3 ms·
I think that there are two big differences between the Industrial Revolution and similar past increases in automation and what is happening now. 1. The workers
by tzs 9y ago
I think that there are two big differences between the Industrial Revolution and similar past increases in automation and what is happening now.
1. The workers then were displaced in many (most?) cases by newly invented physical machines. Those machines had to be built in brand new factories, employing many workers. Building those machines greatly boosted the need for many resources, such as metals, lubricants, fuels, and wood, so indirectly created many jobs in those industries. The machines needed frequent and regular maintenance, spawning even more jobs and industries.
What's going on now seems different. Our automation nowadays involves much less new physical machines. As an example, consider self driving big rig trucks, which some think will be the first self driving vehicles to displace a large number of workers.
What is the difference between a self driving big rig and a regular big rig? The self driving one is essentially a regular one with some additions:
• some sensors,
• some motors or actuators to operate controls,
• one or more computers that run the driving software, and handle the interface with the human who is in charge,
• maybe some kind of wireless communication system so the driving software can receive orders from the trucking company if that's not handled by a human who accompanies the truck.
None of these things are new. What's new is putting them in a truck.
Let's focus on the computers. Let's be optimistic and assume that every single new big rig that comes off the assembly line is equipped from the factory for self driving, so every single one needs a computer. Let's further assume that they use a high end GPU to run the AI software.
Putting a high end GPU in every single new big rig in the US would raise total annual demand for high end GPUs by about 10%. That's not "build a new factory" territory. That's "authorize a little overtime at the GPU factory" territory.
It's similar for other things. Each big rig now has a few electric motors so the AI can steer and shift gears and brake...but as with GPUs that's just a small bump in the total demand.
Worse, many of these things, like the GPUs, the sensors, probably the motors, and probably the communications system are built in highly automated factories, so even if the factories have to kick up production with overtime or even add new shifts, it will be machines getting the new work.
2. During the Industrial Revolution we had large, rapidly expanding frontiers.
If you were in the developed part of your country and lost your job to a machine there was a good chance you could go to the frontier and find a similar job that was safe from the machines because the frontier lacked the infrastructure to support the machine.
Our frontiers now, to the extent that we even have any, are small and not expanding much if at all, and we've gotten a lot better at getting our machines there.