7 ms·
ICO is a distribution service on-top of a blockchain system. That's not all that interesting in this conversation. What is interesting is the same thing that h
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
ICO is a distribution service on-top of a blockchain system. That's not all that interesting in this conversation.
What is interesting is the same thing that has been interesting from the beginning of the blockchain discussion. Namely that these "coins" purportedly offer an alternative currency to sovereign national currency.
I have always held the view that, the fundamental utility of doing commerce through a currency that is outside of sovereign national control/purview is a hard ceiling for any of these systems. Probably the biggest lever a government has on their nation is monetary policy. There is no way that a government would allow the subversion of that.
At the point in which any alternative currency based market becomes big enough to matter within the boundaries of an existing currency based market, then all a sovereign nation needs to do to kill it is make convertibility to the local currency illegal.
China is basically saying, "look we don't even want to come close to this type of alternative currency possibly getting huge" - and the ICO method allows pretty much anyone to convert Yuan to "coin." So they went ahead and did what I have been suggesting would happen, but much earlier than I suspected.
The only way that wouldn't work is if nearly all necessary services, retail, logistics etc... uses the alternative currency. In which case the native currency has effectively failed and thus the government has failed as well.
So I don't see what the real upside here is, outside of very tiny, niche marketplaces that require this kind of currency.
I haven't heard anyone actually respond to this line of criticism of Blockchain.
Blockchain is a perfect solution for many things, but as a currency it's dead on arrival IMO.
- ojr 9y ago"Blockchain" is nothing but a fancy database without Bitcoin, good luck making it completely illegal like alcohol, marijuana, torrents
- korzun 9y ago> "Blockchain" is nothing but a fancy database without Bitcoin, good luck making it completely illegal like alcohol, marijuana, torrents I will put my money on the Chinese government. Your Bitcoins are worthless if you can't exchange them. A business will not risk losing their 'real' assets in favor of Bitcoin 'economy.' The play in the U.S is cute but make no mistake; the government can pull the plug at any given moment, and there is absolutely nothing you will or can do about it.
- aianus 9y agoIt's illegal to convert Yuan into USD but that doesn't make the USD worthless. Similarly with Facebook, Google, etc which are all banned in China. If the Chinese government is the only government that bans Bitcoin, I would put my money on Bitcoin. Of course if they convince the EU and US to join the ban then I would agree with you.
- korzun 9y agoComparing USD to Bitcoins is a sign of drinking too much Kool-Aid. The U.S will never allow a bunch of randoms to have any financial leverage because they 'mined' a virtual coin. Corporations and people with money will just flee the country. People with serious money laugh at Bitcoin 'millionaires'.
- aianus 9y agoUmm ok? I don't see the connection to your previous point which was saying the Chinese government can single-handedly destroy Bitcoin worldwide (or even in China). Drugs are highly illegal all over the world and yet it's still easy to buy them with a few phone calls. Now imagine if drugs could be shipped instantly over the internet from another jurisdiction where they were legal. There would really be no way to stop them. China can't do shit on their own if Bitcoin stays legal in EU/US.
- westiseast 9y agoNot saying you're wrong, but isn't a lot of the massive rise from ~200 USD up to ~3000 USD related to Chinese activity? And Chinese farms mine most of the bitcoins now?
- just_one_time_ 9y agoWhy is my $millions in quotes? Do you think when I deposit my money Bank of America puts my balance in quotes because it came from Bitcoin? My point is, as time goes on, your type of nay-saying just becomes more a parody of itself. You will probably go to your grave thinking only gold, silver and the all mighty USD are "real money". Whatever, i'll just keep laughing back at you all the way to the bank.
- philfrasty 9y ago„...convertibility to the local currency illegal...“ curious: what would be a real world example of this already existing?
- AndrewKemendo 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_exchange_controls https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_exchange_controls Very common up until the late 20th century.
- ericb 9y ago> all a sovereign nation needs to do to kill it is make convertibility to the local currency illegal. This only works if all countries do it, and as is evident from the difficulty in getting coordinated world-wide action on climate-change, this is problematic. As an example, if I have tokens worth enough to say, buy a mansion in France, I can certainly find a local person who vacations in France that will take them for payment in exchange for some local asset. What I'm saying is that it can easily be an asset without being a currency, and that is OK. A government can make it not viable as a local currency, but they can't make it not be an asset.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoThis only works if all countries do it Not true. Using your example, you'd first need to convert your Francs into x-coin. If convertibility is illegal, then congratulations you just entered a black market. Which is fine if that's what you want to do, but now your risk just increased dramatically. Is that kind of risk taking scalable for a mass market? I doubt it. As to it being an asset and not a currency, there are many things that do that, but x-coin isn't that because it has the functions of a currency: Store of value, medium of exchange and unit of accounting. In your example, you're using the coin as currency to intermediate an exchange of [mansion].
- dsp1234 9y agoyou'd first need to convert your Francs into x-coin. Francs -> USD -> x-coin
- vkou 9y agoIf exchanges followed KYC, which they eventually will, then this would also not work. If you had to prove you are an American to use the USD -> x-coin pipeline, then good luck turning your Francs into x-coin. But maybe Zimbabwean exchanges don't follow KYC. That's great for you, but going Franc -> ZD -> x-coin exposes you to a lot of other problems.
- AndrewKemendo 9y ago
- thisisit 9y agoIf I may, blockchain is perfect solution for what exactly?
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI think it's a near perfect solution to the problem of recording and transferring ownership of deeds and titles.
- chinathrow 9y agoNot with the current energy consumption.
- oscilloscope 9y agoNot all blockchains need to use energy-intensive proof-of-work mining to reach consensus.
- thomasdub 9y agoDo you think the current security risks are an impediment to it being a perfect solution? I don't want my house deed transferred to someone else just because the provider that managed my wallet that held the deed to my house got compromised?
- tomc1985 9y agoWallets are not an essential component of a blockchain. Blockchains are simply a linked-list of data, with each new block of data ensuring the integrity of its previous block. That's it.
- roywiggins 9y agoIf you want to verify that a particular operation on the data was done by the person who is allowed to do it, you need some sort of public key crypto, right? If someone steals your private key, they can pretend to be you on the blockchain. Whether that private key is called a wallet or something else.
- nipponese 9y agoWhile I share your opinions re: use of power to protect national currency, I don't see how they apply to this topic. The PBoC didn't ban exchanging cryptocurrency with local "fiat", just fund raising outside of regulation via ICOs. This is the FUD that is artificially tanking the market at the moment.
- Nursie 9y ago>> The PBoC didn't ban exchanging cryptocurrency with local "fiat" http://uk.businessinsider.com/initial-coin-offering-china-bitcoin-ethereum-peoples-bank-of-china-law-all-crypto-illegal-etoro-2017-9?r=US&IR=T http://uk.businessinsider.com/initial-coin-offering-china-bi... It's possible they did.
- nipponese 9y agoI think a major contributor to FUD in this case is the translated interpretation of "financing trading platforms". In my observation, this does NOT mean mean "Yuan to BTC" exchange, but instead exchanges that are set up specifically to host ICOs, for example ICOINFO: https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=zh-CN&u=https://ico.info/ https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=zh-CN&u=http...
- Nursie 9y agoPerhaps so, I'm not an oracle on this matter, but it at least seems possible that this is wider that just banning ICOs and ICO trading platforms. I guess wait and see what happens, because even if the official statement was explicit, whether any action is taken and what action that might be is another question entirely.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI think they actually did. However, even if they didn't, the are intentionally keeping the velocity of Yuan>x-coin low to keep an eye on it. So the BoC might be saying, ok fine, buy bitcoin and then exchange it for trash-coin all you want, and if we see too many capital flows through Y>BTC we'll turn that off cause it's easier.
- olegkikin 9y agoI disagree. Bitcoin and all the alternatives beat traditional currencies hands down. • Most of them are not prone to inflation, let alone hyperinflation. • They work globally. Technically you don't even need the internet to operate - there are SMS gateways for Bitcoin, for example. • If you control your private keys, no shitty government can't stop you from using your own money (not directly at least), no shitty payment system can freeze your money on ridiculous charges. • The transmission fees for most of them are a few cents or zero. Cryptocurrencies are going to win over the traditional fiat ones only because they are a better store of value, the rest of the benefits are extra that will only accelerate this process.
- nrb 9y agoI know you specify only "most coins", but it's worth mentioning that currently Bitcoin transaction fees for a simple transaction involving only 1 input at current USD exchange rate is about $3.
- EA 9y agoWhich is great for large transactions but a shame for small transactions which are the most popular transactions in the economy.
- olegkikin 9y agoYes, I'm aware. That's exactly why Bitcoin Cash was created.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gruez 9y ago>but it's worth mentioning that currently Bitcoin transaction fees for a simple transaction involving only 1 input at current USD exchange rate is about $3. What? I was able to clear a transaction last night for less than 0.0001 BTC/KB, which works out to less than $0.25 for a typical transaction. Granted, it probably wasn't included in the next block, but it was confirmed by this morning. Based on the mempool chart (https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#24h https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#24h), it looks like most transactions with fees above 0.0001BTC/KB are included in the next block.
- Iv 9y agoNo. China has been pretty open and friendly to bitcoin so far. What they fear is Ponzi pyramid schemes damaging the economy. Several ICOs have reached a billion USD without any product and often anonymously. These can bankrupt whole areas of a country. Now is the time to stop them. Remember that their growth is exponential and one at a billion already puts it high in the history of Ponzi schemes (Ponzi himself 'only' caused around 200 millions. Madoff is the recordman with between 50 to 150 billions). Let them grow for more generations and there is a very big risk even for national economies.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoAbsolutely disagree. The amount of scamming and corruption (at least in the western perspective) in the Chinese economy is mind-boggling and they don't bat an eye at it. The CCP cares about population destabilization and independence movements above all things. Economic control starting at the provincial level up through the CCP is job 1. The CCP is very watchful over their provincial governors getting too much power and alternative currencies offer them a potential way for provinces to exploit their local power.
- Iv 9y agoScams and corruption are one thing, exponentially growing pyramid schemes are another. If you are a market regulator who don't have the resources to go after all the wrongdoings, going after the >$1B pyramid schemes are your priority. Some countries like Albania had very damaging scams that implied a sizeable percentage of their economy.
- vithlani 9y agoI don't see what is wrong with this statement? Why the down votes? It's getting to the point where people want to be willfully blind to the truth :(
- L_Rahman 9y agoIt's not just the size of the population, but also how young financial markets are in China. For the vast majority of Chinese citizens, any kind of financial product is new or at most a generation old. They don't have 1930s collapses or Madoff or Enron or 2007 collapse in their cultural DNA to build immunity against scammy speculators. As a result of this, China's markets are overwhelmingly populated by retail investors who are more vulnerable to kind of ICO schemes we're tired of seeing in HN. https://www.ft.com/content/e5af8da0-1fc7-11e5-aa5a-398b2169cf79 https://www.ft.com/content/e5af8da0-1fc7-11e5-aa5a-398b2169c...
- erikpukinskis 9y agoChina is screwed here, because you don't need any special tech to do and ICO. You can just buy a single Bitcoin, and declare each Satoshi in that Bitcoin to be one of your newly minted "KemendoCoins", redeemable at a 1 BTC/1 KemendoCoin rate in your store and all participating stores. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Colored_Coins https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Colored_Coins That cat is out of the bag. The only way to block it is by making unlocked computers illegal, and requiring people to buy all software through controlled app stores.
- mrb 9y ago"Probably the biggest lever a government has on their nation is monetary policy. There is no way that a government would allow the subversion of that." This is a simplistic and wrong analysis. Governments care about the health of their economy, and as you said monetary policy is just one of many levers to influence that. Thus, if the cryptocurrency industry can help increase their economic wealth, they will not only allow it, but encourage the development of this industry and technologies. Case in point: various laws enacted or projects created by governments encourage blockchain/cryptocurrencies innovation & use: https://www.americanbanker.com/news/delaware-blockchain-measure-seeks-to-change-very-base-of-financial-system https://www.americanbanker.com/news/delaware-blockchain-meas... https://futurism.com/ethereums-founder-struck-a-deal-with-a-russian-bank-to-create-ethereum-russia/ https://futurism.com/ethereums-founder-struck-a-deal-with-a-... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BitLicense https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BitLicense http://newmedialaw.proskauer.com/2017/04/20/arizona-passes-groundbreaking-blockchain-and-smart-contract-law-state-blockchain-laws-on-the-rise/ http://newmedialaw.proskauer.com/2017/04/20/arizona-passes-g... "So [China] went ahead and did what I have been suggesting would happen, but much earlier than I suspected." No. Your point would have been demonstrated if China had banned cryptocurrencies. However this is precisely what they did NOT do. They only banned ICOs. The Chinese government cares enormously about stability and public order. They saw plenty of ICO scams and unregulated markets causing people to lose fortunes—not good for stability and order—so they banned ICOs. China actually covets their position as a leader in Bitcoin and altcoins mining, so they are protecting their economic advantage by NOT banning cryptocurrencies. (Proving my point above.) "Blockchain is a perfect solution for many things, but as a currency it's dead on arrival IMO." Exactly the opposite. Currency, and store of value (went up 7×/19×/35× over last 12/24/48 months) are the 2 killer use cases for Bitcoin.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoGovernments care about the health of their economy Yes, so long as they are in control of it. If the Chinese people start doing significant number of transactions in x-coin and not in Yuan then they lose their largest lever of power. No. Your point would have been demonstrated if China had banned cryptocurrencies. They don't need to yet because the cryptos aren't big enough. What they did is put significant brakes on them to make sure they can manage and track the rise/growth through known intermediaries - which is exactly what they did. Banning them outright would have been too big of a move at this point and would have likely caused more instability than they wanted. China actually covets their position as a leader in Bitcoin and altcoins mining, so they are protecting their economic advantage by NOT banning cryptocurrencies. Chinese miners might, but the PnB certainly doesn't. In fact most of the big "Mines" are way outside of cities where they don't get much scrutiny. The PnB is probably looking to see if they can co-opt the situation, rather than let it run on it's own. I wouldn't put it past them to try and centralize it to make sure it falls under PnB purview - effectively having the same impact as making it parity with Yuan.