3 ms·
I find it surprising that Dropbox has access to its users files. I thought cloud storage companies kept everything encrypted, or at least access. My company us
by pier25 9y ago
I find it surprising that Dropbox has access to its users files. I thought cloud storage companies kept everything encrypted, or at least access.
My company uses Dropbox extensively for storing documents with sensitive information.
- atrus 9y agoIt's probably a safe assumption that if you can view files online, they are able to access any of the files. Although there is a database of hashes and whatnot for child porn that service providers can access, so they don't necessarily need unencrypted access to the files, since they can hash locally and send that to their servers.
- lend000 9y agoThat's the value proposition of something like Siacoin or Filecoin. If Dropbox did that, you wouldn't be able to reset your password (since they do not store your password, just a salted hash, I hope). Dropbox does plenty of interesting things with its users' files to optimize storage. I know they dedupe files, probably using a file hash. Perhaps they optimize even further.
- pier25 9y ago> If Dropbox did that, you wouldn't be able to reset your password Right, or course. I'm thick today.
- woranl 9y agoDropbox holds all the encryption keys. They do not use end to end encryption.
- Lazare 9y agoNope. Dropbox has never claimed they don't have access to your files, and you should generally assume that cloud providers are always looking through your data unless they explicitly claim otherwise (and maybe even if they do). Dropbox has been in the news for scanning user files for years (eg, [1][2][3]). Note that the third link dates back to 2011; not a new issue. If you do want to keep your data secure from the cloud provider, encrypt it yourself, or use a service that encrypts it before uploading using a key you provide (and with a client you trust not to be compromised). Spideroak makes a big play for this market[4], but I can't vouch for them. [1]: http://www.pcworld.com/article/2048680/dropbox-takes-a-peek-at-files.html http://www.pcworld.com/article/2048680/dropbox-takes-a-peek-... [2]: https://www.extremetech.com/computing/179495-how-dropbox-knows-youre-a-dirty-pirate-and-why-you-shouldnt-use-cloud-storage-to-share-copyrighted-files https://www.extremetech.com/computing/179495-how-dropbox-kno... [3]: https://readwrite.com/2011/04/20/how-to-keep-dropbox-employees/ https://readwrite.com/2011/04/20/how-to-keep-dropbox-employe... [4]: https://spideroak.com/no-knowledge/ https://spideroak.com/no-knowledge/
- intherdfield 9y ago> Nope. Dropbox has never claimed they don't have access to your files I don't mean to nitpick and it's been a while, but Dropbox used to claim that "even our employees can't access your files". People called them out on the misleading language and they changed it. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/at-dropbox-even-we-cant-see-your-dat-er-nevermind-update/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/at-dropbox-even-we-cant-see-you...
- Lazare 9y agoWow, that's really shady. Good catch!
- gramakri 9y agoWill features like content search work on the website if contents are encrypted?
- pier25 9y agoIt could create a catalog like Spotlight does before encrypting
- wmil 9y agoDropbox is actually pretty invasive. They save space and bandwidth by recognizing media files that other people have stored and just copying internally instead of uploading from your computer.
- pier25 9y agoAny source on that?
- wmil 9y agoNo, this is from memory, I could be wrong. Specifically I recall a story that pirates were using their api to just upload the hash and basically use it as a file transfer service. They had to start requesting random chunks of files to make sure you actually had the file you were trying to sync. Edit - I found a link: http://www.wired.co.uk/article/dropbox-dmca-position http://www.wired.co.uk/article/dropbox-dmca-position
- mixmax 9y agoI remember a story where someone uploaded a large file known to be popular (a new torrented movie if I recall correctly) that would have a reasonably chance of already being in someone elses dropbox. The file uploaded in an instant, lending a lot of credibility to the theory that the software hashes a file and looks for the same hash in a central database, and if there's a match doesn't bother to upload the file but simply adds a pointer to it.
- warrenm 9y agoIt's basic dedup tech Not really surprising
- technion 9y agoThe standard problem is "define encryption". I have no knowledge of Dropbox' internals, but I've been involved with several cloud backups solutions that "fully encrypt your data". Only to have a hard time convincing people that "Full Disk Encryption on a server" will do little to prevent an employee of that company accessing data.