7 ms·

Aren't you worried that incorporation is a consequence of successful entrepreneurship rather than a predictor?

BenjaminTodd 9y ago
Yes - they try to address that in the paper, but it's hard.
rgbrenner 9y ago
That's exactly the flaw with this entire blog post. All of the conclusions are a waste of time... Of course they show those results, when you make a mistake this big.
maxxxxx 9y ago
Totally agree. You need a certain level of money to deal with incorporation. Then it makes sense but you first need to make that money. You may as well have gone with price of people's cars and concluded that it's best to buy a Porsche if you want to be successful.
graeme 9y ago
Main point I was thinking of. I'm self-employed, and my business is growing. Once I reach a certain income level, I will incorporate. Before that point, the legal and time costs aren't worth it. But, this stuck out as something worthy of more study: >The average incorporated self-employed person is highly able – they did well on aptitude tests like the SAT, they have high self-esteem, and were successful in salaried employment, earning more than other workers with similar characteristics. There could be a subset of the self-employed that is basically "soon to be incorporated", which is the group I believe myself to be in. In my case, my salaried peer group are graduates of one of the top Canadian law schools. My default non-business option would have been a high salary; I only did business because I thought I could get something comparable, but with more freedom. You might be able to use the common traits among the incorporated to do further analysis within the self-employed group.
- kanwisher 9y ago
  Not sure in Canada, but in US you can incorporate same day in most states. You literally goto an office and stand in line behind plumbers and other contract works for 20min, fill one form and your done. Even turbo tax can ha dale basic business taxes so this is not a problem either
  - graeme 9y ago
    Are they counting LLC as incorporated? That would significantly change the US situation. My understanding is that LLC is very similar to sole proprietorship in Canada, but with limited liability added in. My comment may be invalid then. Canada has no such structure, so incorporation is a big threshold. You can still do it easily, but it adds a lot of accounting and admin work.

Yes - they try to address that in the paper, but it's hard.

That's exactly the flaw with this entire blog post. All of the conclusions are a waste of time... Of course they show those results, when you make a mistake this big.

maxxxxx 9y ago

Totally agree. You need a certain level of money to deal with incorporation. Then it makes sense but you first need to make that money. You may as well have gone with price of people's cars and concluded that it's best to buy a Porsche if you want to be successful.

graeme 9y ago

Main point I was thinking of. I'm self-employed, and my business is growing. Once I reach a certain income level, I will incorporate. Before that point, the legal and time costs aren't worth it. But, this stuck out as something worthy of more study: >The average incorporated self-employed person is highly able – they did well on aptitude tests like the SAT, they have high self-esteem, and were successful in salaried employment, earning more than other workers with similar characteristics. There could be a subset of the self-employed that is basically "soon to be incorporated", which is the group I believe myself to be in. In my case, my salaried peer group are graduates of one of the top Canadian law schools. My default non-business option would have been a high salary; I only did business because I thought I could get something comparable, but with more freedom. You might be able to use the common traits among the incorporated to do further analysis within the self-employed group.

kanwisher 9y ago
Not sure in Canada, but in US you can incorporate same day in most states. You literally goto an office and stand in line behind plumbers and other contract works for 20min, fill one form and your done. Even turbo tax can ha dale basic business taxes so this is not a problem either
- graeme 9y ago
  Are they counting LLC as incorporated? That would significantly change the US situation. My understanding is that LLC is very similar to sole proprietorship in Canada, but with limited liability added in. My comment may be invalid then. Canada has no such structure, so incorporation is a big threshold. You can still do it easily, but it adds a lot of accounting and admin work.