3 ms·
This has to be some sort of fallacy. After all, I don't expect my cardiologist to have a heart attack before he can tell me how to recover.
by StavrosK 9y ago
This has to be some sort of fallacy. After all, I don't expect my cardiologist to have a heart attack before he can tell me how to recover.
- elmigranto 9y agoI feel like agreeing with your sentiment, though your example seems a bit off. Becoming cardiologist is like a decade of school and certifications, so in my opinion, the better analogy would be criticizing a movie without writing/directing a Hollywood-scale production.
- whfolsom4 9y agoWhy didn't you just choose to not have a heart attack? That is half of the writer's thesis.
- JamesBarney 9y agoThe title is mis-leading and click-baity, but the article argues a more reasonable position. A more appropriately named title would be "Before giving advice on how to climb out of poverty, think a little harder about all of the consequences of a given decision before recommending it to the poor, especially if you haven't had experience living in poverty." She uses the example of "getting rid of your car", which sounds great until you tally up the costs of increased child care, reduced hours, and limited comparison shopping.
- Noos 9y agoThat is a fallacy though, a cardiologist has extensively studied to treat heart attacks and made it his professional calling to tell you how to recover. Most rich people honestly have little to no idea about poverty at all; no real observations or professional/scientific data. They extrapolate based on what they do, rather than what is out there, and assume since they did it, it's a universal law that applies to everyone.
- pizza 9y agoBut you would expect your cardiologist to tell people without a record of cardiology experience/practice to not mislead people at risk of heart problems with ideas the armchair cardiologists have never used once, let alone to depend on for survival.