4 ms·
Because not all poor people have children, and in many cases, having a pet first can be good training for having a child, especially when you run into situation
by kbenson 9y ago
Because not all poor people have children, and in many cases, having a pet first can be good training for having a child, especially when you run into situations where it's hard to make ends meet and you need to make some tough choices. If you own a pet and making sure they have enough to eat is hard to do, that should definitely factor into whether you can support a child if your financial situation hasn't changed.
Beyond that, it's a quality of life issue. Pets can drastically increase the quality of life of people by providing companionship. Questioning why the poor are getting pets is like questioning why the poor have a smartphone, or even just the internet. To some, it looks like a luxury, but a long time ago it became much harder to lead a normal life without internet access. For example, last week was back to school night for my daughter's sixth grade class. All teacher correspondence is through email, updates about classwork is through email or the teacher website, and if you have a problem with the math homework, there's handy set of instructions for how to get instructional videos from the math website. Don't have a computer or a phone that can use the internet (which face it, is probably cheaper)? Guess you have to find a relative or head to the library to get help.
Any time you question whether the poor should be spending their money on something you see as a luxury item, you should step back and think about why they are doing it, and what non-obvious benefits it might impart. That even goes for clothes.
- rootlocus 9y ago> Guess you have to find a relative or head to the library to get help. I fail to see how going to a library means "much harder to lead a normal life". Personally, I would go insane without internet. All my activities depend to some degree on having access to the internet. But going to the library to check for instructions for homework? People have done that for hundreds of years.
- kbenson 9y ago> But going to the library to check for instructions for homework? People have done that for hundreds of years. You don't check out anything, you use a computer on-site to view instructions. Libraries as a place of distribution function fundamentally differently than libraries as internet cafes. Even if your job hours overlap with almost all library hours, you still have the weekend to go to a library and check out books that can be used all week. Internet access from the library is only available while at the library. Our library is nice enough to have (and be able to afford) extended hours on Wednesday, so they are open until 8 PM, otherwise they close at 5 or 6 each day. Good luck using it on other weekdays if you have traditional work hours. Need to respond to an email regarding a prospective new job? I'm sure they won't mind if you take a few days to get back to them... > I fail to see how going to a library means "much harder to lead a normal life". Personally, I would go insane without internet. The context is people criticizing the poor for owning a smartphone. Not only does it solve the internet access problem, but it's probably cheaper, even with the phone cost, than a computer plus separate internet service, since the alternative is not no phone, but a dumb phone (which isn't free).
- mthoms 9y agoThe other commenter was talking about "all correspondence" with the school and you changed that to mean "do occasional homework". >I fail to see how going to a library means "much harder to lead a normal life". In the context of a modern education, you don't think having home internet access is a huge advantage (versus having to visit a library)? You really can't be serious?