4 ms·
I know pg is constantly tweaking the comments algorithms, so perhaps this is why lately I've noticed very few comments with more than 5 or so karma points. Man
by jacksoncarter 16y ago
I know pg is constantly tweaking the comments algorithms, so perhaps this is why lately I've noticed very few comments with more than 5 or so karma points. Many months/years ago, you'd come to the comments and there's be a couple really great comments at the top. So much so that it I didn't need to read the article.
Lately however, I've noticed that the top comments all have one or maybe two karma points. Sometimes I can scroll down and find a comment with 30+ points, but the ones above it are one liners and not really interesting. Overall, the comments have become less interesting.
It's like a lot of barking dogs, short quips, lack of insight. The commenters seem like they don't want to add value, but rather, want to get their username on the board or something.
- philk 16y agoI understand what you're saying, but I think the signal:noise ratio on HN is better than most other places on the web. Plus, there's still plenty of quality, detailed comments. For example in this thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1517339 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1517339 The first comment I see is both the longest and highest rated. It also contains quite a lot of worthwhile information.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]