4 ms·
Factory tolerances are not the key ingredient for weather tight buildings. Water and air management at the joints is. Good management can be achieved by careful
by brudgers 9y ago
Factory tolerances are not the key ingredient for weather tight buildings. Water and air management at the joints is. Good management can be achieved by careful design or by proven practice. Proven practice is why shingles can be weathertight with only moderate attention.
The reason hippie domes leaked is getting the details right during construction is hard and foregoing proven practice makes it much much harder.
Like pretty much every machined building concept other than the mobile home, Fuller's ideas were unsuccessful. Mostly because building weathertight buildings is a solved problem. The solutions are just not evenly distributed.
- Animats 9y agoThere's a huge success story in machined buildings - Butler Buildings.[1] They have about 100 standard steel parts, from which industrial and farm buildings can easily be constructed. Rural America has millions of their buildings, from small sheds to large factories. They offer wall and roof sections with and without insulation. (Their site promotes the fancier options for schools, malls, and churches, but the volume is in the plain metal ones.) There are competing systems, such as Behlen.[2] ("Good iron. GREAT experience"). All these systems bolt together on site, usually mounted to a concrete slab. Such buildings are dull, boring, weathertight, easy to erect, and durable. They're rarely seen in cities, so many people don't know about them. But get thirty miles outside a big city and they're everywhere. [1] http://butlermfg.com/en/butler_systems_details http://butlermfg.com/en/butler_systems_details [2] http://behlenbuildingsystems.com/resources/photo-gallery/agricultural/ http://behlenbuildingsystems.com/resources/photo-gallery/agr...
- brudgers 9y agoPre-engineered metal buildings [1] like those offered by Butler are an excellent form of construction for many applications. The components are fabricated using standard processes of the steel industry (milling, extrusion, roll forming, etc.). To the degree these create a machined building in agreggate, then likewise the aggregate of dimensional lumber, plywood, OSB, asphalt shingles, gypsum board, concrete masonry, insulated concrete forms, etc. [1]: For what it is worth most pre-engineered metal buildings in the US come from mom-and-pop shops rather than the big players like Butler because engineering is engineering and roll formed steel production is a commodity.
- erikpukinskis 9y ago> Mostly because building weathertight buildings is a solved problem. The solutions are just not evenly distributed. Yes, but these two things are connected. Cheap, fixed, weathertight buildings are a solved problem. But as soon as you fix a building to the ground, you enshrine a rent seeking opportunity, and that space will then be subject to market rates, which will make the resource unevenly distributed. If we had cheap, mobile, weathertight buildings (and another of other mobile amenities around them) then you could decouple the living space from the market locked to the location, and you could get something closer to even distribution.
- Animats 9y agoUtopia is trailer parks?
- erikpukinskis 9y agoTrailers are probably not small enough, not cheap enough, and not easy enough to move around in tight quarters. Also: "utopia" in this sense is just "provides a path for re-entry to society to homeless". Not some sort of grand remaking of the city.