy. If you want to crack down on the third class of buyers to protect the others from price volatility or other things that is something else that I dont have a opinion about. Also, investment however flawed is simply not the same as a ponzi scheme. Fundamentaly however you have to realise that low interest rates are not artefical. If the natural interst rate were as high as in 2006 with the rates we observe now we would see a massive collapse of the money supply and a recession worse then the great depression. Interest rate in the hole world have been going down since 1970. A recession itself depresses real rates, because investment is simple not as profitable. The idea that the central bank can indepentenly fix housing bubbles and create stable demand is just flawed, its simply not possible. Its the wrong tool for the thing you want to fix. The central bank could simple start buying and selling property instead of bonds, but that just replaces stability in one market with instability in another.
- dblohm7 9y ago> Which is fascinating to consider that the Bank of Canada, et al, have let this happen for so long and are only reacting now... In Canada this is because the real estate bubbles were confined to Vancouver and Toronto. Raising interest rates to cool down real estate in those two cities would have been bad for the rest of the country.
- dmix 9y agoThe property bubbles are limited (primarily) to those two major cities, yes. That's a good point. But the high household debt issue is country wide. Property ownership in those two cities also isn't limited to being a resident of those cities either. A significant amount of properties are rented out and the landlord can live outside of the cities, so the effects of a drop in prices will be widely felt. Combined with the fact those two cities and surrounding areas represent a significant percentage of the total population. The US housing crisis was itself limited to a group of areas in the country in varying degrees as well, for example Florida got hit way harder than most places. The group was just far larger given the country's population is 10x the size of Canada. And Bank of Canada has started to add mortgage restrictions this year country-wide so they too see it as something that needs to be addressed nationally.
- NathanCH 9y agoThat's a bit misleading, by no means was/is the bubble limited to these cities. More like B.C and Ontario.
- randomdata 9y agoThat may be an exaggeration as well. As a resident of Southern Ontario, but not Toronto, the CREA data shows that home prices in my area were stagnant, to slight decline, for most of the last decade. It has only been in the last year that any meaningful price appreciation has been observed. And I attribute the recent price appreciation to an improving economy and near record low unemployment (currently 2.9%).
- crescentfresh 9y ago
- alkonaut 9y agoMortgages are still normally time based so the monthly expense of paying it off over say 30 years limits the umbers somewhat. In Sweden we moved from interest only mortgages to 100 years as the norm. Still too long. Doesn't work well with near zero interest rates.
- hughes 9y ago"Fixed rate" mortgages in Canada still need to renew every five years, even on a 30 year amortization. As a result, people who bought homes in 2012/2013 will be affected by rising rates as well as a new affordability test. They'll need to prove they could qualify for the loan at 2-3% higher rates in anticipation of the rate environment at their next renewal. As a result, people who qualified & budgeted for loans at 2.5% in 2013 will suddenly have to be qualified for 6% loan interest within the next few months. In terms of financial impact, this could represent an additional $1300 monthly expense people will have to budget for on a ~$450,000 loan.
- alkonaut 9y ago> will suddenly have to be qualified for 6% loan interest within the next few months. What if they are not? If the loan isn't granted, then the lender will have to go elsewhere, and worse case they will have to sell the property, possibly at a loss. That would seem like it just exposes the bank to more risk? Situation here is that you simply keep paying and the bank doesn't care whether you pay 110% of your income because you are unemployed, or 10% of your income because you got promoted - so long as you are paying. Stress tests/qualification can therefore be against a "high interest rate" which is typically 7-8%. What's interesting is that even a 4% interest rate at this point would probably lead to a recession because people are so highly in debt that they would cut saving/spending immediately. That recession would likely see interest rates plummet again. So the "new equilibrium" is a scary low.
- andys627 9y ago> But the side effect has been that retail banks were incentivized to hand out cheap mortgages and the public was incentivized to speculate on the 'hot' property market. Any source for this?
- wyatte 9y agoWell "only reacting now" might be a stretch. A few years back they elimintated 40 year mortgages putting them back to 25 years and adjusted the loan requirements. Canada isn't facing a housing bubble as much as they are facing a debt bubble. Most of the recent household debt that has been record breaking year after year has been with credit cards, autos and lines of credit.
- mgbmtl 9y ago> "Canada isn't facing a housing bubble as much as they are facing a debt bubble." Are you sure? I've seen articles mentioning increasing debt in general, but that's mostly tied to mortgages, which isn't a big deal (unless rates rise quickly, which is unlikely). For example: http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canada-credit-cards-transunion-1.4015250 http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canada-credit-cards-transuni... "[credit card] delinquency rates in British Columbia and Ontario dropped by 2.1 per cent and 3.3 per cent, respectively." (by contrast to Alberta and Saskatchewan) Car loans are ~ 2% of total debt, at least in Quebec: https://www.desjardins.com/ressources/pdf/pv170828f.pdf?resVer=1503924048000 https://www.desjardins.com/ressources/pdf/pv170828f.pdf?resV...
- wyatte 9y agoAs I understand it, housing is out of control in Toronto and Vancouver which accounts for most of the averaged out increase in Canada's housing prices over the last 8 years. These out of control cities are experiencing the increases because of foreign purchasers pushing up the prices (they may only account for 5-10% of purchases, but that money has impacted all pricing through competition). And Canada is a great place for foreigners to have their money. [edit: note that TO is in a short term downwards price adjustment due to the 15% foreigner tax put in recently, that will stabilize this year, but still over the last 8 years TO pricing has skyrocketted] Even so housing across Canada has gotten more expensive. Through gentrification in these big cities, smaller cities have seen people move in causing some nominal increases too. The result is that people all around are needing to allocate more and more money towards housing leaving them having to use credit cards and loans more. You can do a Google search on Canada household debt and there's no shortage of articles declaring record breaking household (non-mortgage) debt levels. So yeah it's all one big problem, but it's the household debt that's going to kill them, not the mortgage debt. Foreigners will continue to invest in Canada even during a recession, because Canada will still be a good investment on a relative basis. Big cities like Vancouver and TO will hold their value as all big cities tend to even during recessions. Just look at how quickly NYC managed/recovered post 2009 compared to other US cities. All this leads me to believe that people are in financial trouble due to household debt, though maybe it's semantics. For some when, mortgage renewals come about, does it really matter which?
- sbenitoj 9y agoYou're right -- the commonwealth countries are in for a rude awakening! Especially considering government debts worldwide have increased A LOT since the 2008 financial crisis [0], they don't have the same ability to inflate their way out of the next crisis that they had after the 2008 crisis. Even though I agree with the spirit of your statement, I don't think that central banks "let this happen" -- on the contrary, fiat currencies and central banks BY DESIGN massively exacerbate (and arguably cause) the boom and bust cycle [1]. Without central banks unilaterally determining the price of borrowing money (AKA interest rates) and propping up bankrupt institutions (e.g. see 2008 bank bailouts), the natural boom and bust cycle would have a much lower amplitude as the market would determine the price of borrowing money rather than disconnected bureaucrats sitting in the room pouring over the latest econometric reports. Price controls don't work for goods and services (see the USSR) and they certainly don't work for money either! [0] Worldwide Government Debt - https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/GC.DOD.TOTL.GD.ZS https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/GC.DOD.TOTL.GD.ZS [1] Austrian Business Cycle Theory - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austrian_business_cycle_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austrian_business_cycle_theory
- mempko 9y agoGovernment debt is never the problem considering government has monopoly to create new money. The problem is private debt. In fact if you look at why private debt increases it's usually correlated to a DECREASE of government debt. For example, the Clinton surplus forced private sector into massive debt. If you haven't noticed, the common wealth countries have been going through a huge austerity program. This austerity is the likely reason private debt increased heavily. Also since corporate tax rates were also lowered, corporations kept more of their profits. They used these to invest in assets like stocks, bonds, and real-estate. In other words, austerity plus lower tax rates equals high private debt.
- sbenitoj 9y ago"Government debt is never the problem considering government has monopoly to create new money." Not for long they don't! Cryptocurrencies have finally found a way to get around such unethical control of the world's monetary systems. And government controlling the monetary systems does not make government debt irrelevant -- even if they can always print more money, they can't always avoid hyperinflation. And regardless, printing money is stealing from savers, so it's not exactly some noble activity.
- GatorD42 9y agoIt's not necessarily artificial to keep rates low. I would argue it's artificial to set rates anywhere, and likely market rates without intervention would be close to zero. Your theory of bank lending and asset bubbles is not consistent with mainstream monetarist theory. Banks are not that affected by the interest rate channel of monetary policy since borrowing at 0% and lending at 1% is not that different from borrow at 4% and lending at 5%. Low interest rates are supposed to spur inflation through the interest rate channel (which affects businesses by making them want to invest more, not banks) and the credit channel. Because of sticky prices and sticky wages in the short term the economy can grow faster than usual in the short term. Long term real effects should be negligible. I don't believe the conventional story is accurate either but your description is not completely correct.
- sbenitoj 9y ago"I would argue it's artificial to set rates anywhere, and likely market rates without intervention would be close to zero." Why would interest rates be zero without intervention? Who would lend money to someone else for free?
- GatorD42 9y agoThe rate the central bank sets is effectively a floor below which banks will not lend. The effective Federal Funds Rate in the U.S. is around 1.16% The one year Treasury rate is around 1.24%. People and banks are lending money to the government for one year for essentially .08%, and this is not entirely risk free. Rates went negative after the financial crisis, and German bond rates are below Treasuries. If banks could find funding at 0.1% they would make money lending at 0.2% (depending on and adjusting for risk). So central bank rates are probably keeping interest rates higher than they would be. All of this is controversial and no one knows for certain how central banks, interest rates, and inflation interact, it's a complex dynamic system and popular descriptions are simplifications that are probably wrong.
- jamez1 9y agoTheir open market operations affect short term bond yields which in turn affect long term bond yields. They clearly intervene and it's hard to imagine interest rates being as low as they have been without the intervention. When they buy bonds, it pushes the yields lower, if things were where they were naturally the fed/ecb etc wouldn't have the sheer number of bonds they do on their balance sheet.
- Mikeb85 9y agoDon't forget that property prices were also inflated by foreign buyers looking for a safe place to put their money outside their governments' reach, and that this practice was encouraged by the outgoing government (probably the current one as well). Also, another issue is that you can cause a housing market crash and financial crisis by abruptly increasing the rate when household debt is at a high.
- refurb 9y agoForeign ownership was pretty limited in Canada. I think the highest level was in Vancouver proper and it was ~10%. Housing prices went nuts in Canada because Canadians felt they were being priced out and "real estate always goes up".