3 ms·
X-Com shipped with a broken difficulty selector, so that all games were played on "Easy" regardless of your setting. The gameplay could be slow and ponderous at
by jerf 9y ago
X-Com shipped with a broken difficulty selector, so that all games were played on "Easy" regardless of your setting. The gameplay could be slow and ponderous at the best of times, and at the worst of times (chasing down the one last alien) could be quite maddeningly slow, literally at times 10-30 minutes of nothing. (Then the last alien gets the drop on you and your dude dies.) Some of the mechanics are pretty opaque in the era before "I'll just read a complete disassembly of the game engine on GameFAQs." Some of that is probably a part of the love for the game, but by most modern standards that's a flaw in a game. (Having to discover mechanics is not intrinsically a flaw, but making them somewhat undiscoverable kinda is.)
I'm not sure I'd defend the "deeply" part of "deeply flawed", because IMHO it still belongs in a different category than some of those other games; it came much closer to doing what it set out to do deliberately, it did not just accidentally back into being a good game despite itself. However, I will defend that X-Com was somewhat flawed. The very fact that they could ship the difficulty selector broken, because nobody noticed, because the difference was not big enough to be noticeable, is a pretty decently sized problem on its own; that affects everything from top to bottom right there.
- the_af 9y agoBecause X-Com was widely considered a masterpiece by the standards of its day (unfair to compare it to today's games, and anyway that wasn't the point of TFA) it's extremely confusing to list it as an example of a flawed or frustrating game. You already mentioned the pace: that was one of its strong points, not a weakness. I -- and most of its fans, I'd guess -- liked the game because of its deliberately slow pace, not in spite of it. Why, I remember about 15-20 years ago I debated with someone about real-time vs turn-based games, and why I preferred the latter, and used X-Com as an example!. Like you also mentioned, I don't think most people realized about the "Easy" setting bug back then (I certainly didn't!). "Easy" was difficult enough anyway, so I think this criticism doesn't apply. We're not talking about bugs here (which happen in every game), but about "flawed" gameplay, and how you experienced the game back when you played it. Nobody complained about the broken difficulty setting, so this couldn't cause a frustrating experience. To me, picking X-Com as an example of a flawed game is like picking a movie everyone considers a classic masterpiece and declaring it flawed because there is a scene which is somewhat out of focus: it's an act of snobbery.